I am leading BizDev at Payflow, I joined due to ethical reasons & social impact. Happen to be that I am southamerican and pretty familiar with people living paycheck to paycheck.
The reason why they are better off is because we are the only alternative that is free for them: Credit cards, loans, etc are not zero-rate. Far from that a loanshark can charge up to 3000% for a short term loan in LATAM.
We are bringing employers into the game, to actually do something and pay so that their employees get the zero-rate that is so popular for high income workers through their cards or banks.
What reduces your purchasing power is financial expenses, not accessing your money earlier.
We won't solve every money problem, but at least we are solving some and reducing low income workers exposure to predatory finance.
Hope you appreciate my answer, it was 100% sincere. Fede :)
People that have infrequent issues where they need to juggle money around could use this. They could also simply save money, since the implication here is that they have enough money but not at the right time. This is a nice option for them to have, though. I would also expect people in this category to have access to non-exploitative methods of financing. If they don't have savings, they probably at least have assets for use as collateral in a loan to get the interest rate down.
For others, they have frequent issues where they have to juggle money around. Their problem is cash flow, not the timing. They're going to continue to fall behind on their bills. They get a $500 paycheck, and have $450 in bills. They need $250 to fix their car, so they take it out. When their paycheck comes, they get $250 and can't pay the other $200 in bills. The late fees on their $200 bill they can't pay are going to stack up to eat the $50/month they could have saved. They're still paying financial expenses, they're just in late fees instead of interest.
credit-worthy people can easily fix this issue with credit cards, which fix the paid-in-arrears issue, and also smooth out spiky intra-month cashflow. but I can see this product being very useful for people who can't get credit cards or don't feel responsible enough to use one.
This is extremely paternalistic and shows how little you automatically think of someone who isn't paid a lot of money. You think that people who don't have money, their problem must be budgeting ("stop eating all that avocado toast!!"), so you need to slowly ration out their money "for their own good." Complete ideological BS.
Providing more competitive and safe and professional options can only help, it can't make an already-bad situation worse.
The only situation worse than having to take a payday loan is not being able to shop for a decent vendor who isn't trying to screw you.
I think the idea is that it helps people avoids predatory payday loans. If Bob needed 50% of his pay for an emergency, he could go to a payday loan and end up spending a whole paycheck or more just paying it back over time.
The solution is government regulation and societal safety nets, not this, but if one’s government doesn’t fix the problem, there’s not much you can do besides this.
The two week (or so) delay between hours worked and money being deposited in your bank account is a free loan from you to your employer. That's wrong. People should be free to access their earned income as soon as they earn it.
I do agree that this sort of product can easily become a payday loan system with terrible rates, but streaming your wages as you make them sounds like a pure good.
$5000? The median pre-tax income in the US is only $2854/month. https://www.ssa.gov/oact/cola/central.html
Op is probably in NY or SF where that doesn't even make you middle class and people who make double that still don't feel rich. $2854 a month would be absolute poverty wages in many parts of the country.
Conversely my company has announced it's not going back to the office ever. I'm tempted to go back to Tennessee where I can live live a king on my California middle class income.
I don't even take home 5K/month and I'm a professional software dev. Granted the reason is I am maxing out every pre-tax savings plan I can (retirement, HSA, etc.) but the notion that a 22 year old couple should be getting 120k/yr for doing nothing is absurd.
Yes this is "enough" but no, it is not enough (especially after having worked and lived for a few years in a medium/low cost of living city).
That being said, $5k/month for "basic expenses" is definitely ridiculous. NYC/SF COL is like 30% more expensive than where I'm living, not a full 2.8x more expensive for basic expenses.
Edit: Also worth noting that in this context the $5k/month is spendable, so in SF for example this translates to about $82k/year pre-tax income, which according to the 2019 census is well above the median individual income of ~$52k.
Assuming that not everyone can be successful in life (in spite of having boatloads of IQ + work ethic) UBI might be one of the few ways left to reduce generational in-equality. Don't get me wrong - I am no fan of socialism/communism and I understand the problems that come with a collectivist mindset. But I am also practical. I certainly don't want to live in a dystopia where a select few "masters of the universe" type rule over vast swathe of humanity.
Then it would have to be funded with local taxes. Why should people with a median salary pay taxes so that someone can get a UBI that is higher than the median salary?
>Assuming that not everyone can be successful in life (in spite of having boatloads of IQ + work ethic) UBI might be one of the few ways left to reduce generational in-equality.
Or you could just get rid of money hoarding and land hoarding. Just think about it. The time people spend unemployed or underemployed is gone but the money isn't. Thus the value of the claim to labor (money) is greater than what the economy can support. The inevitable result is inequality just from a pure logical perspective. The conventional solution had been to just let the economy grow endlessly so that the economy becomes strong enough to support all the freeloaders. Alternatively you let inflation act as a soft default on that unsustainable claim to labor.
https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/08/27/754323652/the-...
Instead of jumping to straight UBI we need to build an abundance of housing that is of good quality, affordable to build, is operated by the state and is available to everyone regardless of income on a cost plus model. Also given that rent is most people's single biggest expense we could take the pressure off the poor. This plan however is politically untenable as affordable housing is something that anyone who owes money on their home does not want
since you're willing to take incremental steps, perhaps we could have the state stop preventing cheap housing from existing, first.
it's not even legal to rent out decent, clean, individual rooms in many places.
>Workers living from pay check to pay check have traditionally been vulnerable to exploitation
And the proposed solution doesn't fix that. Most of those people don't have a problem with unexpected expense once a year. They don't budget and are short on cash every month. So now imagine Bob needs money halfway through the month. He takes out 50% of his pay. He uses is for immediate needs and than has to live at 50% of his pay for the next 1.5 month.
How is his situation any better?
Also I can 100% guarantee you, most people working in this space are working on loans for those users. They don't plan to stay as just company benefit. But even if you will 100% never do that I just don't the see advertised benefit for the workers.
This is just something that sound nice when you don't think too much about it. That explains why the companies are eager to implement this benefit at their companies. At the end the workers will struggle just as much and the struggle will stay hidden from the eyes of the employers, because of the financial problems stigma.