News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by goler on Thursday July 22, 2021 @01:41AM (#27915776)
Are the associated costs passed to ratepayers at cost or is there some allowance for a positive investment return for PG&E shareholders?
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by bcrosby95 on Thursday July 22, 2021 @01:44AM (#27915798)
In theory rate hikes have to go through California regulators but, at the same time, the company is allowed a certain rate of return.

In practice I have no clue how it works out though.

Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by tomrod on Thursday July 22, 2021 @01:47AM (#27915813)
Typically in markets like CA and TX you will have a rate case go to the public utility commission. I'm more familiar with Texas' approach (it was a data source for my dissertation); the idea is to let the companies charge enough to cover reasonable costs.
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by black_puppydog on Thursday July 22, 2021 @02:13AM (#27915953)
Shouldn't "won't be sued for negligence" cover the investment, given that they know their equipment is a fire hazard?
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by jlmorton on Thursday July 22, 2021 @02:17AM (#27915977)
No, it won't, because PG&E doesn't have the money to do this, and the company is already majority-owned by the PG&E Fire Victim Trust after emerging from bankruptcy.

There are no rich shareholders to foist the costs on. No investors are going to pay tens of billions of dollars, more profit than PG&E generated over several decades, to pay for 10% of the electric wires to be buried. If there were any investors on the hook for this, they would simply declare bankruptcy and walk away.

The only option here is that the costs are paid by ratepayers, or taxpayers. There is no other option available.

Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by black_puppydog on Thursday July 22, 2021 @02:30AM (#27916060)
I see, thanks for explaining. That would have made for a nice addition to the article. :)

IMHO an infrastructure of this size & importance might just as well be state owned, but I guess rate hikes will also do. As long as there is some mechanism to help (yes, probably with tax money) those who might not be able to afford them...

Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by amotinga on Thursday July 22, 2021 @02:38AM (#27916118)
in that case why have owners at all? it should basically be nationalized then. otherwise taxpayer paying the cost without really reaping profits (if there are/will be any)
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by stickfigure on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:09AM (#27916284)
Because government-run electric utilities are a mixed bag too. "Public" utility monopolies like PG&E are an attempt to get some of the benefits of a market system from what is fundamentally a government service. The utility can raise money from investors, who expect a modest but stable return. In theory, the profit motive gives the utility an incentive to keep costs in check.

It's far from perfect, but actually-public utilities are responsible for a lot of disasters too. It's not obvious that nationalizing PG&E would be good for anyone.

Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by zbrozek on Thursday July 22, 2021 @06:53AM (#27917438)
Except they have regulated profit margins - it's cost-plus. So they have an incentive to make everything as expensive as possible to maximize their take. And the CPUC rubber stamps everything the utilities ask for.

CA has some of the most expensive electricity in the nation. So it doesn't seem like the idea worked out.

Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday July 22, 2021 @08:33AM (#27918098)
California winds up being in the middle for avg money residents spend on household energy, but mostly because they don’t use AC or heat very much. https://wallethub.com/edu/energy-costs-by-state/4833
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by zbrozek on Thursday July 22, 2021 @10:09AM (#27919063)
Sure, but I said most expensive electricity, not highest monthly bills.
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by stickfigure on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:28PM (#27923125)
You'll have to verify this yourself, but my understanding is that there is no clear winner on the public choice issue of public vs private electrical. There are well-run and poorly-run examples on both sides.

In PG&E's defense, it's not literally cost-plus, and the CPUC doesn't always rubber stamp everything. Imagining the government alternative, what would really be different? There will still be a big bureaucratic organization full of imperfect humans with muddy incentives and limited resources. Would PG&E be better if the board of directors was appointed by politicians instead of elected by shareholders? I doubt it.

Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday July 22, 2021 @10:14PM (#27926500)
The most expensive energy would be Alaska and Hawaii for obvious reasons. California’s rates are similar to northeastern state rates (a bit lower than their average) but is definitely high for a western state that benefits from a lot of cheap hydro.
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by IgorPartola on Thursday July 22, 2021 @02:37AM (#27916112)
A federal grant might work too. Wildfires on this scale affect more than just Californians.
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa... by refurb on Thursday July 22, 2021 @02:57AM (#27916219)
I can’t find it now but a while back someone posted the meeting minutes from the CA PUC review of PG&E’s budget. It had stuff like “request to replace chain link fence for $175k - denied” and it was a 1,000+ page document.

PG&E has to get approval for their spend from the PUC and for any rate hikes.