News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are locally produced solar modules the future? by kragen on Saturday July 24, 2021 @05:51PM (#27944762)
You're talking about what promotes the welfare of society, fundamentally a normative question hinging on our conception of "welfare", while I was talking about what the patterns of world trade are and will be in the future, and what causes affect them, a factual question. I did not intend to deprecate the importance of skilled factory jobs to the welfare of society. In fact, my comment didn't touch on normative questions at all.

I think that, in order to formulate a strategy to promote some set of objectives, as you are trying to do, you must first have a correct factual understanding of the causal relations of cause and effect that relate to those objectives. Whatever strategy you formulate will only have a tendency to promote your objectives, whatever they are, to the extent that your factual understanding of the causal structure of the system you are trying to affect is correct. Therefore, factual analysis of the relevant causal structure is epistemologically prior to any such normative analysis of strategies.

If your factual understanding is sufficiently incorrect, as in Tales of the Black Freighter, the strategy you formulate can easily have the opposite effect of what you intend. This is especially likely if your factual beliefs are being manipulated by other players whose objectives do not align with your own; this article seems to be an attempt at such manipulation.

Re:Are locally produced solar modules the future? by TaylorAlexander on Sunday July 25, 2021 @05:53PM (#27953273)
I gotta be honest your comment is difficult to read. I know what all the words mean, but your sentence structure and word choice make it seem to me to be overly complicated. Idk if it's just because I am a non-academic. Anyway just wanted to give you my honest feedback.
Re:Are locally produced solar modules the future? by kragen on Sunday July 25, 2021 @07:02PM (#27953748)
I can't disagree. I probably should have put more effort into clarifying it, though that probably would have made it a lot longer. Still, I think you'll find it rewarding to work through it to understand what it's saying. You might try thinking of the examples of the phenomena it describes that I should have included—and counterexamples.
Re:Are locally produced solar modules the future? by TaylorAlexander on Sunday July 25, 2021 @09:12PM (#27954465)
Sure. I mean I understand what you are saying.

1) That you weren't talking about normative issues. I get that. Normative issues have been on my mind lately and I wanted to add my thoughts.

The rest of your comment seems plainly true so I wasn't sure what to say really.

2) I must understand the facts properly in order to succeed. If I do not understand the facts, I or others will suffer unintended consequences. This is clearly true.

3) I must work to understand and counteract propaganda from others. I first began to question my beliefs after listening to Noam Chomsky. Clear critiques of the structures of power and how they affect the media and propaganda are key aspects of his philosophy, so I am aware of this.

> I probably should have put more effort into clarifying it, though that probably would have made it a lot longer.

Personally I think you could make it clearer by using fewer, simpler words. But I speak using simple clear words so of course I would think that. Anyway I don't mean to sound too critical, just sharing my thoughts.

Re:Are locally produced solar modules the future? by ttjjtt on Monday July 26, 2021 @12:52AM (#27955812)
As a counter feedback, I found your post an enjoyably clear read. Different cognitive styles perhaps.
Re:Are locally produced solar modules the future? by kragen on Monday July 26, 2021 @06:11PM (#27966136)
I'm glad you enjoyed it!
Re:Are locally produced solar modules the future? by johncowan on Sunday July 25, 2021 @06:25PM (#27953519)
In fact, your strategy can forward your goals with no causal connection to what you want to change, either by sheer luck, or because your rhetoric inspires people to do the Right Thing by some completely different means.

But I agree, of course, that these are not to be counted on.

Re:Are locally produced solar modules the future? by state_less on Saturday July 24, 2021 @08:42PM (#27945631)
I am happy to see a friendly competition to reduce CO2. It’d be cool to see people questioning in the papers about why they can’t be more environmentally friendly.
[dead]
Re:Are locally produced solar modules the future? by kragen on Saturday July 24, 2021 @09:38PM (#27945906)
If you don't know what those words mean, you can look them up in a dictionary. If you're looking to make fun of people for knowing things you don't, whether words or anything else, maybe you're on the wrong website. Or in the wrong species.