Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa...
by zbrozek on Thursday July 22, 2021 @06:53AM
(#27917438)
Except they have regulated profit margins - it's cost-plus. So they have an incentive to make everything as expensive as possible to maximize their take. And the CPUC rubber stamps everything the utilities ask for.
CA has some of the most expensive electricity in the nation. So it doesn't seem like the idea worked out.
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa...
by seanmcdirmid on Thursday July 22, 2021 @08:33AM
(#27918098)
California winds up being in the middle for avg money residents spend on household energy, but mostly because they don’t use AC or heat very much. https://wallethub.com/edu/energy-costs-by-state/4833
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa...
by zbrozek on Thursday July 22, 2021 @10:09AM
(#27919063)
Sure, but I said most expensive electricity, not highest monthly bills.
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa...
by stickfigure on Thursday July 22, 2021 @03:28PM
(#27923125)
You'll have to verify this yourself, but my understanding is that there is no clear winner on the public choice issue of public vs private electrical. There are well-run and poorly-run examples on both sides.
In PG&E's defense, it's not literally cost-plus, and the CPUC doesn't always rubber stamp everything. Imagining the government alternative, what would really be different? There will still be a big bureaucratic organization full of imperfect humans with muddy incentives and limited resources. Would PG&E be better if the board of directors was appointed by politicians instead of elected by shareholders? I doubt it.
Re:PG&E will bury 10k miles of power lines so they don't spa...
by seanmcdirmid on Thursday July 22, 2021 @10:14PM
(#27926500)
The most expensive energy would be Alaska and Hawaii for obvious reasons. California’s rates are similar to northeastern state rates (a bit lower than their average) but is definitely high for a western state that benefits from a lot of cheap hydro.
It's far from perfect, but actually-public utilities are responsible for a lot of disasters too. It's not obvious that nationalizing PG&E would be good for anyone.