Actually, HN is, as usual, doing a great job of evaluating and discussing this issue, in real time.

Judging from the threads so far, HN believes Apple is scanning everything using a naive perceptual hash implementation it probably got off of Stack Overflow, with no oversight or sanity checks, and that even a loose match (which will be trivial) means SWAT teams automatically being sent to bust down your front door like the FBI meme, and that it's all just a pretext for CCP style authoritarian surveillance anyway, and we'll all be in dissident reeducation camps by the end of the year.

I suppose it's great if you're looking for entertainment value. For rational, informed discussion of the technology and its political and social ramifications, not so much. It's just the same refrain of "we never bother to actually RTFA but we imagine a boot stomping on a human face forever."

The actual iPhone quote you're referring to was "Just avoid holding it in that way" not "you're holding it wrong" as it's often misquoted to.

Most of the commentary on this more recent issue is similarly misrepresented and inaccurate.

I think Apple's mistake here was a PR one, they shouldn't have announced this until they had e2ee ready. Then they could have announced that which would have gotten most of the (positive) press attention. Then they could have gone into details about how they were able to do it while still fighting CSAM.

This might not be a hyperimportant distinction under current circumstances but interesting nevertheless. I remember that long form.

"Just avoid holding it in [one of the most widely accepted and ergonomic grips people use for their phones]".

At the time people were showing the effect by gripping the bottom of the phone in such a way that wrapped their entire hand tightly around it.

It wasn’t “one of the most widely accepted and ergonomic grips people use”.

The entire thing was a non-scandal, it wasn’t a real issue. In a lot of ways this is similar.