I've been on there for more than 6 years [1] and it really is an example of a well targeted niche web app.
-----
However, it is a hugely popular game, and I'd love to know why.
Typically, there'll only be one or two really good spots (say, 8-10-5 or something). The players on those spots will/should get a disproportionate share of the baron, both because they have more cards and because they're in the lead and need to be dragged down to everyone else's level.
The game then becomes an issue of trying to get good without appearing so and picking the right time to make your move, rather than 'I have x points/regions, therefore I win'.
Sounds pretty similar to the Monopoly rules, now that I think about it...
The imperfect information in Monopoly is what you're thinking in your head. I've traded things with two or three other trades in mind that the other person couldn't have known I was going after. Or, traded someone a Monopoly they thought was a good deal, then sold my hotels to use up the remaining houses so they can't develop it.
And, there is ABSOLUTELY a strategy shift for the opening and endgame. Don't believe me? Try to develop the Green monopoly first.
+1 for those who recommended Settlers. Ticket to Ride is also fun, and Diplomacy does not have to destroy friendships. (Anyone willing to devote 5-7 hours to a game is a friend forever, no matter how long I remember that time they switched sides without warning and wiped me out.)
http://www.criticalmiss.com/issue10/CampaignRealMonopoly1.ht...
There's plenty of imperfect information - I don't think you're required to reveal how much money is in your hand at any point, much less how much you'll pay for a particular property, and thus plenty of opportunity for richer players to screw poorer ones out of the property that they've landed on.
Fun fact: Xbox 360 version has "equalized dice" setting (don't remember the actual name) which makes dice less random so it would have better histogram. This setting removes some frustration from the game, like you settling on two sixes but getting only eights benefiting the enemy, but obviously makes "lucky wins" less likely for you as well.
I've played regular board-game Catan about 10 times, and every single time either 6 or 8 has come up way less than it "should". It's been roughly equal whether it's helped or hurt me, but it really takes some of the enjoyment out of the game when people fight for those spots, only to have them be worthless.
Shuffle, turn face down and turn the top one over instead of rolling the die.
I often play Neuroshima Hex on my iPhone, it's great.
Games are about decision making, and there is very little decision making to be had in Monopoly (Real or not). There is no strategy shift for the opening, midgame, or endgame. There's no secret scoring or clever traps, there's no imperfect information of any kind. Assuming dice rolls are the same, playing against yourself and playing against another person or playing against a computer will have pretty much identical outcomes.
In other words, if you want to play Real Monopoly with me, just go ahead and play against yourself and do the rational thing for me if a decision comes up. Let me know if I win.
Even in the shorter form of the game, the winner is usually apparent quickly and then there's a long march that resembles the Trail of Tears more than it does board game turns.
If you're going for an interesting board game, instead of Real Monopoly, I'd highly recommend:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puerto_Rico_(board_game)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Settlers_of_Catan