BTW, I'm not implying a stance here as pro- or anti- vaccine requirements - just probing this particular talking point.
Do we know that the activities where vaccines are required are in fact hotspots? If you consider states that did full lockdowns compared to those that didn't but had mask mandates (California and New York vs texas Florida), there wasn't an appreciable difference in cases or deaths suggesting the mechanism of transition lied outside the reach of government. What's to say people still won't congregate elsewhere?
In turn, I'm not convinced this will incentivize people to vaccinate. My mother refuses to get the shot and digs in more against it as penalties show up. Sure this is and data, but I know that many, many people have left New York City due to what they considered draconian lockdowns and I suspect many more people might leave to "freer" pastures.
I'm not convinced this will achieve the intended objective, but instead far more animosity and pushback which is what you see in this thread which is far more tame than what the general population thinks.
Would love to hear a rebuttal.
You may not like being in a marginal group, but you should realize how very few people in this country are discussing your situation when they talk about the unvaccinated. There are tens of millions of people in the country who are willingly unvaccinated, and almost the entirety of them are people who do not have autoimmune disorders. In fact, the people pushing for mandates are often using your situation - that of someone for whom the vaccine is ineffective - as reason for a requirement.
So chill.
Do I have the right to knowingly go about my business in public spaces with untreated-and-infectious Ebola after "weighing my risks"?
And if you don't want anyone to listen to you, why are you typing?
His doctor tested him for antibodies, his were undetectable. He was getting a third shot in hopes it would finally give him antibodies.
By being against vaccines or against vaccine requirements, people risk the lives of those like that guy, who's already suffering and already has to be 10x as cautious.