News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by that_guy_iain on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @06:40AM (#28219514)
> Even one person's life inconvenienced is one too many. People working at Google: where is your conscience? If one of your family member was affected like this by a service provider who you have no control over, how would you feel?

This is an over-reaction. Someone being inconvienced is something you think should affect people's conscience? And it seems like OP could take control here and do something. They allow people to claim a knowledge panel however OP seems to only ask for things to be changed in a knowledge panel. It seems to me they provide the tools for OP to solve the issue but OP refuses to do so. I also wonder if OP choose to flag a problem or issue a legal removal request.

I doubt very much that you sit there and feel shame and contemplate how you have inconvienced others and even when you've done so in a more purposeful way.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by hnthrowaway2 on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @06:51AM (#28219577)
Yes of course. If the actions of a collective group are causing harm to others, I expect members of the collective to feel responsible. This is how we build a caring society.

If my actions have caused pain and suffering to others, whether deliberate or not, it does distress me until I have alleviated that somehow. If I do not have a way to alleviate their pain, the guilt of having inconvenienced them stays with me for a long time. That is how I stop myself from doing such things again in the future.

Do you not care?

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by tartoran on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @10:16AM (#28221207)
If Google employees, blinded by their big compensation cannot understand how this can go bad and how nearly impossible it is to navigate the cracks these algorithm are leaving behind then I agree, the google collective they're part of is causing a lot of harm and they should feel responsible.
Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by Zvez on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @06:46AM (#28219550)
but what if you don't want to be identified? Because to claim panel you most probably have to provide some evidence it is you. on the other hand, what if you don't know/don't care about some google panel about you. But other people get harmed by it? If someone really lost their job just because his photo was attached. Who should be blamed and how this person should fix this if there is no tools to remove panel? So I don't see this as overreaction. If you make something that can do mistakes that can cost someone their job or harm significantly, you should provide some ways it can be fixed fast. And not via months of talking with a wall.
[dead]
Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by HeJAnQuer on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @07:27AM (#28219788)
there is a woman getting threats and harassment, (a woman that has absolutely nothing to do with the book/panel mind you) because of the knowledge panel not working as intended, and that is fine in your eyes because the op can post a photo of herself?(when she clearly said she doesn't want it online) are you intentionally being a devil's advocate?
[dead]
Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by corpdronejuly on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @09:08AM (#28220500)
The OP choose to write and publish a book, about controversial material under their own name. That was a series of choice clearly made to manage risk while taking a stand against a cult.

Google choose to associate write an algorithm to associate names and faces with zero verification. Then google choose to not provide any substantial way to appeal the algorithms ruling.

You're trying to equate a reasonable choice to proactively manage risk with an automated system that has decided to not allow people to manage that risk. That seems unreasonable on it's face.

What am I missing about the tools provided to undo Google's knowledge panel decision?

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by that_guy_iain on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @09:38AM (#28220770)
> Google choose to associate write an algorithm to associate names and faces with zero verification. Then google choose to not provide any substantial way to appeal the algorithms ruling.

I disagree. Google allows you to take ownership of a knowledge panel and take control of the knowledge panel.

> You're trying to equate a reasonable choice to proactively manage risk with an automated system that has decided to not allow people to manage that risk. That seems unreasonable on it's face.

No, I am saying OP decided to take a risk. A calculated risk and now OP is letting others feel the negative consequences of OP's calculated risk. Even tho it seems there are multiple options available to OP to stop others feeling the negative consequences of their actions. Actions have consequences. OP took an action. This action has consequences. And now people are telling all Google employees to feel bad because a search engine behaves the way search engines do. The guess what is the info we want to see.

Let's stop worrying about OP and worry about the people who did nothing in this getting bullshit because OP is choosing not to do one of many things that would stop it from happening. You're either part of the solution or you're part of the problem.

> What am I missing about the tools provided to undo Google's knowledge panel decision?

The claim knowledge panel functionality that has been mentioned in this thread. The legal take downs instead of just reporting misinformation.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by corpdronejuly on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @11:35AM (#28222706)
> I am saying OP decided to take a risk. A calculated risk and now OP is letting others feel the negative consequences of OP's calculated risk.

You are laying blame for Googles action on OP. Google associated an innocents image with the OP, not OP. Google then demanded that OP take an action to undo Googles action, and demands that OP take new actions to undo thing they did not do.

>because a search engine behaves the way search engines do.

What utter nonsense. Some engineer somewhere did the work to create a system that autogenerated the knowledge panel. Now people are upset because Google demands that we do free labor for them to undo the mistakes of their system.

Googles obsession with being the authoritative source of knowledge and that we fix their mess is so clearly the unjustifiable behavior here that I'm baffled at how you can imagine that their practice here is reasonable.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by that_guy_iain on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @12:57PM (#28223986)
> You are laying blame for Googles action on OP. Google associated an innocents image with the OP, not OP. Google then demanded that OP take an action to undo Googles action, and demands that OP take new actions to undo thing they did not do.

No, I'm laying blame for this issue just being an issue. The problem happening, Google's fault. But if you have multiple ways of solving an issue created by someone else and you do nothing. That is then your fault. The blame for the problem existing now also lies with you.

> What utter nonsense. Some engineer somewhere did the work to create a system that autogenerated the knowledge panel. Now people are upset because Google demands that we do free labor for them to undo the mistakes of their system.

You seem completely clueless of tech works. So for a search engine to do anything someone has to do the work to create it. Now search engines allow you to search the web and return GUESSES on that information. It guesses using algorithms and for the most part work well. But they are still guesses and with guesses you get wrong guesses.

> Googles obsession with being the authoritative source of knowledge and that we fix their mess is so clearly the unjustifiable behavior here that I'm baffled at how you can imagine that their practice here is reasonable.

Umm Google's automated system guessed something. Google has 3 ways to deal with the incorrect data here! THREE! Not just one way! Not even just TWO ways. But three ways! One of those ways you control the data and YOU BECOME THE AUTHORITATIVE SOURCE.

Why you think that doing nothing about a problem when given multiple options WHILE OTHER PEOPLE ARE BEING HARRASSED BECAUSE OF WHAT YOU DID is acceptable, I have no idea.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by CRConrad on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @07:38PM (#28228590)
Used to be, you could write a book under your own name, and there was nobody who published someone else's photo claiming that person was the author of your book. Now, if you write a book under your own name, could be somebody will publish someone else's photo claiming that person is the author of your book. And you're trying to make that the fault of the author, in stead of the entity publishing the false association?!? Sheesh, man, can't you even hear how crazy that sounds?

I was going to claim you just have to be paid by Google to post this shit, but, "good faith" and all: No, you're probably doing this all on your own... Because I have faith that Google wouldn't want to be knowingly represented by ravings like yours.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by tremon on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @01:08PM (#28224191)
Google allows you to take ownership of a knowledge panel

Oh how generous. Why didn't they ask the target of the knowledge panel for permission before creating it in the first place?

OP is choosing not to do one of many things that would stop it from happening.

Why should it be on the OP to have to do anything? This is a problem entirely created by Google, for Google's benefit, which happens to cause harm to third parties.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by mellavora on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @09:49AM (#28220894)
not even a good job of blaming the victim.

OP's use of a name isn't responsible for this. It isn't the name on the book. People reading the book wouldn't have reason to think it was about a pastor in another country. And in the other direction, people looking up that pastor by name would not be immediately let to the book.

OP might not have "claimed" the 'knowledge' panel, but they certainly did work very hard to have it taken down or removed.

The harm here is pretty much entirely due to google.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by that_guy_iain on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @01:04PM (#28224115)
I knew someone would try to say I was victim blaming. OP IS NOT THE VICTIM HERE. OP's namesakes are the victims here.

> OP's use of a name isn't responsible for this. It isn't the name on the book. People reading the book wouldn't have reason to think it was about a pastor in another country. And in the other direction, people looking up that pastor by name would not be immediately let to the book.

That is indeed the name of the Author that is on the book.

I often google Authors of books I've read. And if you're a crazy person who harrasses women who write about cults and rape and other things. You would probably Google the Author's name too and see that Author and then follow the rabbit down the hole.

> OP might not have "claimed" the 'knowledge' panel, but they certainly did work very hard to have it taken down or removed.

I dunno, there is a link that says claim and they didn't follow through on it.

And I would disagree that all the harm is done by Google. In fact out of all the actors except the victims of the harrassment they seem to be the least to blame for any harm.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by CRConrad on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @07:43PM (#28228640)
> > OP might not have "claimed" the 'knowledge' panel, but they certainly did work very hard to have it taken down or removed.

> I dunno, there is a link that says claim and they didn't follow through on it.

Yeah, the GP said as much. Which is utterly logical: If you don't want something to exist in the first place, then of bloody course you don't want to own it.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by inetknght on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @10:05AM (#28221065)
> Small correction the person who was pictured who lost their job lost it for sending threats to OP. They deserve the blame.

You and Google are not (and should not be) judge, jury, or executioner. Your comment here suggests you want to be.

Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by anchpop on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @10:47AM (#28221710)
That’s ridiculous. You don’t need to believe yourself “judge jury and executioner” to say that someone who sends (death?) threats to innocent rape victims is responsible for the consequences. If you feel otherwise, fine, but if you can’t blame them for lack of being judge jury and executioner then you certainly can’t blame Google either
Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by inetknght on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @12:53PM (#28223922)
Someone who sends threats to anyone should be reported to law enforcement. Not doing so is reprehensible and encourages the anti-social behavior.
Re:Ask HN: Google is confusing me with others in a harmful w... by CRConrad on Wednesday August 18, 2021 @07:26PM (#28228487)
> Someone being inconvienced is something you think should affect people's conscience?

"Inconvienced"? "Inconvienced"?!?

People have been threatened, physically attacked, and sometimes even killed for books they've written. OP seems to be claiming to have written a fairly controversial book, which so far has generated at least threats. And now Google is associating that book with other people, because their fucking algorithm has more of a hard-on to get a picture, any picture, onto their "knowledge" card than to get shit right.

People could DIE here... And you come blithering about "inconvienced". Are you for fucking real?