News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by ozim on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:28PM (#28238219)
That is called democracy and yes there are a lot of things that are not sold.

General public agrees that explicit material is bad.

Right now we have in Poland shops closed each Sunday - it is annoying for me. Selling alcohol in Norway is heavily restricted and I see more and more restrictions on alcohol sales in Poland.

Explicit material is tied a lot to money laundering, there is also a lot of scams tied to it and lots of stolen cards are used to pay for explicit material. It is huge cost for payment providers, all the laws for anti-laundering trump any "payment neutrality".

If you want to see naked ladies go to "a place" and risk on your own, pay with cash.

Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by toomuchtodo on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:30PM (#28238252)
Payment networks should operate according to laws and regulations, not reputation and public opinion. Would you want your electricity turned off because someone did not like who you were or what you believe? That is a road to tyranny.
Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by adamc on Thursday August 19, 2021 @04:39PM (#28239085)
I agree, but the law does have to consider the very different risk profile some customers present. As has been pointed out, adult businesses have to deal with shame and a lot of fraudulent chargebacks. The reality is that they are much more expensive to service.
Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by emodendroket on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:31PM (#28238259)
No business operates this way.
Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by kelnos on Thursday August 19, 2021 @05:00PM (#28239310)
Given that payment processors are an oligopoly, and it's incredibly difficult to build another Visa or MasterCard, they should be regulated as utilities (or at the very least, similarly to telecom providers), and be required to be content-neutral.

Just like Comcast can't tell me I can't download porn, Visa shouldn't be able to tell me I can't buy it, either.

Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by ozim on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:35PM (#28238306)
Slippery slope argument.

So you are going to run naked in the city center because public opinion about this does not match what you want.

Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by ben_w on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:58PM (#28238593)
I think you and @toomuchtodo are talking about different things.

Laws, democratic or otherwise, can indeed constrain what payment providers will allow themselves to be used for.

Public opinion short of law should not be able to add further constraints.

IMO the question of “what should Visa and MasterCard be allowed to restrict?” is the same category of question as “what category of app should Apple and Google be allowed to restrict?”

Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by InitialLastName on Thursday August 19, 2021 @05:31PM (#28239618)
> Public opinion short of law should not be able to add further constraints.

Isn't reputational feedback one of the key enablers of the free market? Unless you want to move to a system that is fully centrally planned and noncompetitive, you'll have reputational differences (read: public opinion) affecting the success of a firm. To the extent that reputation affects a firm's success, the firm will make decisions (including "do we carry this unpopular thing") based on its reputation.

Shall we require all firms to do business with all potential partners, regardless of reputational repercussions, or if the partner has an established history of abuse (say, a contractor who repeatedly under-delivers on contracts)?

Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by ben_w on Thursday August 19, 2021 @08:01PM (#28240817)
I see your point, but I was thinking specifically of the case where public opinion influences the behaviour of monopolies and duopolies. If there were e.g. a thousand payment providers each with 0.05-0.15% market shares, I’d agree with the free market and reputation approach; but as the number of important players gets smaller, public opinion becomes more like an plutocracy (because one dollar is one vote) without any of the institutional self-regulation governments develop out of necessity.
Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by postsantum on Thursday August 19, 2021 @04:40PM (#28239107)
No, this is dictated by a vocal minority of puritans, don't drag "democracy" into this
Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by bserge on Thursday August 19, 2021 @04:26PM (#28238924)
And when the general public agrees cash is bad? After all you can buy anything with digital methods nowadays. Cash is only for criminals.
Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by aaaaaaaaaaab on Thursday August 19, 2021 @03:49PM (#28238483)
>General public agrees that explicit material is bad

I don’t think that’s true when asked anonymously.

Re:OnlyFans to block sexually explicit videos starting in Oc... by pjc50 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @04:14PM (#28238780)
Which general public? This stuff varies by jurisdiction.