News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by AlexandrB on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:36AM (#28074290)
Good for them. Despite the mantras of "support our frontline workers" many of these employees have been treated like shit by their employers[1], their government who refused to take measures to limit the spread, and their patients - some of whom will continue to actively deny COVID even as they die from it.

[1] https://www.nwahomepage.com/knwa/mercy-employees-frustrated-...

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by MattGaiser on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:45AM (#28074426)
If a company cares about you, it is shown in money. The People and Culture guy is a snake oil salesman meant to scam you.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by pavel_lishin on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:55AM (#28074574)
I think you're underplaying non-financial incentives.

I would rather have a job that pays $X but offers flexible work hours and vacation time that allows me to be a better parent, than a job that pays $1.5X but won't let me take a day or afternoon off to (e.g.) take my kid to the doctor, etc.

Granted, that probably applies more to WFH desk jobs than front-line nurses.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by mumblemumble on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:11AM (#28074853)
The disgruntled nurses I know don't want more money anywhere near as much as they want things like lunch and bathroom breaks.

Money can't buy happiness, but not being able to take care of your basic bodily needs can absolutely buy unhappiness.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by dividefuel on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:21PM (#28075866)
My spouse is just starting her first RN job. As part of the onboarding, an administrator/HR person called and strongly suggested that she sign a paper waiving one of her 30 minute lunch periods. Even though the paper says "I am not being coerced", it's pretty clear that signing it is necessary for getting the job.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by sjdrc on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:50PM (#28081556)
How can a document like that even be legal? What reason would a worker have to willingly sign away their rights?
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by zepto on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:35AM (#28075194)
> Money can't buy happiness

No but not having enough will make you unhappy, and keep you trapped there.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by skt5 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:05PM (#28077325)
> Money can't buy happiness

Usually when someone says this to me, I respond with "then you're spending your money poorly". What I mean to say is that more money buys more flexibility and options, which should lead to more opportunities to leave unhappy situations or at least add more happy situations. Note that this is a generalization so there are plenty of edge cases to counter this.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by mumblemumble on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:00PM (#28078016)
There's also this distressing hump in the money/happiness curve. More money leads to a greater sense of well being up to a point where you meet your basic sufficiency needs, and then, beyond that, the correlation goes inverse.

My guess is that there is a very strong diminishing returns effect to the utility of money, and that, at some point, other effects start to dominate. Perhaps what's happening with health care workers is a case study for what's going on there.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by jxidjhdhdhdhfhf on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:48PM (#28078647)
Can you cite a source on that? The studies I've seen have shown that happiness increases more slowly after a certain income but the slope never goes negative.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.forbes.com/sites/alexledsom...

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by skt5 on Friday August 06, 2021 @08:56AM (#28086484)
My intuition is on the money vs happiness curve, the first derivative is always positive unless “your spending it wrong”. The second derivative might be positive for lower values of money but probably has negative values that might highlight a diminishing returns effect.

I should have qualified in my parent post that it assumes all else being equal.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by pavel_lishin on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:06PM (#28082852)
Having money buys flexibility and options. Merely making slightly more money doesn't.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by skt5 on Friday August 06, 2021 @08:51AM (#28086438)
What’s the difference between having a little bit more money and making a little bit more money? My guess is it’s how it is spent.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by bigmattystyles on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:11AM (#28074851)
An RN I know in New Orleans makes a paltry $28 / hour. Insidiously, they gave her 10k upfront for a 3 year contract. If she leaves, she has to give it back. She put it straight to her student loans so now she’s stuck there. I agree with op, we say we love our front line workers, but that’s just talk. I’m not sure but there’s not much of a union for them down there.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by bastardoperator on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:12PM (#28075759)
Most employers don't go after employees for these because the employee has already paid taxes on the money and the business itself has written the money off. Having to go back and change taxes or sue an employee typically isn't worth the cost of the bonus itself. This is also null and void if they're violating her rights, like the ability to use the bathroom or take a lunch break.

Last, 28 / hour is fairly low for an RN. While indeed shows a median salary of 28.30 in New Orleans, it seems like most companies in the area are hiring at 54-64 dollars per hour setting the median for the pandemic at 46.52 per hour.

If she can nearly double her pay, who cares about 10k... I've never seen a company try to enforce these.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by bigmattystyles on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:27PM (#28075940)
I guess the company can bluff the employees pretty easily. They’re not exactly rolling in it (employees) either or have much spare time. If you get one strongly worded letter or ‘reminder’ from HR, I’d venture most would fold rather than go to an attorney.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by user5994461 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:12PM (#28079042)
It's not bluff. It's common to have claw back clauses on sign-on bonus or trainings, for a limited period (3 years might be too long though).

The comment you reply to is giving really bad advice to ignore it. That sort of clause is valid and the company may or may not action it. You don't know.

What your friend should do is interview for other companies and mentions to the HR interview that she has to refund 10k if she leaves now, and ask whether they would be able to cover it. It's routine for companies to offer a sign-on bonus to cover this sort of things and you can expect the same claw back clause attached for one year.

Alternatively, if she has the money AND can get a job that pays significantly more, she can switch anyway, the worst that can happen is that she has to pay some money if the company asks.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by bastardoperator on Friday August 06, 2021 @09:39AM (#28086990)
No one is arguing the commonality, it's the enforcement of these policies that are questionable. In a right to work state, these clauses are meaningless.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by selimthegrim on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:37PM (#28079403)
They are desperate down here with COVID, she can probably call their bluff and win.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by MattGaiser on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:23AM (#28075011)
Just ask for a signing bonus at the next job. Definitely heard of signing bonuses that size with agencies for nursing.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by 1123581321 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:57PM (#28076391)
Exactly this. In fact competing employers should be expecting to buy out this clawback if her current employer commonly does this.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by FireBeyond on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:49PM (#28077112)
Yeah, here in the PNW, I could point her to two companies that will give her work at her choice of hospitals for $65/hr, with "as much work as she wants".

Don't start me on EMTs working 24 or 48 hour shifts for $11/hr.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by nwellinghoff on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:18AM (#28074946)
News flash. There is no way they can get that money back. She can walk at anytime
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by Jtsummers on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:30AM (#28075099)
This would largely depend on the particular contract. Money can be paid conditioned on an expectation of working for a period of time. Failure to meet your end can result in having to pay it back (in full or in part).
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by R0b0t1 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:53AM (#28075475)
Case in TX where this was overturned. Employer was Buc-ees. The amount in question was far higher, about $100k, as the employee was given a $X/hr raise contingent on at least Y years of service. Court ruled contract violated right to work. This may mean bonus clawbacks can't work.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by Jtsummers on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:09PM (#28075710)
https://cases.justia.com/texas/fourteenth-court-of-appeals/2...

Interesting case. I'm not a lawyer and have only given this a quick read, but it seems that the amount she could owe back was essentially unbounded, the longer she was there the more she could owe back. That was a major factor in the decision against Buc-ee's. See pages 8 and 9, in particular. I don't think this would work against bonus claw backs in general, only if they were similarly considered unreasonable and also only in TX, whose laws were violated in this case. (EDIT: Or states with similar laws, obviously.)

A $10k signing bonus that has a bounded and shorter obligation period could be considered reasonable.

> As noted above, an enforceable covenant must contain limitations as to time, geographic area, and scope of activity to be restrained that are reasonable and do not impose a greater restraint than necessary to protect the employer’s business interest.

https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.15.htm

Sections 15.50 and 15.51 are the relevant parts.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by JohnBooty on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:28AM (#28075084)
Can you back this up? Labor laws vary significantly by country/state.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by MattGaiser on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:14AM (#28074890)
Money can be used to care in different ways. It can be in cash for your current workload or it can be to hire others so your workload is less.

But both cost money.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by syshum on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:16AM (#28074917)
That only works if $X is over your what you feel is "required" to sustain your life style.

Generally Speaking in all but the biggest cities that is probably around the 60K-70K annual mark anything over that a person might put other things ahead of salary

However if you are working for $60K you bet you ass MONEY is how a company should be showing their love...

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by kevinmchugh on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:57AM (#28074620)
There's probably some floor for X below which 1.5x is more valuable than the non-monetary incentives
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by skeeter2020 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:07AM (#28074777)
There is a well-studied phenomena where money is a very strong motivator until a individual-specific level, than quickly tapers off in perceived value. The challenge is the floor $ value is different for everyone and changes over time and circumstances.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by arp242 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:50PM (#28076265)
That's all very good; I genuinely agree with it, and I think it applies to nurses too (schedules etc. permitting).

But it doesn't work if you're struggling to make ends meet. There are hospital workers who don't have health care because they can't afford it for example.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by res0nat0r on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:14AM (#28074895)
I think in this case, I think hospital staff at least would like to be paid more for the hell they've been going through over the last year vs. having folks stand outside on their balcony and clap at 7PM and pretend that will fix everything.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by ledauphin on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:58PM (#28077244)
you're right about these other incentives, but they're all forms of time off.

I believe the GP was referring to the other "stuff" companies try to do to get you to feel like they care about you, but that don't impact your ability to make your own choices about your life the way more time or money do.

e.g., "free" swag, company-wide retreats/outings

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by amerkhalid on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:06AM (#28074761)
Is there a number that will let you sacrifice your family life but also give you enough money to provide really good life for them? I am not saying it can make up for missing parents from ones life but I have seen kids who grew up with workaholic parents and are thankful for them. They had Better schools, professional nannies and tutors, and now they don’t have to work as hard.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by JohnBooty on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:26AM (#28075053)
What a good, tough question.

I'd suspect that it's less of an absolute "magic number" and more like a ratio compared to the alternative. Like a 2X or 3X salary increase, maybe more.

If I was making $30K a year (slightly less than the national individual median income) and had kids, I'd have to strongly consider a $150K job that could open up a completely different set of opportunities for the kids. In a lot of places in America that's a leap from "borderline poor nutrition and you better hope you're smart enough to earn a full college scholarship... and try not to get shot in the meantime" to "safety, healthy food, and we're able to invest in your future."

If I was already making $125K a year that $150K wouldn't be so persuasive. Not upending my life for that.

Although, I suppose, once we start talking nannies and tutors we're probably looking at closer to $250-$500K anyway. A full-time nanny is... well, a full-time employee.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by analog31 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:12AM (#28074867)
Is such a tradeoff common? Or do the best employers offer both?
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by erikerikson on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:31AM (#28075125)
The best employers offer both and often have far better profitability.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:15PM (#28075803)
FWIW, there was a post by an ICU nurse in my local subreddit who said that NOBODY took advantage of extra available shifts even though the hospital was offering double pay.

Her point was for many medical personnel, it's not about money, it's about being exhausted and burnt out.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by lotsofpulp on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:11PM (#28076569)
Bump it up to 10x, and then 100x. Of course, money is just a means to an end, so if the amount of money being offered is not going to achieve one’s goal, then it is useless. If that goal is increasing one’s quality of life by either earning so much that you can quit, or by hiring more people so that you do not get burned out, either way the answer is money.

However, the bedrock of our society has been a growing working age population that is OK with meager wages and quality of life at work, allowing us to lives more luxurious than otherwise could be. This dynamic should change once the working age population decreases relative to the old age population who need the services.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by werber on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:56AM (#28074592)
I think it's also shown in time. I've had jobs that paid me more than my current one, but I was paying for that by my personal time being completely abused on a regular basis, even if it's just a small thing or 3 daily it ends up feeling like you never stop working. I don't have any means of work communication on my phone now, and I've gotten one call that I said I was open to in my current role. To me, shutting my computer and work being completely over till I open it again is such a relief.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by mrtranscendence on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:09AM (#28074829)
Yes, I think attitude towards personal time (or more generally, work-life balance) really is a facet of culture that's important to bear in mind. I've been lucky in that regard, as my managers and coworkers have been very forgiving when it comes to (say) taking off suddenly so I can take my rabbit to the emergency vet.

I wouldn't give that flexibility up for double the pay. If I'm ever in a job where they routinely abuse off hours or disapprove of taking time off, I'll be looking intensely for something to replace it.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by planet-and-halo on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:02AM (#28074693)
This is very reductive and I assume means you've never worked somewhere with an actually decent culture. I understand your cynicism: there are indeed a lot of bullshitters out there. But there are some good places to work here and there, places where the bosses listen and respect the humanity and autonomy of the people around them. Frequently this occurs at a local level rather than across an entire company, but it does happen. (Note: I'm not saying it's an excuse to underpay people, I'm saying this can be an issue entirely independent of pay.)
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by DamnYuppie on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:05AM (#28074755)
I have worked for places with amazing culture and benefits. I still left and went somewhere else for a 50% pay increase. At the end of the day I look at the extra amount I am saving and what it does to my retirement account. The place I left to was by no means horrible but was not at the same level in terms of culture/vacation.

Also I did end up returning to that company after 4 years and was able to get an even bigger raise upon my return. As always the best way to increase your pay is by leaving, so sad to be honest.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by mrtranscendence on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:17AM (#28074922)
It's one thing to move from amazing to not bad for 50% more pay. It's another to move from a good work culture to one that abuses your off time, expects you never to take time off, or forces frequent overtime.

I just recently moved from a place with very good culture and benefits to a contracting company with much worse benefits. Just going from five weeks vacation to two weeks alone really stings. And my pay only went up 10% ... it wasn't only the money, it was because I wanted something new, but I still have a growing sense of regret.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by eckesicle on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:32PM (#28078418)
Why don't you go ask for your old job back? Worst case they say no.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by NineStarPoint on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:13AM (#28074882)
I would say that money is more than just personal pay. It’s paying for enough personnel that people aren’t overworked, and can safely take a day or two off if they need it for mental health. Its in paying for the items and tools and spaces to make the job easier/less stressful for the employees, instead of nickel and diming. I agree that there are culture people who aren’t just bullshitters out there, but a lot of that comes in them being able to argue upward to the top brass for the resources the employees need to be comfortable enough for a good work culture to take place. There are other things a good culture person has to do of course, but as always resources are so foundational that its hard for other things to matter if money isn’t taken care of first.

In the case of hospitals, it’s almost always the top brass’s lack of willingness to hire more people that causes the greatest pressure of culture. Without a person willing to argue that the admins should be paid less so that each individual doctor has more time for each patient, the culture will remain toxic due to the stress that causes the doctors.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by nradov on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:39AM (#28075257)
Modern healthcare requires administrators to deal with finance, facilities, IT, compliance, HR, etc. Most hospitals can probably trim a little admin waste but it's not going to solve the fundamental systemic problems. In nonprofit hospitals that take a lot of uninsured and Medicare / Medicaid patients there's still going to be a lack of revenue no matter how they slice the pie. Real solutions will require realigning incentives at the state and federal government levels.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by lallysingh on Thursday August 05, 2021 @10:50AM (#28074500)
There are certainly shops that treat you like garbage but pay very well. It's an abusive form of golden handcuffs.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by rdtwo on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:52PM (#28079633)
Amazon
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by Tempest1981 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:53AM (#28075474)
Or maybe your mental health is shitty after intubating people and watching them slowly die, over and over for 18 months, with no end in sight.

Money can't fix that.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by nimbius on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:21AM (#28074975)
maybe in tech companies but in more traditional roles like manufacturing and maintenance, its paid in respect for your time. Mandatory overtime is a real thing in the US and less of it means a stronger relationship with your employees. all the money in the world wont replace your weekends.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by brightball on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:04AM (#28074720)
For what it's worth, in insurance controlled businesses that's easier said than done. I'm not dismissing your point, just saying that there are a lot of complexities.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by TheCoelacanth on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:12PM (#28078162)
Good working conditions are also an aspect of the company caring about you. If a company pays you well, but still abuses you, they don't care about you.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by Taylor_OD on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:07AM (#28074787)
Yeah the fact that companies spend money (lots of money) on advertising dollars instead of handing that money to the workers they supposedly support in hazard pay is wild.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by NonContro on Thursday August 05, 2021 @05:33PM (#28080202)
Part of the fatigue is the intense level of PPE. Its physically exhausting and usually just theatre because so many healthcare workers are either vaccinated or have already had COVID.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by hcurtiss on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:01AM (#28074676)
I think it's notable that there is substantial resistance to vaccines even among health care workers. https://www.webmd.com/vaccines/covid-19-vaccine/news/2021062...
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by tejohnso on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:10AM (#28074832)
> One reason some hospital staff say they are resisting COVID-19 vaccination is because it's so new and not yet fully approved by the FDA.

> "I want to see more testing done," she says. "It took a long time to get a flu vaccine, and we made a COVID vaccine in 6 months. I want to know, before I start putting something into my body, that the testing is done."

> Many of her co-workers share her feelings, she said.

Would have been nice if the article included responses to these concerns. Plenty of shaming about how dangerous passing covid to patients can be, but I didn't see anything that actually addresses the confidence problem.

edit:

Looks like a different hospital worked on the confidence problem with some success:

> "There was a lot of hesitancy and skepticism," says William Schaffner, MD, a professor of preventive medicine and infectious disease at Vanderbilt University in Nashville. So the infectious disease division put together a multifaceted program including Q&As, educational sessions, and one-on-one visits with employees, "from the custodians all the way up to the C-suite," he says.

Today, HHS data shows the hospital is 83% vaccinated. Schaffner thinks the true number is probably higher, about 90%. "We're very pleased with that," he says.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by 908B64B197 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:10PM (#28079012)
> Would have been nice if the article included responses to these concerns. Plenty of shaming about how dangerous passing covid to patients can be, but I didn't see anything that actually addresses the confidence problem.

Here's one simple question: who's liable for the damages/complications from the vaccine.

The answer: it's complicated.

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/16/covid-vaccine-side-effects-c...

https://fortune.com/2021/04/07/covid-vaccine-safety-is-astra...

https://www.newsweek.com/fact-check-are-pharmaceutical-compa...

But why should it be? If you trust your product, that's a no-brainer to cover the consumer for damages. If you don't...

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by joshuamorton on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:24PM (#28081368)
> But why should it be? If you trust your product, that's a no-brainer to cover the consumer for damages. If you don't...

This assumes a lot of things about the US legal system that aren't really true. A company can get sued for anything. And the cost of litigation is nontrivial. In the US, by default, each party is liable for their own litigation costs. This means that if 20000 people decide to sue Pfizer (you know, 1% of 1% of the vaccinated in the US), Pfizer now has to deal with the litigation costs of tens of thousands of lawsuits. Even if they win every single one, they're paying for hundreds, or even thousands, of lawyer-years in billables.

And while many of those might just be people hoping for a quick buck, or people with legitimate concerns who are ultimately mistaken, some will be agenda-driven people with funding to make the cases last, and whose goal is to make Pfizer look bad, because those people think vaccines are dangerous and the people who make them should be punished.

And Pfizer is on the hook for all of that even if there are no damages. Zero, zilch.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by 908B64B197 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @07:51PM (#28081563)
> In the US, by default, each party is liable for their own litigation costs. This means that if 20000 people decide to sue Pfizer (you know, 1% of 1% of the vaccinated in the US), Pfizer now has to deal with the litigation costs of tens of thousands of lawsuits.

They can recover those costs if the lawsuit is frivolous. And we're talking about a billion dollar company racking billions in profits fighting in court against... sick people robbed of their health's. A balanced fight indeed.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by joshuamorton on Thursday August 05, 2021 @08:06PM (#28081660)
> And we're talking about a billion dollar company racking billions in profits fighting in court against... sick people robbed of their health's. A balanced fight indeed.

No, in this hypothetical, we're presuming that the vaccine has no side effects. So these people aren't sick people robbed of their health, but either mistaken or agenda driven.

> They can recover those costs if the lawsuit is frivolous.

This is a high bar and isn't always even possible, depending on the jurisdiction. Often it requires things like the person filing the suit to know the suit is frivolous.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by hcurtiss on Friday August 06, 2021 @08:01AM (#28085935)
I find it amusing I’m being downvoted. I’m not questioning the safety or efficacy of the vaccine (I’m vaccinated). I only mean to highlight what a difficult problem this is to solve when even health care workers are struggling with uptake. People, including HN, are truly wrapped around the axle on this issue.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by psychometry on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:10AM (#28074830)
Most people who fall under "health care workers" don't have a medical degree. Many, including techs and nursing assistants, don't have a bachelor's degree either. So, that population isn't really all that different from the general U.S. population in many ways.

Among physicians and medical researchers with PhDs, though, you'll find very little resistance to vaccines.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by scohesc on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:34PM (#28076919)
Strange how the medical system trusts these people enough to parrot the mantra of "this vaccine is safe and effective", let alone actually administer it!
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by psychometry on Friday August 06, 2021 @10:02AM (#28087282)
Are you dumb? It takes almost no training to administer a vaccine compared to developing it.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by iamadog55 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:00PM (#28075584)
I'm reluctant to leverage such language, but this is an appeal to authority. And there's tons of historical evidence that authorities failed to produce their predicted end without regard to their field, specialty, education, politics, etc... So to acede to this solely on the basis that the "intelligentsia" has is perhaps just as blind a means as a coinflip. And there is of course a plenitude of arguments about how politicized this has all become, vested interests, the bandwagon, what someone might call drinking the Kool-Aid. Not to mention at this point in history we're dealt with so much information that unless your specialization is intersecting with, let's say, molecular biology, you're not particularly well suited to make a judgement call. So all these physicians, whose practice is far removed from the infinitesimal nuances of the field may not be wholly capable of assessing the finer nuances, so they trail the authorities that dictate the policy to people ever further removed. And the whole of the field isn't unanimously pressing for vaccination either, there are fringe elements that are duly skeptical who do lay within your "physicians, medical researchers with PhDs" milieu [1]. Not to mention we need a control group, how will the vaccinated gloat if they've nobody to tell "I told you so..."? And, as an example, recently there was paper published showing indications that antibiotics can cause developmental abnormalities due to alterations within the gut-brain axis which alters gene expression. Penicillin was discovered in 1928, 93 years ago, and we're just now finding out that might carry adverse effects when deployed in the young, a practice long unquestioned [2]. That's just an example to wrap your head around. And there's a litany of legitimate philosophical questions that haven't been asked because we're so well conditioned to being dragged along by technology rather than taking the reigns ourselves, and that's where my predominate concerns lie.

[1] https://www.geertvandenbossche.org/ [2] https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isci.2021.102797

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by FireBeyond on Thursday August 05, 2021 @02:00PM (#28077272)
No, it's more the reverse, and it has validity. "Look, even medical professionals have concerns" is a soundbite that loses a lot of its weight when you realize that in some cases, you are looking at MAs with 20 weeks of schooling, LPNs, or even CNAs (who could have had as few as 85 hours of schooling) as "medical professionals" - they can have opinions, validity, concerns - but holding them up as medical professionals worthy of higher merit to their concern has varying degrees of flimsiness.

This isn't to knock those concerns. But while neither an MD, an LPN, or a layperson is an epidemiologist, we should be exalting the opinions of them by virtue of their authority. Not because you _need_ to be an epidemiologist to have a valid opinion, but because the above buys you no more merit, in and of itself.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by edmundsauto on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:17PM (#28075827)
The comment you’re replying to was also using the appeal to authority fallacy. Parent was just clarifying that the group as a whole might not be well informed, but the more educated subset is less vaccine hesitant.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by nonameiguess on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:30PM (#28076869)
It's important to recognize the difference between deductive and inductive logic. Much of academia, from lit reviews to citations to the way people are trained and educated, is inherently based upon appeal to authority. Appeal to authority is a logical fallacy only insofar as you're considering purely deductive logic, in the sense that a statement "X believes Y, therefore Y" is not formally valid. That doesn't mean the beliefs of authorities in a field are not valid informally as pieces of evidence.

Whether or not medical consensus has been more predictive than a coin flip historically is an empirical claim. I have no idea if it's true, but that seems doubtful. It's particularly interesting to cite penicillin as an example of medical authorities being wrong. Child mortality has dropped more than a hundredfold in the United States since the invention of penicillin. Not that penicillin is solely responsible for that, but I have to question whether possibly negative developmental effects you are trying to cite here really offsets the negative effects of children having potentially deadly infections. I had a severe case of pneumonia when I was 5 and would have died if not for antibiotics. Death is surely the worst possible negative developmental effect.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by iamadog55 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:55PM (#28078776)
You're putting words in my mouth. I said as blind as a coinflip.

And you've managed construe a total misapprehension of my intended point. A fairly simple medicine that has been deployed for a very long period of time, very well studied and understood, can still generate novel information. My point wasn't to squeeze mortality rates or make positions on the use and importance of penicillin, simply to evince readers the point there are still unknown unknowns, in practice, of something that's been widely proliferated for nearly a century.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by lamontcg on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:17PM (#28075818)
> I'm reluctant to leverage such language, but this is an appeal to authority.

Then so was the comment it was responding to

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by iamadog55 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:06PM (#28076511)
Let's dissect this: >I think it's notable that there is substantial resistance to vaccines even among health care workers.

So here, the poster asserts that they find it notable, as in worthy of remark, that within the domain of healthcare people are opting out. The poster does not make any conjecture or assertions aside from that, the poster does not lean on any position nor support one from the authority of the "healthcare worker" mosaic. Instead, the poster very simply states that it is remarkable that that cohort chooses to remain unvaccinated without any further context.

The proceeding post moves to make assertions and stratify the cohort into classes, and implicitly posits the superior decisionmaking of the educated, arguing at what is in actuality a phantasm, as the parent did not postulate anything whatever. I suspect he projected some archetype onto the parent, hazarded induction, and argued with an appeal to authority in an attempt to make a point that needn't be asserted in the context.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by lamontcg on Thursday August 05, 2021 @06:04PM (#28080588)
Oh look a 6 hour old account splitting hairs and playing semantic games.

I have real work to do.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by hcurtiss on Friday August 06, 2021 @07:59AM (#28085918)
But GP is right about what I intended. I don’t mean to question the safety or efficacy of the vaccine. I only mean to suggest it’s a difficult problem to solve when even the health care profession, which I would style as more familiar/comfortable with administration of life saving treatments, seems to be struggling with uptake.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by bbarnett on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:26AM (#28075051)
Have to jump in here, that last sentence really erks me.

This thread was about people perceiving a new vaccine, as one not tested enough.

This is vastly different from someone which has resistance to vaccination overall.

I am quite concerned that such mislabelling of people, could lead to disaster.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by syshum on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:20AM (#28074966)
So we are down the rabbit hole of the credentials fallacy, no one can be creditable or have valid concerns / issues unless they have a MD or PhD?
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by standardUser on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:37AM (#28075213)
No, but we expect people who are trained in a certain area of expertise to have well-informed opinions on issues within that area of expertise. We don't ask phlebotomists which vaccines we need. That would be silly. We do ask our doctors that question, and they nearly all say we should get this vaccine and the vast majority have received it themselves.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by FireBeyond on Thursday August 05, 2021 @01:54PM (#28077178)
No, the inverse.

We shouldn't treat the opinions of a CNA who might have had as few as 85 hours of education as "the opinions of a medical professional" - -that- is entirely valid. Their opinions can be credible, and they can have valid concerns, but they're not held higher because they have a cert or license or degree.

Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by psychometry on Friday August 06, 2021 @10:04AM (#28087295)
There's nothing more useless than a person who does nothing but point out "logical fallacies" instead of thinking critically about an issue. That's you.
Re:Hospital exec says employees are walking off the job by mindslight on Thursday August 05, 2021 @11:06AM (#28074769)
Indeed. Social media is a hell of a drug.