News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:21PM (#28308450)
Crypto holder here (but not a millionare). Who says government isn't the reason they haven't done something else? If there were no government, you could just "deal" with the problem person that stole your money yourself.
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by voz_ on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:23PM (#28308481)
This is the most insane take. Are you seriously saying that you want a world where people just take matters into their own hands for everything like this? A vigilante oriented eye-for-an-eye society?
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:26PM (#28308505)
If someone takes your property, you should have the agency to get it back. What do you think the government will do to you if you don't pay millions in taxes? You don't think armed agents will come (even before you are convicted)?

We live in a land of law and order. Without any law or order, or organization, your recourse is to do something similar to what the IRS does when they do not get paid.

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by salt-thrower on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:28PM (#28308518)
> We live in a land of law and order.

This is pretty rich coming from someone who's legitimately suggesting vigilante justice as a policy.

"Law and order for thee, freedom to be judge, jury and executioner for me."

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:40PM (#28308628)
No, I said without a government you could just "deal" with it yourself. I didn't say if government was good or bad. The statement here was folks were up in arms that someone was talking about going through legal process to get bitcoin back. Now you're upset that I stated that government was what was holding them back from taking non-legal options.

Tell me oh wise one, how do you get your money back if you live in a place with no government or organization and there are no legal means? Do you expect all of society is just going to get it back for you? All you'd have is yourself, and your way to deal with it.

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by salt-thrower on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:52PM (#28308736)
You're 100% correct that without a government, vigilante justice is the option that people will take.

But we don't live in that thought experiment. In our current society, let's say Joe tricked Bob into sending him all of his bitcoin.

Option A: the government recognizes crypto as property, and the government intervenes to get Bob his property back. Of course, this also means that crypto is subject to taxes and regulations.

Option B: the government does not recognize crypto as property, and does nothing because no "crime" has been committed. Bob is out of luck. But, there are no taxes or regulations on crypto, so if you don't get robbed you can get rich and evade taxes.

Option B is the logical outcome of the scenario that many crypto anarchists originally wanted for crypto. No government oversight, which means no taxes or regulations, but also means you're shit outta luck if someone robs you. That's what I was commenting on.

Maybe those crypto anarchists also want a world with no government, so they can take Option C and be their own vigilantes. But it's even more ludicrous to desire that kind of world.

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @08:00PM (#28308802)
You realize there is no requirement that crypto be subject to taxes in order to have a legal mechanism for enforcing property rights. You're of the misinformed opinion that taxation of crypto is a necessary function of government.
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by mikestew on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:38PM (#28308604)
You don't think armed agents will come...?

No, I do not, because that's not how the IRS works. Do you have evidence to the contrary? Perhaps even a single example of "armed agents" showing up to the residence or workplace of someone who has failed to pay those taxes?

your recourse is to do something similar to what the IRS does when they do not get paid.

Except that I don't have the authority to garnish wages or put liens on property. Like the IRS does.

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by sokoloff on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:49PM (#28308709)
> Perhaps even a single example of "armed agents" showing up to the residence or workplace of someone who has failed to pay those taxes?

Here ya go: https://www.nytimes.com/1998/04/30/us/3-businessmen-testify-...

“Three businessmen told the Senate Finance Committee today of Internal Revenue Service agents who, with guns drawn, broke down doors, terrified workers and forced teen-age girls to change clothes in front of male agents in raids at the men's homes and businesses that they said were unnecessary.

These aggressive paramilitary tactics were denounced as intolerable and ‘’fascist’’ by Democratic and Republican senators as the panel heard testimony for a second day in its second round of hearings on I.R.S. abuses of taxpayers.”

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:45PM (#28308686)
You don't think the agents that arrested Al Capone for tax fraud were armed?
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by nly on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:37PM (#28308590)
The world you're describing is one where the weak and poor are beaten down and killed, because they have no agency to protect their property.
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:42PM (#28308647)
Then why is anyone mad that a bitcoin holder is talking about using the legal process?

If you think bitcoin holders should be hardcore anarchists you should believe that they should live in a world with those outcomes, whatever you believe they are.

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by meowface on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:49PM (#28308712)
Yes, the point is that most people don't want such a world. With very few exceptions, even hardcore libertarians don't want that world. That's why they're arguing that some sort of court system isn't necessarily incompatible with libertarian values.

It's pointing out the issue with the "how can you consider yourself a libertarian but support people using a government system, like a judicial system, when they're wronged? isn't that hypocritical?" argument. It leads to the conclusion "if they're really true libertarians, they'd either let themselves be victims or just take justice into their own hands", and neither of those would be desirable outcomes.

The argument would make more sense if, say, the victim had gotten taxpayer-funded federal law enforcement to find and apprehend the perpetrators. But in this case they hired a private investigator, sent a request to the parents of the alleged perpetrators, and filed a lawsuit when the request wasn't responded to.

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by salt-thrower on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:22PM (#28308464)
Go ahead and say the quiet part out loud - how would someone "deal" with the problem person in the world you're describing?
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by robbedpeter on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @08:04PM (#28308832)
I'd hunt down the offender in monster trucks with flamethrowing guitars.
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:43PM (#28308665)
Apparently in your idea, if someone were forced to live in a society with no law, order, or organization they should just peacefully let themselves be parted with all they have by anyone who cares to take it.
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by salt-thrower on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:55PM (#28308775)
If all you're really saying is "without government there would be vigilante justice instead" then you're correct, but it's quite a non-sequitur in relation to the rest of the discussion in this thread.
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:50PM (#28309631)
All I'm saying is without government or any organization you are left with taking care of things yourself, rather than policeman with guns maybe taking care of the problem for you.

Let's say the government doesn't care at all about their loss (pretty common for fraud crimes in the US, I myself have been a victim of credit card fraud and no one cared even my bank who charged me anyway after I proved it was fraudulent) they actually do manage to get their property back from the person who stole it without government intervention, but they did it through direct rather than governmental action. Who cares, and what are you going to do about it? Sit back in your chair and type about the injustice of a man taking his property back without begging a policeman on his knees to consider giving the slightest care? It's nice that your moral outrage will be present but the pragmatism remains.

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by viraptor on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:42PM (#28308653)
You're skipping the other side of it, where someone else also "deals" with you as a problem. Not that you stole anything. They just can, because they have more force available and no government means they can.

Dystopian fiction is not something to strive for.

Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @07:46PM (#28308694)
And you're skipping the part where I never said it was a better system, just that it is your recourse if you live in a completely unorganized (or unjust) society.
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by viraptor on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:31PM (#28309493)
I'm not saying you presented it as better. Just that the idea is moot. If you can use vigilante justice, then everyone can do the opposite. It's just not a realistic option where you have the chance to "recover" something. The thing was never "stolen" in that world, because taking things from others is how that world would work.
Re:Man Robbed of 16 Bitcoin Sues Young Thieves’ Parents by quantumBerry on Wednesday August 25, 2021 @09:44PM (#28309584)
Property rights can exist in a world without formal government. Primates have innate understanding of fairness. The idea of ownership of something predates the system of judge and jury, modern government, and even the presence of humans [1]. If someone takes your personal property, you have the right to take it back. It needn't be recognized by some formal entity.

People can already "do the opposite." Hooded men in the middle of the night could try to take your possessions. The odds the police will show up in time is slim; at least in the US especially in rural areas your only chance is to take retaining your possessions in your own hands. Removing governmental restraint just prevents you from being convicted in court if you act directly instead of using the gun of a policeman. This is why in places like Texas is it legal to shoot someone for trespassing on your land and taking your property; some would argue that should extend to your virtual property such as bitcoin.

[1] See citations regarding primate behavior ("property in primates") in https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/214043811.pdf