News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by totalZero on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:24AM (#27960563)
If you have cable TV, you can watch everything at nbcolympics.com/schedule so it’s actually quite accessible. I believe you can watch 30 minutes of content without signing in using your cable account.

Also, the author is wrong. NBC broadcast the opening ceremonies at 7am [0]. The author must have seen a rebroadcast.

[0] https://sports.nbcsports.com/2021/07/23/when-do-the-tokyo-ol...

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by Brendinooo on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:40AM (#27960806)
Came here to say this. They showed it live at 7 AM, on broadcast. No accounts or payment required.

I know some people have issues getting a signal over the air (live in an apartment, too far from source), but usually when I talk to people about broadcast they just have some weird hangup about buying a $10 antenna and connecting it to their television.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by gricardo99 on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:55AM (#27961003)

   they just have some weird hangup about buying a $10 antenna and connecting it to their television.

I think this hang up could be the installation. Where I live you need to mount the antenna at least on an exterior wall, if not the roof to get a clear signal. Then you have to run coax to your TV, through walls, perhaps multiple locations or you can only watch broadcast on that one TV. It’s easily hours of work, including trip to the hardware store, and having the tools. Still worth the one time effort from some, but the barrier is a lot higher than a one time $10 expense.
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by tzs on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:55PM (#27961819)
> Then you have to run coax to your TV, through walls

You can also try under, over, or around the side of a door, or through a window, using a small section of flat coax like this [1].

An alternative I've considered is an Amazon Fire TV Recast [2]. That's an OTA DVR that physically connects to an antenna and power, and then can stream live or recorded content over your Wifi to an Amazon Fire TV Stick plugged into your TV.

With that you only need to get the antenna to wherever you put the Recast. If your antenna was on the roof, for example, you could place the Recast in your attic. Then you only need to go trough one wall or through an attic vent.

I've been wondering if a Recast could reasonably be powered by a battery and put in a waterproof box outside, so that (1) there would be no need to run the antenna wire into the house, and (2) you might not need to tie the antenna ground to the house ground (which can be a real pain if you want to follow code and the places where you can get good reception are nowhere near your house's grounding rod).

[1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01DVKOOA2

[2] https://www.amazon.com/Fire-TV-Recast-over-the-air-DVR-500GB...

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by windexh8er on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:12PM (#27962981)
And if you don't want to deal with Amazon hardware in your home SiliconDust [0] has been doing this for a long time and their products work well.

[0] https://www.silicondust.com/

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by vel0city on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:04PM (#27961135)
So many homes these days had at one point been wired for cable or satellite. The antenna uses the same cabling and often has one or two big splitters to run to each room. Its pretty trivial to change the "source" side of that to the antenna and disconnect unused rooms.
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by treesknees on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:28PM (#27961450)
It's really not that much work. I have a cheap $20 antenna hanging in a window (you could use a suction cup) and I can get almost 40 TV channels.

As far as distribution, I connect my antenna to an HDHomeRun device. I can either stream directly from the device, use a DLNA client on my LAN, or I also have it hooked into Plex server for DVR and live remote viewing.

A basic HDHomeRun device goes for around $100 but I'm sure you can pick up an older model on eBay for less. You could even bridge it into a raspberry pi or some other wifi device so that you don't need to run Ethernet cables around.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by gwoplock on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:40PM (#27961612)
> I have a cheap $20 antenna hanging in a window (you could use a suction cup) and I can get almost 40 TV channels

This doesn't work for everyone. When I put one up, I had to get a $100 directional antenna, a signal booster and mount it in the attic. Even then we had difficulty picking up some stations. Granted our neighborhood is in a big region, a good ways out and in a large depression.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by gruez on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:08PM (#27961173)
> Where I live you need to mount the antenna at least on an exterior wall, if not the roof to get a clear signal

Windows work too, depending on how your room is oriented relative to the nearest broadcast tower.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by pfranz on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:36PM (#27961561)
> they just have some weird hangup about buying a $10 antenna and connecting it to their television.

A few years ago I tried to get OTA to watch the Oscars. This was after the 2009 digital switchover. I did some research and bought a couple different antennas, looked online so they could be directed at the intended tower. I got nothing. It may have been because the signal was blocked by a mountain, but I lived near UCLA in Los Angeles at the time.

With streaming and cable as competition there just isn't incentive on the broadcast and receiving side to set up a good enough system for a lot of people.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by beowulfey on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:54PM (#27961796)
The digital broadcast is great because you can (theoretically) watch any event you want.

As the OP of the article stated, this is actually rather frustrating to do in practice.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by standardUser on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:06PM (#27961159)
I do not know anybody with cable TV. It's like saying "If you have a rotary phone..."
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by partiallypro on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:25PM (#27961415)
Everyone I know sans maybe one person has cable/satellite. So I don't know what future you're living in.

The problem to me is they aren't showing replays that I feel a lot of people want to see on air, so you can't watch at a bar/restaurant. This to me is the major problem with sports on streaming. People like to watch at bars, but bars often don't have streaming devices on hand or a staff that wants to deal with it.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by vernie on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:34PM (#27961520)
Maybe it's a generational thing? I don't know anybody with cable or satellite, not even my parents.
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by matwood on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:44PM (#27961664)
For me it's not generational, but cheaper. Adding the base TV package to my internet is cheaper than no-cap internet alone.

I rarely watch live TV, but it helps that I can use my TV login to stream most of the channels on-demand.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by lotsofpulp on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:45PM (#27961678)
The only people I know with cable/satellite TV subscriptions are 50+ years old who grew up in the US. All my immigrant elders use IPTV boxes now to get their international channels.
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by rufus_foreman on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:33PM (#27966292)
I just turned 50 and I have cable TV for the first time now since I lived with my parents in the 80's. Maybe along with your eyesight and your hearing when you turn 50 you start to lose that part of your mental reasoning that tells you cable TV is a bad idea.

Seriously though, I got tired of switching to different streaming providers when one of them suddenly lost access to some specific content that I was interested in. Cable now is just another streaming content provider.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by partiallypro on Monday July 26, 2021 @10:05PM (#27967803)
I'm not that old though, I'm in the youngest bracket to be paying bills outside of a college student.
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by JohnFen on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:17PM (#27966177)
> Everyone I know sans maybe one person has cable/satellite. So I don't know what future you're living in.

The same one as me, apparently. I don't know a single person who has cable or satellite either.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by chungy on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:47PM (#27961698)
I think the people that have cable/satellite TV are roughly the same ones that still have landline phones.

Sure, it exists, not like there's nobody, but I'm pretty sure it's less than half in total.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by cududa on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:05PM (#27962853)
I can think of tons of people I know with cable and the only person I can think of with a landline is my grandma, and my stepdad’s extremely rural vacation cabin
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by partiallypro on Monday July 26, 2021 @10:02PM (#27967781)
Not true, more than half of the US has cable/satellite subscriptions (~61%). It has shrunk but it is still the majority. I don't buy the argument that "cord cutting" is necessarily less expensive when you add up all the streaming services, especially given streaming services are currently low balling to bring in customers.

In any case, no one has addressed the problem of sports bars/bars being unable to service customers on streaming exclusive events.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by weeblewobble on Monday July 26, 2021 @01:31PM (#27962331)
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by RHSeeger on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:26PM (#27961433)
I know many people with cable, but only 1 with a rotary phone.
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by dragonwriter on Monday July 26, 2021 @01:28PM (#27962285)
> I do not know anybody with cable TV.

AIUI, these things typically described as “if you have cable TV” apply to most cable, satellite, and internet multichannel video programming distributors (so, yes, cable/satellite, but also Youtube TV and similar online services.)

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by thehappypm on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:47PM (#27961693)
My mom lives with me, and she likes cable, so we added it for relatively little to our existing Verizon package. It's nice to be able to log into streaming sites like the NBC Olympics.
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by coopsmoss on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:12PM (#27964785)
I don't know if it's available outside the country. But the CBC is streaming everything online, no login required.

They have streams with commentary for the major events that they are televising but you can also watch the raw international streams with no commentary for everything else.

The streams are recorded and available at any time too.

If it's available in the US, or you have a VPN, I'd look into that.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by kevinwang on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:09PM (#27961180)
> If you have cable TV, you can watch everything at nbcolympics.com/schedule so it’s actually quite accessible.

This is the site mentioned and linked to in the article as a "site where you can actually watch live. And they have replays… of preliminary matches"

I've also found out to be quite good-- not sure why the author is so negative of it.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by asciimov on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:57PM (#27961845)
Because it is hard to find, not very well advertised, and isn't free unless you have a cable provider (youtube tv does work).

For me, I had Youtube TV record everything, but NBC doesn't show everything, and its completely US centric coverage (I like watching the competition). On demand wasn't helpful either.

I tried Peacock (NBC's app) thinking that's where they were hiding all of their coverage. And again not everything is there, and much of it is behind paywall.

Fortunately, my wife clicked on the Olympics section of our Roku and it prompted us to install the NBC Olympics app. Then I had to sign into it, because it only provides 30 mins of viewing without a cable plan. On top of that they are injecting a lot of commercials into the programming, so I'm not sure why they couldn't air all of it for free (with commercials)

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by lotsofpulp on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:36AM (#27960740)
Requiring the purchase of an unrelated product for no reason other than padding subscriber numbers for NBC’s benefit qualifies as “making it difficult”.
Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by totalZero on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:45AM (#27960870)
Several of the tv stations broadcasting the olympics are on cable (eg USA). I understand the desire to watch for free, but cable is certainly not an unrelated product here.

If you have a raspberry pi you can probably set up a vpn at a house with cable and watch it that way. For my provider I think they simply match the IP to the ISP (the login was automatic).

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by lotsofpulp on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:51AM (#27960955)
Cable is unrelated if you have access to broadband internet and the digital video signals are being transmitted via the internet.

Cable is only related if you own a cable company and want to continue making money for being an unnecessary middleman.

Re:Why does NBC make it so difficult to watch the Olympics? by quickthrowman on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:50AM (#27960947)
Comcast owns NBC and directly benefits from cable subscriptions. NBC also owns all the rights and doesn’t have to put stuff on the cable channels it owns. That’s why people are complaining.