Like, with locally made solar panels you have some high paying jobs and those people will spend that money locally. With foreign made solar panels you have low paying warehouse and distribution jobs moving around foreign goods and most money goes overseas.
So yeah 10x cost is maybe still too much. But I suppose the actual figure depends on how value is calculated. I think it’s kinda wild the USA invested billions to build factories in China and now they can produce cheap goods and regular people in the USA can barely afford to live.
I think that, in order to formulate a strategy to promote some set of objectives, as you are trying to do, you must first have a correct factual understanding of the causal relations of cause and effect that relate to those objectives. Whatever strategy you formulate will only have a tendency to promote your objectives, whatever they are, to the extent that your factual understanding of the causal structure of the system you are trying to affect is correct. Therefore, factual analysis of the relevant causal structure is epistemologically prior to any such normative analysis of strategies.
If your factual understanding is sufficiently incorrect, as in Tales of the Black Freighter, the strategy you formulate can easily have the opposite effect of what you intend. This is especially likely if your factual beliefs are being manipulated by other players whose objectives do not align with your own; this article seems to be an attempt at such manipulation.
1) That you weren't talking about normative issues. I get that. Normative issues have been on my mind lately and I wanted to add my thoughts.
The rest of your comment seems plainly true so I wasn't sure what to say really.
2) I must understand the facts properly in order to succeed. If I do not understand the facts, I or others will suffer unintended consequences. This is clearly true.
3) I must work to understand and counteract propaganda from others. I first began to question my beliefs after listening to Noam Chomsky. Clear critiques of the structures of power and how they affect the media and propaganda are key aspects of his philosophy, so I am aware of this.
> I probably should have put more effort into clarifying it, though that probably would have made it a lot longer.
Personally I think you could make it clearer by using fewer, simpler words. But I speak using simple clear words so of course I would think that. Anyway I don't mean to sound too critical, just sharing my thoughts.
But I agree, of course, that these are not to be counted on.
Because typical businesses are making decisions for themselves, and not their whole industry or economy?
Colluding with other businesses to try to achieve a collective goal might well even be illegal.
I assume you understand the reasons there are people who live in an apartment on disability without working, but others are homeless. You may want to spell it out to make sure we are on the same page.
I'm wondering if you are drawing on specific personal experience and think you understand the crux of the problem. Could you state it if so.
>People are dying because they can't afford medical bills.
Which implies that EMTALA, Medicare, Medicaid, the ACA, etc. are insufficient, so do you have a specific gap and/or thing to fill the gap in mind?
>It's worth asking ourselves if we're really doing the right thing.
Saying that to a random person on the internet kind of implies you don't think most people ask themselves that all the time.
I'm inclined to assume virtually everyone does.
Take a look:
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLP0dfLFk-anf00e9_YBWy83SW...
I recently had a conversation with someone about this who is a libertarian capitalist, and they found a few videos I shared intriguing, so I've just put them into a playlist to share with you. It starts with a 2 minute video that describes things in high level terms and then subsequent videos provide more detail. I think you might like it!
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLP0dfLFk-anf00e9_YBWy...
Kids, your money is broken. Money is the mirror image of debt and someone took that mirror image hostage. You still need the mirror image. The only thing you can do is shrug and create a new mirror image by creating new debt until the day the hostage is returned.
What if you don't want to create new debt? Rescue the hostage. That will never happen because people will deny reality for as long as possible. It actually takes someone who will force reality upon you, either the US government or the Fed. The former is prone to denying reality as well. The latter is unable to force reality onto people.
If denying reality is the fundamental problem then no ideology will ever fix it. Communism will suffer from other problems because it is just a different mechanism, it didn't change the humans that are part of it.
So getting people to face reality is a key part of making the necessary changes. This is why all revolutionary ideologies include education as one of the first steps. So yes, if you cannot educate then you cannot make changes which require voluntary collective agreement. But I don't think it's impossible to educate. The real problem is that counter-revolutionary forces have a lot of money and power to "educate" in their own way, and manipulate us in to accepting unjust systems.
In its simplest form, anarchism is a process of questioning existing power structures. And some are legitimate and can be justified. But those that have no legitimate purpose must be dismantled. Libertarian communism is a method of organization that aims to build a foundation for an economy without massive power imbalances.
Really, I'd encourage you to look at the playlist I linked in my above comment, and let me know what you think.
Seems rather like reporting about what happens in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicon_Saxony
Besides that we had some form of solar cell production here, only to outsource it to China decades ago. Much to the lamenting of the locals. Same for wind turbines. It's all embedded in the pork cycle/boom-bust scheme embedded in the maze of federal/state subsidies, policies and whatnot else.
German manufacturing obeys far, far more stringent environmental parameters and is consequently more expensive. Its worth paying the premium if we want solar because of the climate.
One significant difference between environmental regulatory regimes in Germany and China is that in Germany there is no death penalty for polluters.
Regardless, my comment wasn't about what would be good or bad or what was worth paying or whether the environmental costs of Chinese PV manufacturing are 9% higher than those of Europe or 13% higher or 90% lower, and according to what measures (information you somehow seem to have forgotten to include in your comment too). It was about what economic circumstances must obtain for local production of PV modules to be economically competitive with modules shipped in from overseas, whether the modules are shipped from Germany, from China, or from Indonesia.
Please stop. That is behavior unbecoming of the dignity of a human being.
But in general, I firmly believe that western nations with high social, environmental, legal standards cannot compete with China, except in areas where China didn't yet have the chance to catch up for some reason. I think we are going back to a world where most nations know how to produce almost everything, so competition will no longer be on that knowledge but more on the other necessary factors to make production cheaper.
There's the Ricardian comparative advantage argument: even if, say, China can produce N95 masks more efficiently than the US, the US might still be able to export N95 masks to China, if all the Chinese are so busy producing more profitable products like solar panels and microchips that they don't have time to also produce N95 masks, as manifested by Chinese wages rising too high for N95-mask factories to produce N95 masks at competitive prices.
However, this does not seem to be the case at present. If anything, the situation is reversed: there are things Germany imports from China, even though Germany could make them domestically from less inputs, because German wages are higher than Chinese wages.
It's possible that the German factory that paid for this PR puff-piece will be able to bring their cost to within 10% of that of Chinese vendors, or even lower. If that happens, the result won't be a world of locally-produced solar modules; the result will be a world of German-produced solar modules, and there may be articles in the Chinese press lamenting how China is now importing PV modules from Germany.
Generally things are locally produced when shipping costs, tariffs, or risks would make overseas-produced versions economically uncompetitive. Potable water (0.03¢/kg) is usually locally produced at the 10km scale. Construction sand (3¢/kg) and aggregate (1¢/kg) and liquid oxygen and nitrogen are locally produced at the 100km scale. (The liquid gases are expensive to ship because they boil off during shipping.) Portland cement (10¢/kg), natural gas, and electrical energy are locally produced at the 1000km scale. Things that cost more than US$1/kg are, by and large, not locally produced.
PV modules cost about US$2/kg, so if shipping costs stay the same and war doesn't break out, we shouldn't expect to see them locally produced in non-protectionist countries until their price falls by another order of magnitude or so, maybe in 8–16 years.
______
† I think the real number is closer to 5% than 10% (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26598814), but the article carefully avoided including any objectively verifiable numbers so we could find out whether I'm overlooking something.