I really want to like habitica but the game loop doesn’t quite hook me like it should.

I've had an on-again-off-again relationship with Habitica. Having other party members really helps with motivation. However, I fell off once our party lead stepped back and quests stopped.

I did use it while ignoring the game part for a bit. It was still useful, but I did just end up forgetting it later.

Ex-Habitica user here. The accountability element broke me. I quit in shame when I couldn't keep up with my clan members without burning myself out from too little sleep and having too much on the list.