Basically just before guns became popular armor was so good that sword fights usually turned into wrestling followed trying to stick a small knife into some small gap. Various hammers/clubs (or using the pommel of your sword as a hammer) were much more efficient weapons against a person in full plate.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLLv8E2pWdk
It does seem like swords were more decorative than actual effective weapons...they do look cool when wielded though.
Check out Akira Kurosawa’s films for some fairly accurate samurai fights.
It's part of the modern Pentathlon.
Note, I'm a foil fencer.
These sorts of rules should be good for the sport, so long as they don't encourage excessive aggression and risk-taking. From what little epee I've actually done, defensive strategies (which to the camera might look like doing nothing), can be effective depending on the opponent's strategy.
For rapiers, I think the same applies. Meyer advocates the same with single-hand sword, with more emphasis on feinting. I studied Thibault for a few weeks and while I am no expert, his style focuses on geometrical relationship between your sword and body with the enemy's.
All are fun, though if the fight is lethal they would be horrendous to see.
1. parry
2. thrust
3. game over