News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday July 23, 2021 @12:36AM (#27927250)
Articles is from July 8th. This is a fast moving story.

The current state of affairs (from Muse Group's perspective) is here: https://github.com/audacity/audacity/discussions/1353 (published today)

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by infogulch on Friday July 23, 2021 @01:46AM (#27927612)
This seems like a reasonable and thorough response. They revised and cut unnecessary bits and added clarification where possible within a reasonable time frame for these matters. Good job.

I really don't get the wailing and gnashing of teeth against even the principle of adding update checking and error reporting features. Real, regular people will get tangible benefits from these features. Their scope is so limited and implementation (now) drawn down to such a sharp point I can't really sympathize with a hard-line counterposition that these features must be defacto evil.

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by TeMPOraL on Friday July 23, 2021 @02:21AM (#27927781)
The "wailing and gnashing of teeth" is against updates and error checking being opt-out, or even not opt-outable at all.

Sometimes this gets mixed with observations that telemetry and auto-updates are modern-day antipatterns, encouraging bad software development practices and resulting in subpar products.

Personally, I feel that a ToS/privacy policy for Audacity would be more palatable if it explicitly limited scope of data collection to optional features of update checks and error reports.

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by rhizome on Friday July 23, 2021 @03:26PM (#27934627)
The question of data collection could use a little reverse consideration: what could Audacity possibly collect that would be of interest to law enforcement? The only thing I can think of is IP address with a timestamp (which I'm not sure would be admissible as evidence anywhere) given their current stance, or....more? They want to add video so they have to be prepared for e.g. pedo interest? The circumstances in the movie "Blow Up?" I really can't think of anything from the real world.

Beyond that, there's nothing that requires them to allow for this in their TOS. There's no loose end by not including it; it's not a 't' to be crossed or an 'i' to be dotted.

I'm eager to be corrected, but I just don't see why they'd need to change the TOS at all except to replace some ownership info.

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by infogulch on Friday July 23, 2021 @07:44PM (#27937014)
I had a big comment drafted but I'm realizing that I'm basically copy-pasting the whole policy and comments (as said elsewhere itt, "Everything is now as opt-in as it can be expected to be"), so it would be quicker and more accurate to ask you to just read the new privacy notice directly to see that everything you asked for and more is already present. It's quite readable:

https://www.audacityteam.org/about/desktop-privacy-notice/

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by bmn__ on Friday July 23, 2021 @07:47AM (#27929625)
You have to come up with the modicum of empathy to put yourself in the shoes of the users to be able to understand why they are angry.

• You must acknowledge that privacy is a basic human right.¹ Maybe you were brought up in a culture where these rights don't count; well, here's your opportunity to learn and grow. Maybe you have simply forgotten your school lessons, that's not good and the blame falls squarely on your shoulders then.

• The users were promised UI improvements and an eighth zoom button, instead they got malicious software and bad treatment from the new owners.

• Look at what Muse originally planned, not what they compromised to after the public push-back.

• There is a person at Muse named Daniel Ray who is a sociopath and lacks the basic decency/internal filter in communicating with other people and utter lack of self-preservation for avoiding bad consequences for himself, such that he thinks that threatening a software developer on public Github with doxxing him into the gulag is an acceptable thing to do.

¹ Let's see how these rephrases violating some other human rights feel: "I really don't get the wailing and gnashing of teeth against even the principle of forced castration and hysterectomy." "I really don't get the wailing and gnashing of teeth against even the principle of trading and using chattel slaves."

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by Karunamon on Friday July 23, 2021 @01:45AM (#27927605)
From the Github thread:

>I have been doing 3.0.3 Release Candidate testing and all seems good:

>a) error and crash reporting are one-off opt-in each time you get such a dialog,

>b) the update checking dialog that you get on initial launch of 3.0.3 enables you to turn off update checking in Application prefs BEFORE you hit the OK button - and thus no data is sent.

Everything is now as opt-in as it can be expected to, and the privacy policy has nothing untoward in it. I'm not super happy with how long it took to get to this point, but at least the wound has been debrided.

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by mastazi on Friday July 23, 2021 @01:46AM (#27927616)
> We have removed the provision that discourages children under 13 years old from using Audacity

This point is very important. Like many other open source projects, Audacity is used in a very large number of education-related projects. Having 13 as the minimum age was going to be a huge problem.

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by papishow on Friday July 23, 2021 @02:14AM (#27927754)
I agree, but if memory servers correct they are lying here. Or at least being extremely disingenuous. They didn't discourage children under 13 years old from using Audacity. They forbade children under 13 years old from using Audacity.
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by viraptor on Friday July 23, 2021 @03:14AM (#27928070)
That's not correct. The actual quote was:

> The App we provide is not intended for individuals below the age of 13. If you are under 13 years old, please do not use the App.

They did not forbid it.

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by okamiueru on Friday July 23, 2021 @03:25AM (#27928128)
That's a very interesting nuance. What does "please do not" mean in this context, and could its intended effect be?
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by Gravityloss on Friday July 23, 2021 @06:07AM (#27929023)
What's the motivation for age being mentioned at all?
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by p_l on Friday July 23, 2021 @09:30AM (#27930419)
Because children couldn't be a party to the privacy policy involved in the surveillance
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by Gravityloss on Friday July 23, 2021 @11:39AM (#27931927)
Could it be made so that only adults could opt in?
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by rhizome on Friday July 23, 2021 @03:33PM (#27934708)
Legally in the US, adults are the only people that TOS applies to. Minors can't enter into contracts, of which a TOS is one.
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by papishow on Friday July 23, 2021 @05:04AM (#27928676)
Thank you for that correction, it seems I have been led astray by some interesting reporting then.
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by heurisko on Friday July 23, 2021 @05:53AM (#27928957)
"Please do not use the App" is forbidding use of the app.
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by 2Gkashmiri on Friday July 23, 2021 @05:34AM (#27928864)
I need to understand. Lets say I have an inquisitive 8 year old kid at home who does arduino and pi and 3d printing and Python and now even does YouTube and stuff. They are saying now that they have implemented telemetry that a resident offline software cannot be used by aged 13 and below? Why?

What has the law to do with offline apps on a personal computer owned by a family home when the machine is supposed to be "family machine". The next thing you know windows will forbid ages 13 and below from using their products?

Its not like there are dangers of pedos by using audacity? What about "YouTube kids"? How is that allowed when its online with automated content moderation but audacity is not for kids?

Re:Another misstep for Audacity by jeeva on Friday July 23, 2021 @06:56AM (#27929312)
As I read it this was (based on the previous revision of the policy) - "we're planning to store some data on all users, with no way to opt out. However, in some regions, we cannot/shouldn't store data on people who are 13 or under. So, if you're 13 or under, please don't use this software as we'll be storing data on you."
Re:Another misstep for Audacity by ChrisArchitect on Friday July 23, 2021 @10:32AM (#27931090)
correct

and it was shared 2 weeks ago also. Best to move along to more current developments.

Discussion on the mentioned Latest Update https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27927407