2 is actually a very interesting idea. I know that among my friends some are interested in different types of startups(music, video, commerce, social networking, etc.). Finding people who want to start a company in the same space would probably be helpful.
I'm surprised by the response to JustHackIt. Already, in 1 hour the site's gotten over 400 unique visitors. Mostly from HN but also coming from Reddit now too.
I don't think JustHackIt will take off, but I do think that if a version of this idea was integrated into HN it could help a lot of people. I'm sure the rockstars here don't need this, but the average startup-rookie on this site could find it helpful.
I guess a further elaboration on the whole YC meets LinkedIn/matchmaker concept would be that it places the people (and their 'compatibility') ahead of the startup idea, which is also what VCs and YC (I think) place priority on.
Why? Why don't you make JustHackIt your startup, or at least your muse? With some Google ads it could be, at least, self-sustainable.
Are you looking for a cofounder ;-)
You might want to borrow some ideas from speed geeking: http://facilitation.aspirationtech.org/index.php/Facilitatio...
1) Why have a separate search field for 'city' and a pull down for geography? I didn't even see the geography pull down the first time I visited.
2) Signing in to search the site is kind of lame. This encourages people to create an incomplete profile just to try things out. Which leads to ....
3) They don't force you to fill in a complete set of data. This is not the end of the world, but as someone looking for a co-founder, I would most likely skip over incomplete profiles. Perhaps this consequence could be explained as the user fills out their profile.
Edit: First impressions are not great, but now that I've logged into the site, I'm impressed. I still think their questions could benefit from a bit of lateral thinking.
Instead of listing job skills, why not have the user answer more personal questions (like, 'why are you a software animal'? or 'What have you built that you are really proud of?') A list of skills does not provide enough insight.
Offline the two main methods are:
- friend set-ups/ Family
- Dating (I think this is what this site does)
Edit: I guess if you just want to do a project to see how things work out with someone, that could be a smart way of getting started; I just wouldn't place much pressure or importance on the project.
BTW, Breck didn't write this post. It was me.
LinkedIn for Mac hackers
1) Although being too secretive about a project isn't usually a good thing, I don't really want to plaster my idea on a site, either.
2) I think another (more controversial) approach to solving the 'co-founder problem' would be to create a database of users populated with answers to questions similar to the YC application form. So, one could filter based on interest level, availability, proximity, etc. Real names would be optional (news.yc user names could be used instead). Think YCombinator meets LinkedIn.
The more I write about 2), the more I like it. If I weren't working on another project, I'd implement this myself. In any case, contact me if you want more ideas (see my profile).