The most sustainable fish are the cheapest. If we can move past our fetish for eating apex predators, we can easily solve fish sustainability without the need for regulation.
>Scientists aiming their gene sequencers at commercial seafood are discovering rampant labeling fraud in supermarket coolers and restaurant tables: cheap fish is often substituted for expensive fillets, and overfished species are passed off as fish whose numbers are plentiful.
The link states that overfished species are being intentionally mis-labelled. I would say that, yes, we might as well not bother if the seafood industry is going to pull these kind of shenanigans, absent some sort of regulation from the government (an unpopular sentiment here).
Surely there must be laws against this already. I have a hard time imagining that claiming that you're selling X when you're in actual fact selling Y is legal. If no one is being prosecuted it must be because the government doesn't care enough, not because they lack laws to prosecute under.
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/22/science/22fish.html
And here's a reference to an even earlier story from 2005, in which farmed salmon are substituted for wild (not DNA-checkable):
http://vitalchoice.com/shop/pc/articlesView.asp?id=95
So, 6 years later, we still don't know what we're eating.
It would be a better argument if you could talk about the actual odds.
Buy whole fish. It's much harder to be lied to when you can look the fish in the eye.
Perhaps it's difficult to assure you're being given what you're told, but at least people are starting to ask.
And when preservation such as fishing regulations are proposed, this will make sense to more people. Maybe all the more so when they realize that their individual decisions don't matter, aren't sufficient, because they're bing lied to.
I hope. The alternative is pretty dismal.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/27/science/earth/27fish.html
Consumers have no effective way to verify what they're eating. This is a situation where there is either government action or no action; no private personal actions can be successful, barring the creation of instant cheap at-the-restaurant-table DNA analysis.