Yes.
When I was 15, I had nudes of a 17 year old. Age of consent is 16 in the UK but sexual images of people under 18 is illegal.
Having that content was illegal; and I have the criminal record to prove it.
Did you have those nudes with the consent & permission of the 17 year old in question?
Is there more to this story than you are letting on?
It's bonkers. But it happens. Unfortunately all of this has become something of a taboo, but teenagers having sex is ... kind of normal. What exactly is and isn't acceptable is very hard to decide as a general matter, and far too often any conversation is shot down with "pedophile apologist!" or, in this case, baseless "you must have done something wrong!" assumptions.
In some countries, you can have sex at 14, but only do sexting at 18. Total mindfuck.
Laws are far from being logical or always making sense.
Find enough innocent to change the jurisprudence, but I d bet that you can find so many more quilty parties that the law had to go one way.
Now I have a daughter and I was 16 before mobile phone existed. I m thinking what I would do if I see her sexting: probably nothing after 16 and a soft warning between 14 and 16 and a very strict one before, just because consent can only exist with maturity. Now if the guy is 30 and she s 16, I d tell her she s being an idiot sending him anything: it's not like he cares about her as a person, most likely and she s going to suffer under my responsibility or at best put him in danger. But, 16, starts to be her choice to listen or not and difficult for me to enforce anything.
Glad she s still 3 :D
I actually think that there were other EU countries that had even lower age limits than Germany.
Someone under 18 could have sex with someone over 14 (but also still under 18).
As soon as one of them is older than 18 it becomes child molesting, and the grown up is in serous trouble.
The law makes not sense of course. It was a more or less recent change. The old regulation may seem bizarre given that example of the parent, but it was more close to reality in most cases.
Before that a 18 year old was not in trouble when sleeping in consent with a slightly younger friend (which is a common situation in reality). Now you would automatically get prosecuted as child molester if authorities would find out; no matter a relationship and consent!
That's the outcome of the CP witch-hunt in Germany… Quite normal things are now outlawed and can ruin lives of young lovers quite substantially.
It's somewhat related to determining whether the child was capable of "sexual self-determination". But typically the abuser will only get punished if both the child and its parents file a legal complaint(at least that's what the law says).
I'm going to leave my opinions on this at the front door, but given how easily this law can be abused it's almost comical how often the german government has used the excuse of "think of the children" when they passed mass surveillance laws.
By the way as others have pointed out while the 14 and 17 year old can have sex legally, sending any kind of nudes actually triggers another law that may lead to imprisonment[1]. Making any kind of "pornographical" material available to children under 18 is a felony. Who would have known that the porn my classmate shared in highschool on VCR, if shared on an iPhone nowadays could have led to him being sent to the juvenile detention center.
[0] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schutzalter#Schutzalter_14_Jah...
The other child posts are correct, I'm wrong.
My confusion comes mostly form a not realized, but once planed change in this laws.
In the end the current legislation seems quite sane.
But this can't be said about the laws governing messaging intimate content between teens. That's the other source of my confusion.
Anyway, thanks to bmn__ and rjzzleep for pointing out my error!
Can you look first into Wikipedia, online law publication to verify before spreading misinformation?
You are morally obligated to edit your post and correct it with the true facts.
No, but he would be. She would merely be in possession of it.
For the record, Denmark has, indeed, punished a large number of underage offenders for spreading child pornography through social media. It's mostly been regarding clips spread without the participants' consent though.
Not sure whether other countries go by the age of sexual consent, but I've personally never heard any other definition of child porn than "sexually explicit/suggestive content involving people under the age of 18". Assuming that's valid everywhere, then it would indeed be child pornography since the Dane was under 18.
EU-wide harmonization of such laws would be a welcome step to take before privacy-invading measures were to be taken, and such legislation definitely should address underage sexting.
It depends on what country they are, right now.
Age of consent in both France and Denmark is 15.
For example in many countries age of consent threshold is not enforceable if both are minors and the age difference is at most 4 years.
A 15 years old sending nudes to a 17 years old girl would not be punished as CP.
Police was riding schools for stuff like that already after teens used monitored channels (like "private" social-media messages) to exchange such pictures.
> is not enforceable if both are minors
15 and 18 are __not__ both minors
Now even minors can get prosecuted for CP. I should have mentioned this explicitly in addition.
https://www.heise.de/news/Kinderpornografie-Immer-mehr-Ermit...
https://www.heise.de/news/Kinderpornografie-Kinder-und-Jugen...
> Twenty years ago it was assumed that no one would inadvertently own child pornography.
> As soon as a 13-year-old sends a pornographic medium of herself and it ends up in a class chat in some form, every member of this chat can be liable to prosecution.
Unless I am missing something, It doesn't refer to two minors sending each other pictures, even though I agree that the scale the phenomenon has assumed in the past 20 years is somewhat scary.
Teachers are for example required to report cases in class.
But the same laws apply of course to any such content minors create and send to each other. Only that it doesn't get reported in any case (until now e2e encrypted chat is completely private for example; Apple is working on changing that though).
But there are cases where things got reported to authorities by social media companies, when kids used unencrypted messaging for example. Where else all that giant numbers of child porn on social media come form? Form a few cases before all the new laws to thousands of cases now?
No real pedo would exchange such material in the open as it's commonly known that those companies are scanning for it. That's mostly children not aware that they don't communicate really privately!
With the new law in place the numbers of such cases will skyrocket likely. As now it's going to be mandatory to scan for such content and directly report it to the authorities.
They can than say, "look, the amount of child pornography cases on the internet is skyrocketing. We need more online surveillance to fight this epidemic! To do that effectively we finally also need to solve the encryption problem"…
This game has been going on for quite some time now. The goal is also clear: More surveillance. This new law now is just the next step on a long journey. CP (besides "terrorism") is the vehicle to sell things to the people. It's always "terrorism" or child porn when they want to cut down the next civil rights…
But this specific law is simply asking tech giants to comply, it is not over reaching, like the Apple new features that creates perceptual hashes on people's phones and than upload them to Apple servers, potentially forever.
Some control over content was to be expected, but until the EU mandates that every cloud provider should look for something controversial (political affiliation, controversial opinions etc. etc.) they can't be enforced and they can't be collected by companies operating in Europe or on European citizens' data.
It's a big difference IMO.
Sexual assault is one thing, but it's worth taking a minute to realize how arbitrary and ridiculous some of these laws are before you start throwing children into jail for texting... let alone stripping away basic civil liberties on the basis of "some people are bad so we can't have nice things."