I’m with you, this joke haunts me daily. I studied economics in undergrad, and market efficiency is such a basic tenet that it’s really hard to see opportunities that don’t just look like a mirage.
The other performs an internal utility calculation and eats the dog shit.
Continuing their walk, the second economist sees another pile of dog shit and makes the same offer to the first. The first economist also agrees, and eats the dog shit. They walk on.
After a while the second economist says to the first "it feels like we're both worse off than we were before this walk".
The first economist replies "impossible! We've just engaged in 2000 dollars worth of trade!".
That convinces me that P!=NP, heheh.
I can't help but notice that the joke rests on an impossible premise that they didn't pick it up on first notice.
They are so convinced in their theories, that a real world discontinuity in them is instead, seen as impossible.
EG, Why would they pick up what clearly (to them) cannot exist?
The $100 is vaguely seen in the middle of the street during traffic. Is it actually $100? Maybe it's just a dollar bill. And are you good enough to grab it without getting hit?
Maybe it's true if you come from a rich background and have family wealth to fall back on, which I suspect is where most of these people are coming from.
In the long-term, markets are certainly efficient. However, the period of inefficiency is determined by the absolute quantity of profit dollars available in the market which in itself determines the competition. That is, the quantity of ticks (time) required for a dynamic optimization w.r.t. profit extraction is the measure of competition in some market, and thereby the degree of efficiency.
It is then true, that in the most competitive markets, the ones with the most capital, have a very small window of inefficiency, but they do exist. It requires a lot of capital to dynamically extract profit from those inefficiencies. An example of this would be the near hegemony of Citadel Securities in making markets. It is impossible for anyone today to compete in the market-making (an advanced arbitrage) industry without tons of capital.
However, we are time-bounded beings so there is always present an inefficient market. The challenge of the proprietor is then to determine that market which can provide a return to his constrained capital.
For instance, a restaurant can give a 15% annual ROI, which outperforms the S&P. The Citadel is not going to be interested in this inefficiency because that ROI is unavailable to the amount of capital they're trying to invest. So what we see is that the most competitive markets beget the most capital, because they have the most profit available to extract absolutely; then the most amount of resources, where capital is the analogue, are invested into those markets--so any inefficiency is quickly eroded.
This means that just like the restaurant, there are markets that remain untouched for long periods of time due to their inability to return large amounts of capital in absolute terms. These markets then have a great ROI in terms of percent. It is these markets that are available to the proprietor with low capital.
This is why the startup advice of finding a niche first is so salient, they are always necessarily underserved non-competitive markets. There's the other cycle from crossing-the-chasm which removes enterprises from this market who have the same idea as they scale, that's a separate explication, but this cycle allows the period of inefficiency to be maintained in those markets through that self-regulation.
First efficiency isn’t about winners and losers. A lottery has negative returns even though someone still wins. Similarly Google was an absolutely great investment yet venture capital firms tend to under preform the market on average.
The nuances run deep. T-Bills seemingly vastly under preform the stock market, yet buyers are generally being rational.
This is a really astute observation.
Both my parents were economics professors and I have a degree in economics. I feel like this concept was instilled in my core, and poisoned my thinking, but it’s fundamentally not true.
I’ve come to finally learn in old age that the market is full of inefficiencies that can be exploited, they are everywhere.
If you’re reasonably smart, or even just well-informed on a specific subject, things that seem obvious and trivial to you will in fact be observations you can profit from.
The world is full of $20 bills lying on the ground to reference a popular punch line.
Doesn't market efficiency just say that someone is going to be the one to identify the inefficiency and make a ton of money in the process? The market doesn't become efficient unless people do things.
It magically generated about $8000 in a couple of days, and then the market came crashing down and the inefficiency it was exploiting disappeared forever
Pretty **ing frustrating, and it's all the Efficient Market Hypothesis' fault
You should look up the debates that Warren Buffett has had with people about the EMH, it's insane
I'm hoping that whoever snatched this up won't be ready to grab it quickly if it ever reappears someday
There’s a concept called the EMH and I think there’s a very strong tendency in Econ and pop culture to skip ahead and assume the hypothesis is basically true most of the time, often in the face of painfully obvious evidence to the contrary.
But also as Krishnamurti said "Truth is a pathless land." And as Lin Chi said "If you meet Buddha on the road, kill him." Take the parts here that resonate with you and build the rest the way in a way that works for you. It will probably take commitment and multiple failed attempts to get there. Just accept that from the get-go. Not everyone has the tolerance for risk to go down this road though.
I agree and I think it's partially a circular argument. In discussions of stocks, you'll hear that one 'cannot beat' 'the stock market' and you'll hear phrases like, "already priced in" "efficient market hypothesis" and so forth. Which is different than the sentiment that it's 'very hard' or even 'unlikely' to do something like that, which I sympathize with.
The existence of the hedge fund industry is a paradox for the idea of efficient markets. If markets are efficient, then the value added of hedge funds is zero. And if markets are efficient, hedge funds should only be able to charge their value added in fees, which is zero. Hedge funds charge a lot of fees. PE and VC funds charge even more. So markets are not efficient.
it reminded me of the time i did start my own business and the number of people that tried to talk me out of it was overwhelming. that's when i learned that a lot of people hate the successes and freedoms that others have.
Part of me thinks the worst thing I ever learned about was market efficiency. Once you've heard that argument from a professor, you can apply it to just about anything. Heck I even had colleagues use it against me, despite being specifically hired to beat the unbeatable market.
The guy in the article is right though, it's bogus. There's lots of little things you can do that might turn into a business. The existing players have not hoovered up all the opportunity, and new opps come along all the time. People talk about things that are profitable even if they haven't locked it all up for themselves.