News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by lqet on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:33PM (#28226724)
Regarding classic film-noir movies, I found "The Lady from Shanghai" by Orson Welles much more baffling, and also frustrating. The first time I watched it, I didn't really get the plot. As a big Orson Welles fan, I assumed it was my fault and consulted Wikipedia. The Wikipedia understanding of the plot was equivalent to mine and didn't answer any questions, so I watched it a second time, and a third time. There are massive plot holes. I really believe that Welles was not interested in a coherent plot, he just needed a vehicle for beautiful cinematography and great acting. But it is so frustrating if you try to follow a complicated plot, only to realise at the end of the movie that not even the director was able to understand it.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by WalterBright on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:50PM (#28226952)
The "Lost" miniseries is enjoyable only once you accept that it simply doesn't make any sense. Just enjoy the moments.

Though "Lost" was on to something with the dialog "it's a snowglobe!" They could have followed up on that, leading to a satisfying conclusion, but as with everything else, it just went nowhere.

Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by asdff on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:54PM (#28227000)
I'm really surprised LOST still has that reputation years after release. Having seen the entire thing, I think the plot makes sense and there aren't very many holes. The writers omit a lot early on but I felt like it gets answered by the end as you learn more about the island. In the moment as it was being released year by year I can see how it was seen as confusing when you'd wait for a while to get an explanation, but these days you could binge the entire thing.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by WalterBright on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:59PM (#28227067)
Having an "explanation" that it's all pointless magic is not an explanation.

I suspect that the writers originally had a coherent story arc, but the show was so successful they had to extend, extend, extend it, which produced the incoherence.

Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by asdff on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:18PM (#28227311)
Well, it is one of the most highly regarded series in history by critics, so some people thought the explanations were sufficient at least. Abrams and the writers were planning from the outset to do that many seasons and wrote a story bible outlining all the lore and mythology referenced throughout the writing. Having story arcs over the course of years was intentional and a novel idea at the time when most TV series plots were written on a per episode basis.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by mattmanser on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:47PM (#28227593)
Why do you think it's highly regarded by critics?

Final season's got a relatively low rating on rotten tomatoes.

It's referenced as a joke series in my circles, if you want to refer to something pointlessly convoluted with no pay-off.

Personally, I stopped at the beginning of season 3 when I realized the writers didn't have a clue where to go with the plot.

Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by dhosek on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @10:31PM (#28229691)
I made it to the end, but it was hard. Partway through, I was thinking that it would be cool to re-watch the whole series after it was done to see everything fit together but after that final season, I had zero desire to watch anything to do with the series at all.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by prawn on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @09:35PM (#28229357)
I dropped it at a similar point after working out how many hours I still had to go and asking myself if, later in life, I would view having seen it through as a good use of my time or not. It was then a very easy decision!
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by handrous on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:34PM (#28227470)
Whoa, we must follow very different critics. My impression is that it's usually referenced as a joke, or as an example of how not to do things. I'm not sure I've seen it unironically praised since back when it was still airing.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by skinnymuch on Thursday August 19, 2021 @07:20AM (#28232494)
Where do you get Lost being one of the most highly regarded series in history by critics? Besides that not being the case even if you only look at Metacritic and Rotten and only look at the basic numbers, a review from Entertainment Weekly, TV Guide, or E! are always on those sites but not worth much at all.

For the two core creators, they both have other shows that are arguably more highly regarded. Lindelof’s The Leftover’s and depending on how you feel comparing it to a mini series, The Watchmen. For JJ Abrahams, Fringe’s last 3 seasons or each season building upon the previous season are very highly regarded.

The big difference between Lost and The Leftovers and especially Fringe are that the latter two were underwatched and less hyped than Lost. Not that Lost is more highly regarded critically. It’s more highly regarded by an avg person, but that’s just pop culture fame.

The hype and credit you’re giving to Lost for outlining and having lore from the outset is over done as well. It is doubtful chat Lost stuck to much more than a loose outline by the end of the series. It felt much more like its contemporary Battlestar Galactics where it had its lore and story down early on, but lost that for various reasons after the early seasons.

On the other hand, there were shows back then too that had their lore and content planned out in advance. HBO’s Carnivale is one contemporary example coming out a year earlier that had its lore written out in detail as well.

Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by xsmasher on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @07:39PM (#28228603)
> Abrams and the writers were planning from the outset to do that many seasons and wrote a story bible outlining all the lore and mythology referenced throughout the writing.

Citation? There's a PDF floating around somewhere of the pitch for season one or the pilot; it specifically says that the SHOULD plan the mystery in advance... but then they failed to do that.

Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by WalterBright on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @07:22PM (#28228458)
> Abrams and the writers were planning from the outset to do that many seasons and wrote a story bible outlining all the lore and mythology referenced throughout the writing.

"lore and mythology referenced" is not the same as having a plot outline.

Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:52PM (#28226980)
> The “Lost” miniseries

Is this different than the Lost series of 6 seasons and 121 episodes?

Or is this just an unusual use of the prefix “mini-”?

Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by jcrawfordor on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @05:09PM (#28227195)
I've heard a joke along the lines of "I loved LOST, it's a shame they only made one season" from multiple people. Whether they allow one or two seasons of the show to actually exist in their memory depends on the person.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by WalterBright on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:56PM (#28227031)
Yes, that Lost.
Re:The Big Sleep: The most baffling film ever made? by anigbrowl on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @04:51PM (#28226956)
I don't remember enough about Welles' life and career without checking to be sure, but there's a good chance that the flaws are the result of welles' running out of money or having control of the film taken away by other producers due to his inability to meet deadlines.