http://www.theage.com.au/business/accc-seeks-unlimited-optus...
http://www.lifehacker.com.au/2011/01/dodo-busted-by-accc-for...
Optus is the second most popular ISP in Australia. Telstra is most popular and even they got slapped for having 'Unlimited' in the past (Now called Liberty plans).
Granted, it sucks to see this happen, but if transfer rates aren't also specified in the plan/advertising it's hard to argue that this represents going back on an "unlimited data" promise.
I would say yes: if you have, say, a 1MB/s line, which you keep constantly saturated, you can transfer (1 month * 1MB/s) = ~2.5TB in that month. Whether you have a data cap or throttling, it translates to such a line getting being able to transfer less than 2.5TB of data per month.
You'd say "that's absurd; it's not high speed internet. You've effectively limited my speed." They advertise _unlimited_ and _high speed_. If they throttle, then one may have a case depending on the reasonable expectations one might have about how fast (total throughput) a service labeled as "high speed" should be.
(IANAL - this is not legal advice)
I know they have footnotes in the contract, but isn't it some kind of false advertising? It's not "unlimited", it's more like "a lot", and they get to decide what a lot means.
If you're not going to really give people unlimited data, and you're going to get upset about it when people actually try using it as if it was unlimited, then how about you stop advertising it as such?