Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state
by systemvoltage on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:28AM
(#28143179)
Fundamentally disagree. Locking citizens in their own homes nationwide is terrible precedence for “balance of rights”. If that’s what “balance of rights” looks like then I have a history book to sell you.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state
by scohesc on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:59AM
(#28143698)
Balance of rights means nobody has rights.
If you need to "balance" the rights (read: take them away) of somebody to equal the scale, then rights don't exist in the first place.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state
by II2II on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:46PM
(#28149685)
I am trying to figure out whether you are arguing that rights must be absolute or that rights do not exist. If it is the former, I will point out that the rights of one person can infringe upon the rights of other people or the rights of one person can be used to repress other people. Simply put, rights are never absolute. In the latter case, I will simply point out that rights are a social construct. As a social construct, they very much exist yet society will be in an eternal struggle to define what rights are.
Police investigative powers are an example of this balancing of rights. They need investigative powers to enforce the laws which protect our freedoms. The flip side is that investigative powers can easily be twisted to become surveillance, then be used to take away our freedoms. I don't know what the solution to this conflict is. I don't think anyone knows, which is why the state automatically seeks overreaching powers and the opposition seeks prohibition rather than offering solutions.