News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by noduerme on Monday July 26, 2021 @02:20AM (#27956272)
> Being anti smoking worked

Really? About 30% of adults still smoke where I live, and all the teens and 20-somethings use vape pens. What's the definition of "worked" in this context?

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by jjav on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:28AM (#27957396)
> What's the definition of "worked" in this context?

Back in the 80s you couldn't go out to anywhere (bars, pubs, restaurants, music clubs, pool houses, etc) without coming back with every piece of clothing stinking to smoke. The percentage of people smoking in public was so high that there was no way to avoid this, other than stay home.

Today (and for the last ~20 years or so) I haven't smelled cigarette smoke in ages and haven't seen anyone anywhere smoking. Public smoking has completely disappeared (California here). I see cigarettes are still for sale in convenience stores so someone must be buying them, but I guess they all smoke at home only now. So the anti-smoking campaign has worked exceedingly well.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by ido on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:23AM (#27957743)
This was definitely still the case in at least Vienna and Berlin as late as the '00s and early '10s (lived in vienna 2005-2012 and in Berlin 2013-current).

It's better now but not to the point that I haven't smelled cigarette smoke or haven't seen people smoking!

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by ornornor on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:33AM (#27957417)
I wish it was as successful in Europe. People here smoke so much and almost anywhere. it’s banned indoors though, but smoking in a playground or while holding your baby in the other arm is perfectly fine and socially acceptable.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by pedrosorio on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:28AM (#27957048)
In the US, 14% of adults smoke. In California it’s under 12%. Among households with an income above $100k it’s 7% [0].

If you belong to a certain demographic that is prevalent in this forum (upper middle class in California), the above is pretty much true. I can’t think of any person I regularly interact with who smokes.

Globally, it’s a matter of time.

[0] https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/adul...

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by noduerme on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:43AM (#27957135)
I looked up the official rate where I live (18.1%), but I find it hard to believe, since virtually everyone I know smokes, at least casually. And the few who don't smoke, vape.

Why do you care? Everyone knows the risks by now. It's never going away. You should find better things to do with your time than trying to control other people's behavior.

Also, I'm originally from Cali and I make over $100k a year, but I'm hardly a unicorn since all my California friends bum cigarettes from me whenever I see them, even though they all "quit" years ago. California is just a miserable habitat where you can't enjoy a beer and a smoke at the same time unless you belong to a private club. And they all lie on the surveys.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by pedrosorio on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:26AM (#27957385)
Why do I care? I grew up in Portugal with asthma at a time when indoor smoking was allowed and prevalent.

The progress in the past few decades has been amazing for my quality of life and that of all other people (specially children with smoking parents) who were regularly subjected to 2nd hand smoke from a young age through no fault of their own.

EDIT: also it’s unclear to me how you got the message that I was “trying to control other people’s behavior” from my first comment

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by noduerme on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:03AM (#27957612)
I'm fine with bars banning smoking based on the owner's preference, but I think there is value in having places where people can congregate to smoke and drink, and I don't believe some people who don't like it have the right to ban other people from doing it everywhere. This is also in response to the other post above who said it had negative social and economic impacts. We pay extremely high taxes on tobacco to more than cover those costs. I personally don't smoke around children. But nothing is enough for some crusaders who want to prevent me from enjoying tobacco. It's the same impulse as people who want to ban alcohol or marijuana. Adults should have the right to do as they please so long as it isn't hurting others, and no, smelling diffused secondhand smoke outdoors is not giving you cancer any more than the exhaust from the cars or the fallout from Fukushima.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by wizzwizz4 on Monday July 26, 2021 @07:45AM (#27958260)
> smelling diffused secondhand smoke outdoors is not giving you cancer any more than the exhaust from the cars

Bad analogy (or, rather, reasonable analogy, but it's not making the point you're trying to make). And smoking's a bigger concern for asthmatics; have you taken that into account?

> and I don't believe some people who don't like it have the right to ban other people from doing it everywhere

If you can smoke without polluting everybody's air, then sure, go ahead. Otherwise, please don't.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by noduerme on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @01:04AM (#27968845)
Can you fart without polluting everybody's air? If so I'm sure I can light a cigarette. But to paraphrase Kansas... everyone's a fart in the wind
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by wizzwizz4 on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @03:28PM (#27976508)
> Can you fart without polluting everybody's air?

Nope, but I adjust my diet to minimise the impact of my farting, and it pollutes the air much less. Plus, my farts aren't responsible for respiratory illnesses.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by Nursie on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:33AM (#27960692)
> Adults should have the right to do as they please so long as it isn't hurting others

Business owners don't get to decide that for their staff, is why it's banned in businesses too.

You don't pay taxes to cover the health effects you have on other people.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by noduerme on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:10PM (#27968214)
So make the staff sign a contract and give them hazard pay. It's no worse than working in a popcorn factory.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by Nursie on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @04:12AM (#27969887)
Making people who need work sign a contract which might result in them getting cancer is not something that society has generally deemed ethical.

FYI - the harmful stuff in popcorn has been identified and removed too, because we don't let popcorn workers sign up to die either.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by noduerme on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @09:21AM (#27972060)
Not every workplace has to be made ideal for every person seeking a job. Just because you might not want to work at a deep fryer doesn't mean we should ban fried food. If you're a vegan, don't work at a steakhouse. If you're opposed to sex, you don't have to work in the sex industry, but that's no reason why we should ban it or drive sex workers into the underground economy. The same is true for places where people want to smoke.

Also - it's only unethical if you don't know what you're signing up for. The whole point of disclosure and hazard pay is to let adults choose whether to do something dangerous. Humans can decide if they want to do something or not. This whole idea that no one has a choice and everyone is a victim of circumstances is ridiculous (not to mention lazy, whiny, and ultimately futile).

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by Nursie on Tuesday July 27, 2021 @05:47PM (#27978069)
> Just because you might not want to work at a deep fryer doesn't mean we should ban fried food.

AFAIK deep fryers don't give you cancer just by working around them.

> This whole idea that no one has a choice

People on low incomes with families to feed don't. Hope that helps you have some empathy.

We, as a society, have chosen their health over your smoking.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by addicted on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:03PM (#27961126)
> value in having places where people can congregate to smoke and drink

Call them home. Why do you think other people should be subject to the dangerous conditions you're imposing on them? Not just patrons but also workers.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by noduerme on Monday July 26, 2021 @11:04PM (#27968189)
I worked for a couple years in a coffeehouse that allowed illegal smoking after 9pm. I smoked. The owner smoked. Cops came in on their midnight break and smoked. You wouldn't have gone there, let alone worked there, if you didn't smoke. So tell me, why should that be illegal? So you can go there and everyone else has to go home?

Once the city cracked down on it, a few mothers with babies showed up for awhile to show that they really had always wanted to go there. Then it was empty and it went out of business. So why can't you stand the idea of a place existing where you wouldn't want to go, but other people might want to go? I don't go to orgies or to burning man, but I don't feel the need to shut them down.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by ornornor on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:37AM (#27957436)
I care because 1. I don’t want to get cancer or damage my health as a result of smokers‘ poor life choices, 2. smokers diseases costs everyone a ton of money (universal healthcare or not, the premiums have to at least cover the costs), 3. there are many children who get to breath their parents second hand smoke who will develop health problems later or even a nicotine addiction as a result of their parents‘ poor life choices.

It’s not just a matter of life and let live. One smoker on a terrasse or park ruins it for the 20 others who don’t smoke but get to breathe in the stench and the carcinogens.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by wildrhythms on Monday July 26, 2021 @10:02AM (#27959453)
Smoking directly affects non-smokers; either secondhand smoke wafting in the direction of non-smokers, or discarded cigarette butts littered about. I remember being a child riding into town with my aunt and uncle who smoked in the car with the windows up and not being able to articulate that I couldn't breathe. Smoking should not exist.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by pizza234 on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:30AM (#27957063)
Some time ago I spoke with a Norwegian, who told me that smoking is socially perceived as negative, to the point that it may happen that somebody ends a date because they find that the other person smokes.

They've told it's been due to successfull campaigning against smoking. I'm very surprised, but if it this is accurate, it shows that a cultural shift is possible.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by SXX on Monday July 26, 2021 @04:52AM (#27957183)
Let's say you're not smoking. Wouldn't you end a date with a smoking person? Because as I see it smoking is a big deal if you're looking for a partner for more than one night.

And I'm personally not exactly anti-smoking person since I can smoke hookah few times a year. But I still can't imagine being together with a person that smoke daily. I can only imagine how bad this can be for a person who actually hate the smell.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by lotsofpulp on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:14PM (#27961270)
I am in my mid 30s now, and even 15 years ago in big US coastal cities I grew up and worked in, smoking was very rare amongst my peers in the white collar office workforce, and absolutely a reason to not date someone.

I can smell cigarette smoke on people’s clothes and the tar lingers and sticks to the walls, so I would not even want them in my house.

Vaping and marijuana do not have the lingering smell problem though, probably because there is no tar or whatever else causes the odors to stick.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by Nursie on Monday July 26, 2021 @05:34AM (#27957418)
> About 30% of adults still smoke where I live

Where is that? In some places it's dropped precipitously since measures have been taken. The UK, USA, New Zealand and Australia have adult smoking figures of 13-14%. Continental Europe seems to have much higher rates, with the exception of Sweden, and the rest of the world still seems to have it pretty bad.

> all the teens and 20-somethings use vape pens

Which isn't smoking... It's not ideal, but it's not anywhere near as bad.

Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by kewrkewm53 on Monday July 26, 2021 @07:29AM (#27958146)
Sweden's lower rate can be explained by snus. Too bad that the rest of Europe bans sales of this product, which unlike cigarette smoke does not cause harm to anyone else but the user.
Re:Don't Be Anti Car. Be Pro Something Else. by tonyedgecombe on Monday July 26, 2021 @03:26AM (#27956653)
It's down to 14% in the UK, falling from 45% in the seventies.