News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:19PM (#2814188)
"I spoke to Airbnb about EJ’s situation. They won’t reimburse her for damages, they say, and they do not insure against losses. They are helping police track down the person who did this, but their help ends there."

...

Fuck. That.

I don't care what the long-term implications are, I don't care about precedent, I don't care about policy, I don't care about cost.

If my business does this to someone I make it right. Even if that means going into my own goddamn pocket. Anything less is simple villainy.

If you are going to enjoy the rewards of your business, you have a moral obligation to ensure that you make things right when that business harms someone else. And let us be clear: this is harm. This isn't "oh dear, my careless guest spilled wine on my TV. Buy me a new one guys."

This is "the guest you sent me destroyed my home and sense of safety." This is completely beyond the pale, an incredible stretch no one, clearly, bothered to imagine. Crucially: it's completely documented by law enforcement.

If it's true these guys aren't going to make this right, Airbnb is dead to me. Fuck Obama O's, to hell with their Cap'n McCains, and all the struggle that earned my admiration. I'd say that to their faces, I'd say that if I worked there, and I'd quit if I worked there and this wasn't made right. This is a test of human decency. I hope they don't fail it.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by oldstrangers on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:33PM (#2814276)
"This is a test of human decency. I hope they don't fail it."

Technically, they've already failed it. Now they just have to admit that they failed, and actually fix the problem (financially). If this was my company, a "worst case scenario" money chest and an itemized plan-of-action would've been the first thing I created. Investors are protected (in a number of ways) from the financial risk of investing in Airbnb (or any company); the clients should have a similar expectation of security, considering that they're creating the value for investors.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:37PM (#2814294)
> Technically, they've already failed it.

The book isn't closed on this yet. I don't know these guys personally or anything but hearing Brian Chesky talk about his company and his struggle, you can tell that these guys aren't assholes. Right now they're getting stupid, shitty, short-sighted advice from people who've convinced them to do the wrong things.

I want to believe they'll turn it around.

If they don't... well, as I said.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by prostoalex on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:52PM (#2814360)
Where do we draw the line on decency?

* Guest trashes the place, takes off with host's camera, iPod, laptop, jewelry - should AirBnb chip in for the cost?

* Guest scratches a hardwood floor that's pretty expensive to fix - should AirBnb chip in for the cost? Or just buy a rug to cover it? What if it's some Mongolian oak that's custom-ordered at $5000 per sq.ft.?

* Guest overflows the toilet, causing some floor damage and a call to plumber - should AirBnb pay for just the floor? Or cover plumber's visit?

* TV is not working on guest's departure, guest claims to never have touched it, owner says it worked perfectly before the guest arrived - should AirBnb just buy a new TV?

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:55PM (#2814370)
I'm willing to go on record as saying the line is drawn at a sociopath willfully destroying someone's home and stealing their identity.

It's pretty simple. If the user can't pre-screen and validate the guest's identity before renting, the onus is on Airbnb to ensure that they will not destroy your home.

Besides, that's the only way this company can work at scale. Without trust in the system, who will use it?

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by pak on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:38PM (#2814555)
Your reactions here are completely emotional. This is understandable, since the story is about a potentially emotional topic, but your response to it is not helpful for making a rational business decision.

Try to divorce yourself from the topic and read your reply again, realizing that you've set up an impossible standard and blanket-judged a complicated balance of liabilities as "pretty simple."

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by btilly on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @07:28PM (#2814720)
No, that is not where you draw the line. That is a random point very much on the far side of where you want the line drawn.

The problem for any organization dealing with a large volume of possible cases is that you need to figure out where to draw the line. Preferably you want it in some place that is transparent and easily communicated to people. Otherwise you'll have an endless stream of cases close to the line with arbitrary outcomes that you can't explain.

Clearly, "So and so drilled through my walls to steal my stuff" should be on the far end of the line. Clearly, "So and so stole my pencil" should be on the near side of the line. But where do you draw it in the middle? With the claim of a broken TV? With a hole in the wall?

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by prostoalex on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:59PM (#2814393)
There are databases for convicted felons and molesters, but other than that, how exactly do you ensure someone is not a "sociopath willfully destroying someone's home and stealing their identity"?

Even if AirBnb had a way to check this guy out, it's quite possible he doesn't habitually destroy homes and steal people's identities.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:25PM (#2814504)
> There are databases for convicted felons and molesters, but other than that, how exactly do you ensure someone is not a "sociopath willfully destroying someone's home and stealing their identity"?

Dunno. That's going to be Airbnb's problem to solve if they want to enjoy ongoing business. That's their job if they want to be the "Ebay of spaces."

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by romey on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @07:12PM (#2814676)
Actually, it isn't. Airbnb job isn't to guarantee the sanity of its renters to homeowners. They merely provide the interface for that interaction. I've been burned on ebay deals before (none of this magnitude, of course), but I don't place the responsibility solely on ebay for all of those -- in a few cases it was because I was trading with someone who was in another country, or had a low seller rating, etc. In situations like these, where you are putting your faith in a complete stranger, it is up to you to do your research and protect yourself. Sure, I think that there should be more on airbnb about the risks homeowners are taking on (as in, craigslist style), but to say that recognizing their limited responsibility in this incident would be "villainous" seem overly sentimental to me
Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by NathanKP on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @09:07PM (#2814961)
It is definitely possible for the host to pre-screen and validate the guest's identity. I've used AirBNB as a guest before and I was screened by hosts. They asked questions about why I was in the area, whether I smoked/drank, etc. I told them my name, allowing them to look me up on FB, Twitter, find my personal blog, etc. You'd better believe I looked up their names as well to make sure I wasn't inadvertently staying with someone who was a felon.

If your argument is based on the assumption that hosts can not screen guests then your argument is wrong.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by scythe on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:58PM (#2814387)
>Where do we draw the line on decency?

"If damage incurred through malice or gross negligence exceeds a reasonable proportion of the overall value of the establishment" where reasonable proportion might be defined as anything from 0.5% to 5%. The cool thing about legalese is how it can define a whole lot of undefinable things.

I am not a lawyer and never will be.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:57PM (#2814381)
> I don't care what the long-term implications are, I don't care about precedent, I don't care about policy, I don't care about cost.

Do you care about your company continuing to exist for more than six months?

If you ran AirBNB and paid out to this girl, you would probably be flooded with similar complaints and legal assaults.

You'd feel great about the several people you helped, but then you'd be looking for a new job.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by rokekr on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:32PM (#2814262)
>This is "the guest you sent me destroyed my home and sense of safety."

Not to mention the theft of personal documents and potential theft of identity. The (very real) potential of being bushwhacked by additional fraud years down the line due to this incident is pretty horrifying.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by patrickod on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:37PM (#2814296)
What would you have rather AirBnB done in this situation? Do you not think it's a little unreasonable that AirBnB would have to take on the role of the insurer here ?

People should know the risks they're taking in letting a complete stranger into their house without even meeting in person. Just because someone found you through AirBnB doesn't mean you can take the risk for granted. You're still letting a complete stranger have access to your house and belongings.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:45PM (#2814330)
> What would you have rather AirBnB done in this situation?

Make their user whole with a big fat wad of cash that approaches the value lost in the described crime. Relocation assistance. Go completely above and beyond.

> Do you not think it's a little unreasonable that AirBnB would have to take on the role of the insurer here ?

In general? Sure. Here? Absolutely not unreasonable. This is the absolute worst case scenario. The only way you top this is burning down a house and killing someone's dog.

Airbnb did not plan for this and did not appropriately set expectations. What they did set expectations for was "an Ebay of spaces," a safe and orderly way to monetize your home. The victim here argued very persuasively that because you can't contact people before the transaction, the onus is on Airbnb to ensure that they aren't sociopaths who will destroy your home and steal your identity.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by dredmorbius on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:06PM (#2814428)
No, the worst-case scenario would be that guest copies keys, returns, and rapes and kills the owner/occupant.

Remember: once you've allowed physical access to your resources (computer, accounts, home, ...), all bets are off with regards to future security.

AirBnB has a pretty intractable problem here.

People aren't fundamentally vettable. It's an age-old problem. TSA, the HUAC, lie detectors, loyalty oaths, pledges, blood bonds, FICO scores, PGP webs of trust, are all attempts to solve that problem.

We can identify, authenticate, predict, track, audit, and prosecute.

We can't know the future.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by adrianwaj on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:44PM (#2814583)
Worst case scenarios could come when the host is the lunatic.
Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by learc83 on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @09:47PM (#2815028)
> No, the worst-case scenario would be that guest copies keys, returns, and rapes and kills the owner/occupant.

The keys problem is fairly easy. I don't have keys. I enter a 4 digit number to enter my house. Just install something like that and change the passcode when the guest leaves.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:35PM (#2814543)
Whoa.

Good point.

Shit just got real. Thanks for creeping me out even further.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by wnight on Thursday July 28, 2011 @02:33AM (#2815655)
The risk has always been there. Have you ever seen/used a lock-pick gun? They'll open anything non-specialized in less than a second. Failing that, a lightly skilled (50h practice) lock-picker can open most household locks, even "secure" ones, in under fifteen minutes.

Beyond that, the lock/deadbolt/wall is pretty weak. A sledge hammer will open almost any door in a single blow. Windows are essentially just big gaping "serial-killer's enter here" signs, as you can easily break them and gain access to the domicile. Where, presumably you would feed on the brains and organs of the residents.

And worse, the phone company publishes a book that lists your name and address. No longer do serial killers need to drive endlessly, trying to stumble upon a Stuart or a Fred, they can just pick up a phone book and they'll find a perfect list of people, indexed by name for easier killing.

PANIC!

But seriously now, you're over-reacting here. These risks are everywhere and AirBnB was just another way to meet another person.

What I'll consider unethical is if they do anything differently for this lady, who got the media attention first, than they'd do for anyone else.

I don't necessarily think they're liable, even morally. It depends on how they represent themselves. If they purport to offer screened participants and don't, that's a problem. But if they don't it simply means they're offering a lesser service, pay accordingly.

I want a market to exist for cheap and potentially dangerous things instead of offering only padded kid-safe versions. For instance, Lithium-polymer remote-controlled vehicle batteries. Essentially the same tech as the laptop/cellphone batteries that occasionally catch fire. But they don't have protective circuitry built in to prevent this. If you overcharge them they will catch fire. But they're far cheaper and you can draw more power than if they had safeties built in. If you're clear about the trade-offs what would cause a recall and lawsuit in one market can be perfectly acceptable in another.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by dredmorbius on Thursday July 28, 2011 @06:02AM (#2816055)
Entry certainly isn't the problem.

Authorized entry is, and in the case of AirBnB you've got a case where someone's contracted for entry, may have notified neighbors / building management that strangers will be present, etc. (though "hey, strangers will be present, would you mind looking in on things might have been another good practice for EJ).

Your points on locks are very well made, and there's a long Internet (and pre-Internet) history of attempts at censorship by lockmakers against picking methods.

Phone books? How archaic. I don't have a landline -> no phone book entry. My information might be accessible elsewhere, but my perimeter security systems are quite good, and Krell steel resists mosts assaults.

Your idea of "unethical" (to say the least of good business sense) is markedly different from mine.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by wnight on Friday July 29, 2011 @06:35AM (#2821094)
> Your idea of "unethical" (to say the least of good business sense) is markedly different from mine.

I'm sure it'd be more profitable (and thus good business sense) to treat customers better based on the publicity they have. But do you really consider that ethical?

> Phone books? How archaic.

I wondered if someone would nitpick that. :)

But do you remember when lists of people's name and address were common and people weren't all chicken-little about it? I wonder if Terminator changed that with its phone-book directed killing spree.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by NathanKP on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @09:16PM (#2814980)
I really don't understand why the victim would say that it is not possible to contact people before the transaction, because as a user of AirBNB I have talked to hosts before and exchanged details about who I am, including full name, location, age, etc. The hosts had enough information to look me up on FB, find and read my blog, my HN posts, and whatever else they felt like looking up about me on the internet.

It is completely possible to vet your guests before accepting them. Now granted I do agree that it would be very kind for AirBNB to compensate her for the damages she suffered, but I do not feel like AirBNB should be held responsible as if they caused this to happen, because they certainly didn't prevent her from looking up this rogue guest before accepting the transaction.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by Cushman on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:46PM (#2814334)
It's not unreasonable, it's their business model.

Airbnb is built on smoothing over the process of renting your house to a complete stranger. If they don't have a solution or even a process for the possibility that a complete stranger will trash my house, they just lost a huge part of their value proposition.

I don't think anyone is saying Airbnb is legally liable— just that they should take responsibility for their own sake.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @10:23PM (#2815102)
> Update (from Tech Crunch): I spoke with Brian Chesky. He says the company has offered “to assist financially, find new housing for the host, and anything else she can think of to make her life easier.” He says they intend to “go above and beyond” to make the situation right for her.

Good man.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by codyrobbins on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @05:58PM (#2814390)
Give me a frigging break!

I don't care what the long-term implications are

Clearly you’re not a business person if you wouldn’t care what the long-term implications of your company’s response to this were. They have responsibilities to investors, employees, and other users—they’re (rightly) making a decision with those stakeholders in mind, not the woman who had her house ruined.

I don't care about cost

Again, clearly you’re not cut out to run a business if you don’t care about cost.

If my business does this to someone I make it right.

Airbnb didn’t do this to her. The people who did it to her did it to her. Airbnb provides a marketplace for these interactions to occur—nothing more. The users cannot abdicate their personal responsibility not to use the service carelessly. I mean, we’re talking about letting people into your home here.

Is a car manufacturer liable when a driver runs over a jaywalker because they were texting on their phone? No. Is the phone manufacturer liable? No. Should I be sued when I recommend my accountant to my friend and the accountant defrauds him? No. Should Craigslist be liable if precisely the same thing happened through Craigslist? No.

Anything less is simple villainy. This is a test of human decency.

Calling this villainy is one of the most hyperbolic statements I’ve heard in living memory. So is declaring, as if it were agreed upon fact, that Airbnb is evil if they don’t reimburse her.

If you are going to enjoy the rewards of your business, you have a moral obligation to ensure that you make things right when that business harms someone else.

If your company actually does something to somebody, then sure—but not when you’re company doesn’t. Airbnb didn’t do anything to her: she let a stranger into her house for a week without thinking about it! I’m not blaming the victim, I’m blaming the people who did it to her—but I’m certainly not blaming the middleman.

What happened to this girl sucks, but your post is overly emotional and absurd. It’s not Airbnb’s moral responsibility to do anything about this. They may choose to from a pragmatically-motivated customer relations, reputation, and corporate image standpoint—and sure, it would be an all-around charitable and nice thing to do—but I completely disagree with the claim that they have any moral responsibility to do so. Airbnb can do whatever they damn well please and what they believe is in the best interests of their business.

What I think is indecent is creating an artificially high and illogical holier-than-thou moral high ground divorced from the realities of running a $1B business that you then use to drum up a public crucifixion of a company that doesn’t live up to said standard.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:02PM (#2814408)
> Clearly you’re not a business person if you wouldn’t care what the long-term implications of your company’s response to this were.

Doing the right thing is more important than making money. I'm really glad I learned that before earning my business degree.

I'll tell you a story.

A couple of years ago, during the height of the financial crisis, I decided to quit a pretty safe job, move across the country, and focus full-time on building and selling iOS apps.

Just before the move, with cash tight, I shipped a new app.

It was doing... so well. A nice bit of press, good placement in the App Store, and revenues like no other project had yet produced.

There was just one problem: sometimes, you could enter a shitload of data into the app – and then it would crash without saving. A lot of work lost. Not all of the time, just enough to make you suspicious of the app. And as a result, a worthless tool.

The fix was very easy. Absurdly easy: one line of code. An over-released object. But Apple doesn't work quickly now and definitely didn't then. I had a choice: two weeks of selling what I knew to be a worthless app or destroy all my momentum and pull the app until the fix was ready.

So I pulled the app. Lost the high ranking that would have led to even more sales. Donated all the sales from that first day to a worthy cause, since I couldn't issue refunds. Fuck, did I need that money.

But I never looked back. Because it was the right thing to do.

You profit from creating value. If you do harm, you take responsibility and put things right. Anything less is unworthy of your humanity.

That's it. If my passion for doing the right thing makes me bad at certain things, oh well. Money comes and goes. My conscience is with me until I die.

> What happened to this girl sucks, but your post is overly emotional and absurd. It’s not Airbnb’s moral responsibility to do anything about this.

Sorry you feel that way. We'll never have common ground to work together. Good luck!

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by codyrobbins on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:13PM (#2814454)
You’re patting yourself on the back for not selling a buggy app to people? That's a completely different situation than that in the story at hand. Airbnb worked precisely like it was supposed to—there were no bugs. It’s just that Airbnb is in no way supposed to prevent things like this from happening.

If you do harm

Again, you’re not addressing the simple fact that you’re working from the assumption that Airbnb itself did harm here. They simply didn’t.

Doing the right thing is more important than making money.

Clearly Airbnb does not believe that doing so would be ‘doing the right thing.’ You’re simply calling them evil instead of recognizing that they have a different—and quite defensible—point of view concerning their responsibility.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:30PM (#2814519)
> there were no bugs.

The utter destruction of your home at the hands of a service that aims to help you monetize it is ipso facto a bug. Intent: create value. Result: destruction of value. Bug! It would be like a roach trap that helped roaches breed instead of killing them.

It's pretty simple. You can't talk to guests until the transaction is consummated. If that's so, it's on Airbnb to make sure that they're not sending a dangerous creep into your arms.

They failed in that task. If they want to be the "Ebay of spaces" then they need to provide for some basic level of safety and security.

It's okay that you and I have different value systems. They're incompatible, so we won't ever work together.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by codyrobbins on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:40PM (#2814564)
The utter destruction of your home at the hands of a service that aims to help you monetize it is ipso facto a bug.

Again, Airbnb didn’t destroy her home. Are you under the impression that someone from Airbnb itself was the one staying at her house?

Intent: create value. Result: destruction of value. Bug!

You’re basically defining what you want the responsibilities of Airbnb’s service to be and then faulting them according to those responsibilities. But those are not Airbnb’s responsibilities. Again, Airbnb doesn’t claim to prevent things like this, therefore it’s not a bug.

If they want to be the "Ebay of spaces" then they need to provide for some basic level of safety and security

No they don’t. There will be business consequences for not doing so, but they don’t have to. They can define their service to be whatever they want it to be. As it currently stands, their service is not meant to prevent this from happening.

They're incompatible, so we won't ever work together.

This came through loud and clear the first time you patronizingly said it.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by danilocampos on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:42PM (#2814576)
Conveniently, you fail to address the point upon which this whole issue is predicated:

"You can't talk to guests until the transaction is consummated. If that's so, it's on Airbnb to make sure that they're not sending a dangerous creep into your arms."

No one thinks anyone from Airbnb blew up her home, dude. I'm not paid well enough to know if this meets the standard of tortious negligence. Yet it was negligence. Had she not used the service, she'd be fine now.

And, I mean, if you've got such a boner for the business side of this, in what universe can you trust a service like Airbnb now? You can't vet people until you're locked in, you have no recourse if you get screwed. This is a business problem, without the morality of hey, it's a good idea not to bring harm into people's lives.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by codyrobbins on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @06:49PM (#2814599)
Well, you haven’t addressed any of my points, but that’s fine. To answer your question, just because the transaction was consummated doesn’t mean she had to let the guy into her house. If the dude was suspicious or ungoogleable, she could have called Airbnb and explained the situation or she could have simply not left her key. Instead she just got on an airplane without thinking about it. That’s not Airbnb’s fault.

And you’ve just illustrated my point perfectly: if she hadn’t used the service, she would be fine now. But she used the service of her own volition; nobody forced her to; and she made the decision herself. Airbnb might have made the gun the guys used to trash her apartment with, but Airbnb isn’t the one that fired it: she pulled the trigger. Again, the people who trashed her apartment committed the crime here, though.

This is a business problem

I never said it wasn’t a business problem—that’s exactly what it is. But it’s not an issue of morality.

in what universe can you trust a service like Airbnb now?

I would never in a million years use Airbnb. Why would I leave a complete stranger alone in my house so that they could trash it and go through my things? You realize how insane that is, when evaluated outside the reality distortion field of the startup craze we’re in right now, right?

I think the genesis for your arguments is your desire to live in a world where you can trust a service like Airbnb. But if you just think about it for five seconds you realize anyone could do this and Airbnb in no way prevents it from happening. Just because Y Combinator funded it doesn’t mean it’s magical.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by jcc80 on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @09:44PM (#2815021)
"Just because Y Combinator funded it doesn’t mean it’s magical."

It doesn't? jk. But seriously, if you mention airbnb to an average person, say anyone in my family on the east coast they haven't heard of it. So, airbnb isn't even big enough to have the problems craigslist has had with scams...but, this is just the start.

Once airbnb gets bigger there will be more of these stories. Someone will build up a rating by renting a few low priced places and then just completely rob a more expensive place.

I guess they should have seen this coming but now it's time to accept they are getting big enough where the common criminal will look to exploit the service. "You mean I just rent a few places and then some rich person will give me the keys to their place and I can take whatever I want? Awesome!"

I mean it's terrible, but I think we can all imagine it's possible someone using airbnb to rent a room in their home getting killed by the renter.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by CamperBob on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @10:04PM (#2815069)
I think you're both right. Like most major crises, this one occurred as a result of not one "bug," but two or more bugs occurring simultaneously.

The first "bug" arises from the fact that AirBnB is much like a pay-for-play dating service, with all of the flaws of that business model. They have to control communication between the parties to keep from being cut out of the revenue loop... which means that they indisputably need to accept some responsibility for conducting the due diligence that they forbid their users to conduct. That's expensive and risky at best, but if they don't step up to the responsibility -- which they don't -- then they don't deserve to succeed. A stolen credit card should not be enough to gain access to someone's home for a week. Cases like this provide the necessary publicity to call attention to the unfair bargain they offer hosts.

The second 'bug' was the almost unbelievable naivete on the part of the host. She was, or should have been, aware of the terms of AirBnB's service and the limitations of their liability, because she would have had to agree to those terms and limitations when she signed up. It shouldn't take a law degree to understand that AirBnB's terms are ridiculously inadequate when situations like this arise. The idea of turning over the keys to your home to someone you've never met, based on the inadequate assurances and warranties offered by AirBnB, sinks to the level of incompetence IMHO. Not everyone will agree, but come on... if what she did isn't "asking for it," then there's no such thing as "asking for it."

To me, it seems clear that the responsibility for allowing this incident to happen falls on the host's shoulders... but at the same time, AirBnB should not be lauded for trying to play it both ways. If they're going to do everything they can to prevent hosts and renters from doing ordinary due diligence on each other, then they also need to stand behind their decisionmaking process when they approve a renter. I think a mandatory insurance policy has got to be part of the answer, just as common sense on the host's part is also a requirement.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by codyrobbins on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @11:17PM (#2815228)
This. I definitely think this entire situation calls into question the feasibility of Airbnb’s continued success and their business model in general. They’ll need to find some way to address these problems to maintain confidence in the site, and as the site’s audience grows it may not even be possible to do so.

I don’t dispute any of these things—my only real point was that it’s completely off-base to call Airbnb immoral for not compensating the woman.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by CamperBob on Thursday July 28, 2011 @12:43AM (#2815416)
Yeah, I don't think they owe her anything, given that they never misrepresented their terms. But I also agree with those who argue that they should help her out as a gesture of goodwill. Sounds like they're indeed doing that.
Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by friendstock on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @07:50PM (#2814774)
Actually, I've used AirBNB multiple times -- hosts CAN talk to the guests... but it's done through the AirBNB messaging system which actively removes real identifiers such as email addresses and phone numbers.
Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by NathanKP on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @09:03PM (#2814947)
I can back this up. I've used AirBNB before as well, and good hosts generally ask for some details about you before they approve your request to stay in their home. They generally ask a few background questions, why you are visiting the area, etc.

You can tell them your name, and they can look you up on FB if need be to do a background check. It is false to say that AirBNB does not allow hosts to communicate with guests, and it is fully possible for hosts to check up on the background of their guests.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by veyron on Thursday July 28, 2011 @12:44AM (#2815420)
"You profit from creating value."

I really wish more people, especially SV-esque startup people, approached business this way.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by chailatte on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @07:20PM (#2814698)
Personally I don't know why people get a hard-on about the story of Airbnb.

So they sold a fad product (cereal) at the right time to make a little bit of money. Just tells me they have no moral integrity (which explains the craigslist email spamming).

So they struggled to make rent in SF a while. Who told them to stay in an expensive city with no savings? That's bad financial planning, and they could've bootstrapped their startup in Austin.

Oh, and they made a startup that is illegal in many parts of US, and manage to dupe investors to give them hundreds of millions. Now they won't even help a girl whose life they help tear to shreds.

Sounds like upstanding fellows to me.

Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by NathanKP on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @09:11PM (#2814971)
I really don't understand why people are laying blame on AirBNB for what happened to her. AirBNB did not help the criminal destroy her home. On what basis do you make the statement that they helped "tear her life to shreds."? The fact that they helped her list her home and conduct business with this individual? That is like blaming the ISP for allowing a DDOS or a malicious blackhat attack on a server.
Re:The Moment Of Truth For Airbnb As User’s Home Is Utterly ... by kyro on Wednesday July 27, 2011 @08:06PM (#2814817)
I'm sure they wouldn't employ someone who reacts in such a hot-headed manner so quickly. Keep in mind this is the first time this has happened to them, that they've probably never been placed in this sort of situation before, that they most likely exercised a bit of intelligence and consulted a handful of advisers, and that they are trying to take the wisest steps in handling this.

I doubt they're that soulless and cold-hearted; and if you'd just waited a bit, you would've caught Brian's response explaining how he plans on helping her out financially.

You're the one failing on human decency due to your inability to exercise even a shroud of empathy for these guys. They're trying to play it smart while still doing what they can to help.