News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lisp in an “impossible” language, the most complex Malbol... by lucrtz on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @03:11PM (#28064959)
Also of course this was not written entirely by hand, but with a toolchain as the author says somewhere else, it's not exactly feasible to write this by hand.
Re:Lisp in an “impossible” language, the most complex Malbol... by Jerrrry on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @03:30PM (#28065177)
exactly, but this audience knows anything can be trivially transpiled to any turing-complete language regardless of the "difficulty" of the language once basic operators are established.

the entire sadistic point of the esoteric exercise is to dwell in the agony of unaccomplishment, not roll it up using a toolchain.

Re:Lisp in an “impossible” language, the most complex Malbol... by palaiologos on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @04:01PM (#28065573)
I think that you never touched Malbolge yourself.

> anything can be trivially transpiled to any turing-complete language regardless of the "difficulty" of the language once basic operators are established

Yes! It already was. There exists the Nagoya toolchain which I'm aware of, but it's generated code simply is too inefficient and unstable (from my testing) to be ran on contemporary machines. To write efficient Malbolge programs, like I just did, you'd need to implement a good chunk of "basic" operations in Malbolge (or, for the record, low level assembly which maps really well to Malbolge itself).

> the entire sadistic point of the esoteric exercise is to dwell in the agony of unaccomplishment, not roll it up using a toolchain.

It's easy to program assembly, it's hard to write a compiler that targets good assembly. As humans we've been striving to make good compilers for ages, yet still we're not even close. So, I'd say, the fact that I made it _using_ a toolchain makes it even more impressive.

> this audience knows anything can be trivially transpiled to any turing-complete language

This is the definition of Turing-completeness and I'd be surprised if this audience didn't know it. But I wouldn't be so sure about it being trivial. Two questions:

1) How do you "obviously" target cyclic tag systems and the Rule 110 automation?

2) How do you make it efficient? If we assume the simplest way of transpiling, we'll get nowhere near _actual usability_ (to some degree) which MalbolgeLisp exhibits.

Re:Lisp in an “impossible” language, the most complex Malbol... by isoprophlex on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @04:40PM (#28066021)
Could you be a little bit less condescending? Simply don't upvote if you think this is trivial or crap content.

In any case this definitely feeds my intellectual curiosity. Even if it's indeed trivial to transpile between languages, I have zero idea how to go about that... and besides, I for one always love reading about Malbolge.

Re:Lisp in an “impossible” language, the most complex Malbol... by yladiz on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @03:49PM (#28065412)
Who are you to be the gatekeeper of what is or isn't an acceptable way to use Malbolge, or any esoteric language?