But that said, I've often times wondered if this requirement of having to "rewrite in your own words" may do a lot of harm too. It obfuscates that things that people are talking about are actually exactly the same, or make it fuzzy what the exact differences are.
In a particular academic CS area I've witnessed people reproduce again and again the essentially identical description of setting and assumptions, but in being afraid of plagiarism accusations, they over and over re-formulate things which made it nonobvious that things are the same as from other authors or even from their own earlier work.
1. authors submit a paper with expository sections about (eg) some materials being flammable and others inflammable
2. reviewer tries to explain that they have incorrectly understood the meaning of the terms, explains the meaning carefully and maybe suggests the terms they might mean.
3. Authors copy in the explanation and maybe replace incorrect usages with weird tortured phrases
4. Rejection
Obviously this description reads a little bit silly and things were probably more nuanced in practice. I think Iām probably also being uncharitable towards the authors in the example.
In the absence of an explicit directive or request from you, given that the authors are from a different culture, how do you expect them to know what was required by them?
I don't mean to be snarky or accusative. Your comment was thoughtful, articulate and detailed, which tells me you are a sophisticated communicator.