News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Addictive Personality? You Might be a Leader by hammock on Sunday July 24, 2011 @04:52PM (#2800301)
I dont want to sound too hard, but I have an intuition that this is just a load of hogwash. The author racks his brain and comes up with a few examples of addicts who run big companies.

What about all the big companies run by non-addicts (the majority)?

What about all the addicts who don't run big companies (the majority)?

These things need to be addressed before I'll start to buy the argument. And this comment coming from a habitual risk-taking leader himself.

Re:Addictive Personality? You Might be a Leader by tilt on Sunday July 24, 2011 @05:26PM (#2800374)
Is that me or the author is not implying that good leaders ARE addicts (to drugs) but that they seek success, progress, disruption, quality as an addict would seek pleisure "artificially"?
Re:Addictive Personality? You Might be a Leader by jey on Sunday July 24, 2011 @05:31PM (#2800387)
> What about all the big companies run by non-addicts (the majority)

Sure, but the real question is whether "addicts" are over-represented amongst successful CEOs more than the general population.

Re:Addictive Personality? You Might be a Leader by jey on Sunday July 24, 2011 @08:22PM (#2800770)
Looks like I should explain myself:

If there was no association between having an "addictive personality" and being a successful CEO, we would expect "addictives" to be CEOs just as often as non-addictives. If being an addictive helps with being a successful CEO, we'd expect a higher concentration of addictives amongst the population of successful CEOs.

The grandparent is presenting a argument a much stronger straw-man: that the majority of successful CEOs have addictive personalities. The original post does not make that claim.

Re:Addictive Personality? You Might be a Leader by corin_ on Monday July 25, 2011 @06:48AM (#2802113)
That isn't how statistics work. If 10% of people are "addicts", and 20% of CEOs are "addicts", it's fair to say that there is correlation - despite the fact that there are still five times as many non-addict CEOs.

edit: Think this is actually the point you're trying to make, though I think you didn't quite nail it.

Re:Addictive Personality? You Might be a Leader by jey on Monday July 25, 2011 @11:15AM (#2802932)
I mis-spoke when I wrote "expect 'addictives' to be CEOs just as often as non-addictives". I meant to write "expect to find 'addictives' amongst the population of CEOs at the same rate at which they occur in the general popluation" or something.

Would've been easier to write it out with math. :P