Re:dhcpleased(8) and resolvd(8) enabled in base, replacing d...
by rkangel on Saturday July 17, 2021 @06:11PM
(#27869231)
systemd fundamentally made a branding mistake, not a technical one. Putting all of these components under one 'systemd' umbrella name meant that people simplistically think of them as one thing and then start making the 'Unix philosophy' argument.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:dhcpleased(8) and resolvd(8) enabled in base, replacing d...
by dralley on Saturday July 17, 2021 @08:46PM
(#27869949)
We're in a thread about OpenBSD, a Unix that keeps literally the entire OS (except for ports) in one repo, and ships them together.
So this is a strange criticism to make.
Re:dhcpleased(8) and resolvd(8) enabled in base, replacing d...
by csande17 on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:38PM
(#27870168)
You're right that Linux is pretty much the only operating system where users can mix and match core system components. That's precisely why people get so mad about systemd!
If I wanted to use an operating system where all the components were tightly coupled and made by a single vendor, I'd use Windows, or macOS, or a BSD. (In fact I do use those operating systems when that's what I want.) But I would also like for other kinds of systems to exist in the world. I downloaded Linux because I wanted to use an operating system that _wasn't_ macOS!
Re:dhcpleased(8) and resolvd(8) enabled in base, replacing d...
by dralley on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:58PM
(#27870252)
They are free to make that criticism but they should do it without invoking "the Unix philosophy" which Linux has never adhered to.
Unix never had interchangable components like that.
Re:dhcpleased(8) and resolvd(8) enabled in base, replacing d...
by pjmlp on Monday July 19, 2021 @05:11AM
(#27880576)
Specially because "the Unix philosophy" as preached by Linux afficionados never happened in real UNIX, it keeps being preached as some kind of cargo cult by people that weren't even around during the UNIX wars heyday.
Re:dhcpleased(8) and resolvd(8) enabled in base, replacing d...
by j0057 on Sunday July 18, 2021 @02:15AM
(#27871077)
Because it all lives in one repo, some distros make the choice of packaging all of systemd into one package, so that you can't choose to not install timesyncd or networkd.
Re:dhcpleased(8) and resolvd(8) enabled in base, replacing d...
by bonzini on Sunday July 18, 2021 @03:59AM
(#27871452)
You can choose not to use them though. RHEL uses neither of those two, for example.
Re:dhcpleased(8) and resolvd(8) enabled in base, replacing d...
by op00to on Saturday July 17, 2021 @07:13PM
(#27869532)
Moving the goalposts yet again. Not only must it be technically superior for everyone, not only must it adhere to decades old computing dogma, but now it must be branded in such a way that itβs individual components must be unidentifiable?