News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by andy_ppp on Friday July 16, 2021 @06:21PM (#27861892)
As I understand it (I read this on Twitter so massive grain of salt etc.) the family concented to this explicitly. Would you feel better if it was a voice actor who could read Bourdain’s email in a perfect mimic? What about historical recreations, would you object to computers being involved in, say, recreating Abraham Lincoln’s voice? Does the age of the subject matter?

I think the squeamishness about AI as it becomes more and more capable will be interesting to define why we are feeling it. The machine is going to be capable of (and consequently used to do) these things whether you like it or not.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by ineptech on Friday July 16, 2021 @06:50PM (#27862065)
Any of those are fine - with disclosure. It seems pretty clear that in this case, they were less than transparent.

> “If you watch the film, other than that line you mentioned, you probably don’t know what the other lines are that were spoken by the A.I., and you’re not going to know,” Neville told the reviewer, Helen Rosner. “We can have a documentary-ethics panel about it later.”

...or we can have it sooner, on Twitter, and you'll get excoriated, and rightly so. I don't care if they train an AI to imitate Bourdain rapping the third verse from Modern Major General, it's a free country, but you have to be honest about it. You can't call yourself a documentarian and get cutesy about the authenticity of the material.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by speleding on Saturday July 17, 2021 @03:07AM (#27864029)
Call me cynical, but a documentary needs publicity to be successful. It seems to me this ethical dilemma gives just about the right amount of outrage for people to pay attention without it overly hurting the film maker's reputation.

Perhaps we'll see a mea culpa later on, where he will say he misjudged the amount of outrage, which is not a real apology, so lots of commenters will jump on that thereby providing even more publicity.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by Xplune13 on Saturday July 17, 2021 @03:33AM (#27864145)
I just don't like how people will go to any length just for "publicity".

Creating an outrage for some publicity of a documentary just doesn't sit right with me. Yes, it is an effective step or publicity stunt, but how does people don't have that inner voice? (I don't know what to call it) that tells them that this isn't what they should be doing without proper consent of the family members and without any disclosure over what is real and what isn't.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by latexr on Saturday July 17, 2021 @03:55AM (#27864245)
> I don't know what to call it

A conscience.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by briefcomment on Friday July 16, 2021 @06:26PM (#27861918)
His widow did not provide consent [1].

[1] https://twitter.com/OttaviaBourdain/status/14158894550057164...

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by sen on Friday July 16, 2021 @11:06PM (#27863294)
She's not his widow, she's his estranged ex-wife.

I should hope people's ex-wives don't get authority over their lives later (unless it's related to kids/shared-assets/etc).

The family giving consent is way more relevant.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by GravitasFailure on Saturday July 17, 2021 @03:20AM (#27864078)
> She's not his widow, she's his estranged ex-wife.

That's incorrect. They were still married when he died and most of Bourdain's estate was left to their daughter with Ottavia overseeing it. "The family," in this case, is Ottavia and Ariadne Bourdain.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/life/people/2018/07/06/anthon...

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by sen on Saturday July 17, 2021 @06:23AM (#27864833)
From TFA:

> estranged wife Ottavia Busia-Bourdain

He left her in charge of the trust/etc because she's still the mother of his child, and therefore a major part of his life, but they weren't together.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by GravitasFailure on Saturday July 17, 2021 @07:00AM (#27864960)
Fine. Estranged widow. The point is if anyone has control of his legacy, it's her, and the director claims to have consulted his widow which couldn't really be anyone other than her, which means one of them is lying about giving the go ahead to do the deepfake voiceover.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by nxpnsv on Saturday July 17, 2021 @02:46AM (#27863960)
That’s a response to that the movie people stated they cleared the scenes with his widow.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by spoonjim on Friday July 16, 2021 @10:49PM (#27863231)
I don’t think you count as someone’s widow if you split up before they die.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by andy_ppp on Friday July 16, 2021 @06:28PM (#27861931)
Cool, great to get that clarified but also good to see I didn’t invent the fact they claimed to have asked.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by unishark on Saturday July 17, 2021 @02:12AM (#27863869)
We don't know that anyone lied. The guy had two ex-wives and a girlfriend. Perhaps they didn't ask enough family members for someone's taste. But as others noted, an objection from one ex-wife doesn't really make that case very strongly.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by shkkmo on Friday July 16, 2021 @07:46PM (#27862433)
That wasn't the fact that you stated.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by rovr138 on Friday July 16, 2021 @08:37PM (#27862703)
>As I understand it (I read this on Twitter so massive grain of salt etc.) the family concented to this explicitly.

This is the "fact". Half of it is a caveat to take it with a grain of salt.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by virtue3 on Friday July 16, 2021 @06:27PM (#27861924)
Historical recreations are fine.

Creating a digital voice model of abraham lincoln and then using it for ??? is not.

All of this is being done for profit means (the orville redenbacher, fast furious, star wars).

Just because we can doesn't mean we shouldn't stop and think if we should.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by mc32 on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:07PM (#27862819)
Just about every Presidents’ Day I’ll hear car deals with voice actors pretending to be Clinton or Bush and also on TV people dressed up as Lincoln… so I dunno.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by daniellarusso on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:10PM (#27862829)
If car salespeople do it, it should be fine. Is that the bar?
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by lostlogin on Friday July 16, 2021 @10:40PM (#27863207)
It would seem that the closer one gets to recreating the look or sound of someone else, the less acceptable it is.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by ViViDboarder on Monday July 19, 2021 @01:09AM (#27879475)
Or, more simply, is it an attempt at deceiving people into believing it’s the actual individual being impersonated?

Impersonating someone like Lincoln in a car commercial is one thing, but it’s another is someone presented an impersonation as their actual voice in a documentary.

It’s also complicated by the fact that the AI voice is trained on his likeness and dubious as if the reproduction is a new creation or something else. Similar to the debate about GitHub Copilot.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by andy_ppp on Friday July 16, 2021 @06:30PM (#27861946)
On which timescale does something become historical? Are the Beatles historical, to you maybe not but possibly to your children? Where is the line you’re drawing?

If I’m honest humans have never done the moral thinking, we largely just middle through and hope to get away with it.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by patrickthebold on Friday July 16, 2021 @06:41PM (#27862009)
Time doesn't matter as much as what is said. Fake Anthony Bourdain voice reading something he wrote seems fine to me, especially in the context of, say, a documentary.

John Lennon's voice doing an ad for Vox amps seems in poor taste.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by serf on Friday July 16, 2021 @07:28PM (#27862328)
>John Lennon's voice doing an ad for Vox amps seems in poor taste.

the Bourdain documentary we're talking about was created in order to generate profit; it has box-office showings and advertisement campaigns.

A documentary is nice, but I fail to see how it's less of a product than Vox amplifiers, aside from some shallow altruism like "We're spreading the ideas of Bourdain", which could be done entirely without a profit scheme.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by andy_ppp on Saturday July 17, 2021 @04:19AM (#27864353)
I don’t understand, are you saying documentaries should be made to generate a loss? Do you think the same documentary would be better if it didn’t have advertising or box-office showings? I really don’t understand the logic here at all! Please explain rather than downvote like in the other comment where I ask about this.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by serf on Saturday July 17, 2021 @06:09AM (#27864766)
>I don’t understand, are you saying documentaries should be made to generate a loss?

No, the 'for profit' nature of this venture is just the amoral cherry-on-top.

My real problems with this type of thing are many-fold :

1) Textual messages are often times created in such a way as to be convenient rather than to be read. Inflection and tone mostly go out the window when written out, so people tend to use lots of hyperbole and metaphor to better convey nuance like sarcasm -- this can quickly make someone who is eloquent in-person look moronic in-text, but people close to the individual know better and ignore the email parlance.

2) There is a level of artistry and creative interpretation when deciding how an AI voice generates text-to-speech. What samples are used, how is the phrase tempo'd, environmental interpretation, etc. The end product is very much not-Bourdain , but it's sold to people watching the documentary as Bourdain, so it's assumed that he said these things.. which leads to :

3) Personally I believe that the post-death 'image' of anyone should only be manipulated or altered by third-party testimonial and record-level evidence.

An unaware person watching this documentary would come out of the theater with the notion that Bourdain said things that he never said.

A third party is using Bourdain's own image to sell persona/image changes to the public on his own behalf, post-death -- I have major ethical and moral qualms with this idea, even with all the express permission of those around him and his family.

Regardless of who these people are that gave permission -- they're not him. The voice/image/actions of your own persona should probably never be tampered with by someone else -- even the closest people to him can't begin to know what he'd say internally, even if they may have felt that they had a good grasp.

Now, sure, we can always argue that a celebrities image is likely sold to the companies managing them -- and I would have to agree. Legally, sure, his image likely isn't his own property, but I don't have to agree with the methodology on an ethical level, and I have a real hard time imaging that I ever will.

>Do you think the same documentary would be better if it didn’t have advertising or box-office showings?

Yes. I am less against the manipulated and possibly perjured conjuration of fake dead-people's voices when someone isn't making a profit.

(I detected a bit of snark in your question, so I replied with a bit of snark -- but it's an honest answer. Apologies if you didn't mean for it to be interpreted that way -- another incongruity in text-based-talk :) )

Just one example of the prickliness of this with the for-profit aspect in scope : an AI generated likeness of a famous voice says "Eat Snickers!" , after the family of the original voice gives all the permissions in the world to whoever may want to use it.

Tons of royalties are accrued.

Who is given the royalties?

so, tl;dr, here's the point I feel most strongly about : An unaware person watching this documentary would come out of the theater with the notion that Bourdain said things that he never said, in a way that he perhaps never would have said them. This technology, along with others like it, creates a situation in which a third party can manipulate the persona of a long-dead person in a first-person way, thus circumventing a lot of the trust checks that exist with regards to the perceived image of the now-dead.

I don't think this particular example is damaging, even if I think it's unethical -- however I do think that it's an indicator of things to come, and I believe that it is going to be heavily abused until some regulatory body makes lots of rules and regulations regarding the depiction of image of those that are no longer able to fight their own libel cases.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by patrickthebold on Friday July 16, 2021 @08:55PM (#27862770)
Good point. I suppose I'd say I'm comfortable with some combination of appropriately compensating the heirs/estate and some sort of 'respect for the dead'.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by noxvilleza on Friday July 16, 2021 @08:08PM (#27862552)
The change of medium is significant IMO. Rarely in spoken word do we expect a citation of when/where the words are spoken (barring for example, famous speeches/addresses), but in written form it often is. In this case, Fake AB Voice was reading part of a bigger piece of text - but it's not obvious what that underlying text is, making further analysis of the context in which it's spoken a bit more difficult.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by tayo42 on Friday July 16, 2021 @06:44PM (#27862023)
Idk if historical is based on time. I think intention is more important. if you recreate the Beatles purely for profit then it seems unethical and disrespectful. if you want to keep someone's voice for record keeping or something educational that seems different
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by andy_ppp on Saturday July 17, 2021 @02:25AM (#27863914)
Why do people in this thread seem so focused on profit? Everything has a need to make money or do you all work for free? Why is trying to make money on some hopefully valuable art you’ve produced bad?
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by serf on Saturday July 17, 2021 @06:16AM (#27864799)
>Why is trying to make money on some hopefully valuable art you’ve produced bad?

Most direct and honest answer I can give you :

It's (considered by many) unethical to profit from human death and suffering.

It's (considered by many) extra unethical to assume you can speak for the dead.

It's (considered by many) extra-extra unethical to try to hood-wink an audience into thinking that your Mechanical Turk is the real-deal.

This particular 'valuable art' we're discussing has flavors from all three of those types of behavior.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by spoonjim on Friday July 16, 2021 @10:51PM (#27863242)
I don’t think my family should have the ability to make decisions regarding my likeness. My likeness is one of those things which is just totally 100% mine. I married my wife and had kids with her and would want her to have all of my money if I died but wouldn’t want her to be able to license my voice and face to promote Wheaties cereal or something. It shouldn’t be allowed unless the person explicitly grants those rights while alive.
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by ipaddr on Saturday July 17, 2021 @02:05AM (#27863850)
When did you get a copyright on your likeness? Your likeness might not be unique or unique enough for others to identify a distinct you.

1,000 Elvis' likenesses disagree.

Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by spoonjim on Saturday July 17, 2021 @02:59AM (#27864000)
You get a copyright automatically on anything you write... why not on your likeness (insofar as it specifically refers to you)? The 1,000 Elvises are part of the problem: although Elvis chose to be an extremely public figure, I'm not sure he would want his likeness to essentially be a cartoon character for Vegas weddings and the like. I would say that a person's likeness should be off-limits to everyone, unless specifically authorized while alive, for the duration of the copyright term (70 years after death), and then become public domain (family members should not be monetizing their relative's likeness after their death, unless specifically authorized to do so).
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by ipaddr on Saturday July 17, 2021 @11:57AM (#27866667)
How do you deal with twins or similiar likeness between parent/child?
Re:Voice clone of Anthony Bourdain prompts synthetic media e... by spoonjim on Saturday July 17, 2021 @12:24PM (#27866859)
Existing law on likeness already deals with this. If you're the identical twin of a celebrity, you're allowed to use your likeness as it relates to you (i.e. use your photograph to promote your real estate business). You're not allowed to use it to suggest the celebrity in question.