ASHRAE 62.1 and 62.2, "Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality":
* https://www.ashrae.org/technical-resources/bookstore/standar...
> The answer is normally a complex HVAC system but that then uses power and requires maintenance.
> older buildings are drafty but it comes with health benefits and keeps the building dry by allowing moisture to escape.
Drafty buildings are bad. The air comes in through random cracks and crevices, which may have mold and which also allow bugs and rodents to enter. The rodents may leave droppings, which the flowing draft may then pick up particles from. There are no health benefits to that.
> The answer is normally a complex HVAC system but that then uses power and requires maintenance.
The drafty house you laud above will also use power: in the winter air that was heated will leak out, and the cold air that comes in will have to be brought up to temperature; in the summer the cooled air will escape and the hot (and perhaps humid) air will then need to dealt with to make the building comfortable. And that doesn't include dealing things in the air like dust and pollen (plus the above mentioned critters).
Or you can install some ducting to remove stale air from the house (esp. bathrooms and kitchens), and introduce fresh air (esp. to bedrooms) that is first filtered (MERV 13+) and then tempered via an ERV/HRV core so there's a minimum of re-conditioning needed. The main source of maintenance is the changing of the filter(s). And running an ERV/HRV will use less energy (W or BTU) than re-conditioning the leaky air.
This is a solved problem: build tight, ventilate right.
After air tightness throw on some insulation (while reducing thermal bridging) and you can have a house that uses minimal energy in dealing with environmentals. You just have to make the effort up-front when designing it (or when doing a renovation/retrofit).
* https://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/article/understanding-f...
* http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ijerph120708448
* https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Mean-PM-25-removal-effic...
Just make sure your system can handle whatever MERV you go with (higher = more back pressure that needs to be designed for).
* https://www.zehnderamerica.com/our_products/comfowell-silenc...
Which allow MERV 16 and even carbon filters:
* https://www.zehnderamerica.com/product-category/comfowell/
Mandating (whole house) dehumidifiers in building codes may help with that if air tightness is also mandated.
https://www.kane.co.uk/knowledge-centre/what-are-safe-levels...
I’m horrified to think of all the poor people in these programs that are probably feeling bad but have slightly better energy bills. Good health is the most important quality we have. There need to be energy conserving air exchangers put in with each tight house made. That’s the best of both worlds.
Airborne contagions do not spread from bringing in outside air and tempering it via an HRV/ERV. The risks rise when you do not bring in fresh air but rather recirculate indoor air, but these can be reduced by using MERV 13+ filters:
E.g. a cheap addition to existing installations: aircode.se
Limited but sane research from around 2013(?) points to even cheaper options of ventilation treatment.
How much energy is used to build and maintain the building.
Can the building function as a building people want to use - if just sits empty its a huge waste of energy. Removing all the windows would help but wouldn't be very appealing.
And lastly ventilation is probably of of the most tricky, it's very easy to create an energy efficient sealed box, but how do you create a healthy environment - older buildings are drafty but it comes with health benefits and keeps the building dry by allowing moisture to escape. The answer is normally a complex HVAC system but that then uses power and requires maintenance.