News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by newbamboo on Saturday August 07, 2021 @10:50AM (#28098990)
“ Columbia were typically borrowing $181,000 apiece before entering a job market that pays less than $30,000”

The sickening part is hearing people not only defend this, but to attack and defame the good people who are speaking truth to power on this. It’s David and Goliath and the usual suspects, wealthy elite, attack David for trying to warn youngsters who will destroy their lives by taking on a debt burden that guarantees a lifetime of wage slavery. No honorable person can defend this.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by mc32 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:07AM (#28099097)
And then people wonder why people get angry and want to burn the system down. This is the fault of universities not setting the right expectations. Drive students to where demand will be not fields with artificial cachet that have little return on investment.

These kids then sulk and bemoan society while they work at a coffee dhop that affords them higher pay than the degree they studied for affords them.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by MattGaiser on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:10AM (#28099121)
Are students really being driven to film or are there just enough people who want to be in film that they will do and try anything to succeed in it, no matter what it costs?

I have a really hard time believing Columbia made a credible argument that you can make a good salary in film.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by mc32 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:14AM (#28099150)
The loans for low demand majors should not be guaranteed and those students should be allowed to default.

Majors in high demand and good with prospects can have guarantees. These can be re-evaluated periodically to adjust to demand.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by lumost on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:33AM (#28099342)
This would likely just lead to oversupply of in demand fields and schools creating shoddy majors.

If everyone with a psych major switched to comp sci tomorrow one of two things would happen.

1) we’d have more engineers than we’d know what to do with - wages would collapse and companies would stop trying to conserve engineering time. Innovation would slow and we’d head back towards the days of J2EE etc.

2) universities would create fake versions of the majors that are guaranteed, but easy to pass and unlikely to lead to employment.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by mc32 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:36AM (#28099379)
Presumably as CS or engineering oversupplied the market, loan guarantees would be removed and other majors in higher would get a boost instead.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by lumost on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:38AM (#28099390)
Oversupply affects the current marginal negotiation power of employees. By the time loan guarantees are removed there can be massive gluts of workers who are locked into loans they can’t repay.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by mc32 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:45AM (#28099461)
It couldn’t be worse than what we have now with kids going into dead end degrees and coming out loaded with debt that they can’t unload.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by newbamboo on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:19AM (#28099202)
Put more simply, loans should not be given out when there is a low chance they can be repayed. The term is “loan shark”. That this disproportionally enslaves minority and first generation college students makes it all the more outrageous.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by lumost on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:18AM (#28099190)
The universities go out of their way to give this impression by presenting “success cases” and misleading statistics.

Many of these students would rationally believe that studying “film” would lead to a shot in the film industry.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by itronitron on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:29AM (#28099302)
I highly recommend this video, where CaptainSparklez (one of the YT millionaires) discusses his decision to turn down an offer to pay 70K a year to get a CS degree in gaming (starts at the 15 minute mark).

https://youtu.be/TexLwzN_PiU

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by ipaddr on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:37AM (#28099383)
They never mention salary just the educational genres you could be studying. The way it is written I wouldn't think it was geared to studying hollywood movies nevermind a career.

https://arts.columbia.edu/programs-study/ma-film-and-media-s...

It does say: A few Teaching Assistantships are available. Student Service positions employ students as Programming Assistants and Research Assistants.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by ampdepolymerase on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:25AM (#28099258)
Academia is not elastic, many universities have limited spots for the in-demand classes like CS. For medicine, residencies are the limiting factor. Academia in general refuses to scale and be responsive to market demands.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by MattGaiser on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:50AM (#28099506)
Given what academia pays, I imagine that instruction jobs are hard to fill in CS.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by baron816 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:14AM (#28099157)
The average medical student graduates with >$200k in debt, with medical residents earning an average of about $60k. But med student debt isn’t a problem because doctors earn much much more after completing their residency.

The article says “entering a job market that pays less than $30,000.” That doesn’t mean that masters holders earn that on average, or that that’s what they’ll be earning mid career.

Not to say that masters degrees aren’t a scam, nor that the article is being intentionally deceiving. But my guess is that it’s not quite as life destroying as it appears.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by lazide on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:24AM (#28099243)
In many cases it’s disingenuous to argue that everyone will be in the same place as a medical student?

I know someone who spent similar amounts on a UX masters degree, and almost decade later was only finally hitting 100k/yr - in the SF Bay Area. Which cost of living/free cash flow perspective is probably even worse than your $60k/yr med student.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by baron816 on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:31AM (#28099325)
I’m not. What I’m saying is that you can’t compare someone’s debt level to their expected earnings one or two years out. It still entirely possible that masters degrees are a very bad deal, but the figures they show don’t fairly demonstrate that.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by legitster on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:18AM (#28099191)
This is for a master's program in filmmaking at Columbia. For the most part we are talking about children of the elite and privileged being taken advantage of here.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by ashtonkem on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:20AM (#28099214)
If you’ve got that kind of money to burn on sending your kids there for funsies, is it even “being taken advantage of”?
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by havelhovel on Saturday August 07, 2021 @12:08PM (#28099657)
A degree from an "elite" school costs about the same as an expensive luxury watch or car, and I'm sure that many applicants see such a degree as a prestige symbol that defies utilitarian value. Just because the author doesn't see the logic doesn't mean that there isn't any there, or that anyone is being swindled.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by cubano on Saturday August 07, 2021 @12:24PM (#28099776)
Are you saying that a luxury watch costs the same as a luxury car?

If that is true (which I find incredibly hard to believe) it literally makes no sense. The utility and the ability of a car to give you a ROI compared to a watch is almost infinitely more.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by havelhovel on Saturday August 07, 2021 @01:10PM (#28100137)
While the entry price for luxury watches is lower than it is for luxury cars, I see a fair amount of Pateks and APs that go for at least $100,000. There are many more exclusive models and companies that I know next to nothing about that are significantly more expensive, but you can get a sense of the wider market here: https://www.hodinkee.com/packages/all-the-new-watches-of-202.... And yes, I agree that the utility of a car far outweighs that of a mechanical watch. It's also why I believe that paying $150,000 for a fancy master's degree at a world-famous school is a pretty sweet deal for the wealthy and vain.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by ashtonkem on Sunday August 08, 2021 @11:37AM (#28107478)
To be fair, a $150,000 watch can be re sold. High end watches hold their value incredibly well, and in some cases can even appreciate in value. Even luxury cars, which typically depreciate quite quickly, can be re-sold for a significant portion of their purchase price.

The same cannot be said of a $150,000 education, which cannot be re-sold. Perhaps in some cases a high value education can be turned into a higher value career, but that’s obviously not relevant to the hypothetical rich kid getting a film degree at Columbia.

Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by SAI_Peregrinus on Saturday August 07, 2021 @01:39PM (#28100356)
Try a search for Patek Philippe watches. Some of the used ones are under $10k, but new ones go into the millions.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by ashtonkem on Saturday August 07, 2021 @05:32PM (#28102032)
Depends what watches you’re talking about. For some brands $50k is the basic model.
Re:The Great Master’s-Degree Swindle by legitster on Saturday August 07, 2021 @11:22AM (#28099229)
Exactly. My point was this group is very willingly exploiting themselves.