Re:Apple’s device surveillance plan is a threat to user priv...
by jasamer on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @07:20PM
(#28228433)
The CSAM scanning solution allows law enforcement to do one thing, assuming they have full control over the image hash database: find people who have multiple photos that are already known to law enforcement that they upload to iCloud.
How would you use this to find criminals in general? I have a hard time to think of a very useful example. Maybe photos of bomb plans downloaded somewhere from the internet that are known to be used by criminal groups?
As to what stops a pedophile or a journalist form disabling iCloud photo storage: Absolutely nothing. This solution is supposed catch people storing CSAM photos in iCloud, that's it. A careful pedophile will not be caught by this.
Apple’s new image scanning technology is almost as much of a backdoor to individuals' privacy as handing out their device decryption keys on demand. Except with this new tech, finding criminal activity is even easier for law enforcement, as Apple will attempt to locate criminals for them.
That said, there are better privacy tools available for those that need as much privacy as possible, but they are nowhere near as user-friendly as Apple's devices. For instance, if this new search tool only searches images uploaded to iCloud, as claimed, what stops a pedophile or a journalist from disabling iCloud photo storage and synchronizing photos manually? It is extra work, but not difficult. Keeping average everyday things and activities, such as web browsing history, mostly private requires more effort and expertise than manually copying photos between a phone and a computer.