News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by jfengel on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:46AM (#27856171)
Unfortunately, that advice isn't great, either. The police have the authority to arrest you for pissing them off. They may not be able to charge you with anything, but they can make your day a lot worse before releasing you. And there is basically nothing you can do about it.

If a police officer pulls you over and you start pulling the "I've been told never to talk to the police", you're escalating the encounter before it even starts. That's no excuse for police abusing their authority, but they've got the authority and you don't.

Lawyers have told me to use your best judgment. Cooperate as long as the police are being cooperative, and the odds are you'll go about your day with only minor aggravation. Only escalate to the "I don't talk to police" when they start getting hostile with you. This is, I'm told, what the lawyers themselves do.

This is for minor encounters, like traffic stops or ordinary questions. If you're actually taken in or you're a suspect, yeah, shut up and wait for your lawyer.

And, uh, this is the advice they give to me as a white man. It may not apply if you're somebody more likely to be subject to abuse.

None of this is good. It's very, very bad. This advice is not about fairness; it's about trying to make your life as least-worst as possible.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by maccard on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:57AM (#27856265)
Hard agree here. I've had two run ins with the police (in the UK - I made a mistake driving and was pulled over, and the other was just wrong place wrong time) and in both cases just being civil removed me from the situation in less than 15 minutes. If I had started parroting the "I refuse to speak to the police" line in either scenario it would have been a whole whole lot worse.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by jfengel on Friday July 16, 2021 @10:51AM (#27856825)
Aggravatingly, in the US, even the most routine traffic stop frequently runs considerably more than 15 minutes. I don't know precisely what's going on. They take your driver's license and registration back to their car, presumably to run it through some kind of database.

Does that take 20 minutes? I dunno. Or maybe they're doing paperwork, or playing solitaire, or maybe just wasting your time because they can. The process is incredibly opaque. Even if it's necessary, it's unclear why, and I've never had a traffic stop that didn't feel abusive.

I'm always super placating about it in an attempt to keep it from getting even worse. Fortunately, it has only happened a very small number of times -- all of which were for minor violations that could easily have been "Hey, I saw you do X. Don't do that again." (Which actually did happen once -- for failing to turn my lights on in the daytime. Which was written on a sign. Presumably about some kind of visibility, I guess. But at least they didn't fine me over it, or take up more than 5 minutes.)

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by EvanAnderson on Friday July 16, 2021 @11:33AM (#27857327)
Having worked with some law enforcement records software I can say that "paperwork" (which now involves filling out electronic forms) and waiting for state database queries to come back are definitely a time suck. The officers who I know would like the process to be faster as well. Being stopped on the roadside is a dangerous situation that nobody wants to be in longer than necessary.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by jfengel on Friday July 16, 2021 @12:27PM (#27857947)
That's really good to know, actually. It makes the waiting a bit less aggravating to think that they're not just trying to piss me off.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by wil421 on Friday July 16, 2021 @08:15PM (#27862581)
Not sure where you live but 15 minutes is way long for a traffic stop. I was in a traffic accident and it took 15 minutes for the police to do everything he needed including an automated print out with my court date (hit someone at low speed from behind). Same deal when I was speeding, less than 10 mins with a full print out with pay X fine or appear on Y date. All automated.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by Accacin on Friday July 16, 2021 @10:12AM (#27856400)
But the UK isn't the US, and staying silent wouldn't be beneficial to us, in fact it would probably make it worse.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by MeinBlutIstBlau on Friday July 16, 2021 @10:53AM (#27856855)
The pot brothers at law made a video of how they got a guy off at a weed distribution plant because he kept his mouth shut. The prosecutor couldn't prove he was an employee, customer touring, or what. All because they shut up and didnt say anything.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by leephillips on Friday July 16, 2021 @11:46AM (#27857516)
And the ones who tried to evade responsibility by saying that they weren’t employees, just volunteers, got busted for distribution.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by rPlayer6554 on Friday July 16, 2021 @10:18AM (#27856453)
The video is specifically about the 5th amendment to the US constitution and has nothing to do with the UK legal system.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by iso1631 on Friday July 16, 2021 @11:54AM (#27857616)
I had two police officers at my door a couple of years ago, turns out my neighbour had died and they wondered if I'd heard anything or not heard anything from him.

Apparently the correct advice is to refuse to say anything without a lawyer, which I'm certain would be the end of the matter. I wonder if it's lawyers (paid $500/hour or whatever) who suggest that advice.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by themaninthedark on Friday July 16, 2021 @12:53PM (#27858261)
I am pretty sure it is lawyers who are suggesting the advice but not sure if that makes it based out of greed.

If you look at it from a lawyer's perspective: The majority of my clients who speak to the police(either before or after employing me) have a large amount of trouble. So therefore it is ill advised to speak to the police.

What they are missing: All the people who spoke with police and had no problems.

It is sample bias.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by brigade on Friday July 16, 2021 @02:43PM (#27859685)
The guys a lawyer yeah, but the advice isn’t to offer the cop a chance to talk with you with a lawyer; it’s to avoid talking to cops at all. Then if the cops try to force an interview anyway, that’s where the “without a lawyer” comes in; if they’re arresting you then they should have other PC and you’ll be needing a lawyer anyway.

And the whole point is that even in your case, it’s not directly beneficial to you to answer even innocuous questions about your neighbor’s death; at best it doesn’t change any suspicions on you, but at worst there is a chance that your answers could make you a person of interest when you weren’t one before.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by iso1631 on Saturday July 17, 2021 @09:46AM (#27865724)
If you have a disfunctional police force that may be the case, but when I cold shoulder my local pc (who I've spoken to a couple of times at parish council meetings about speeding issues in the village), that's clearly going to be increasing suspicions on me.

Your claim "not directly beneficial to you" is also odd. Not talking to the police and thus not finding out there's a murderer around?

Maybe it's different in third world countries where the police don't care about the public and are just a law to themselves, that's certainly not the case where I live.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by rPlayer6554 on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:53AM (#27856236)
The lawyer made a follow up video clarifying that in routine traffic stops police do have autonomy. So as long as you are reasonable and just showing the policeman you aren't a public menace. So I can agree that is reasonable. For any other reason I'd have my lawyer on me no matter what.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by smnrchrds on Friday July 16, 2021 @12:57PM (#27858324)
Could you please link to that video?
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by rPlayer6554 on Friday July 16, 2021 @05:18PM (#27861345)
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by smnrchrds on Friday July 16, 2021 @05:32PM (#27861481)
Thanks
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by pc86 on Friday July 16, 2021 @12:48PM (#27858204)
A traffic stop is its own thing. You've presumably given them probable suspicion that you've committed some sort of infraction. Everything from something very innocuous like weaving within your lane to them seeing you run a red light. You're officially being detained, you're not free to go, and you have to answer their questions. Depending on your state, their questions may have to be related to the original purpose of the traffic stop unless they've got probably suspicion of some other infraction.

Nobody with a law degree has ever suggested that at a traffic stop you start off by saying you're not answering questions and to call your lawyer.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by jfengel on Friday July 16, 2021 @12:50PM (#27858212)
I'm sure nobody with a law degree ever said that, but that's how the advice is commonly portrayed.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by ffffwe3rq352y3 on Friday July 16, 2021 @03:02PM (#27859933)
Look at one of the top posts on reddit today: https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/olecn5/know_your_rig...

It seems like a lot of people think that its what you should do! I personally think its dumb for a traffic stop

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by darksaints on Friday July 16, 2021 @10:12AM (#27856394)
Technically they don't have that right. Detainment without reasonable suspicion, and arrest without probable cause, are crimes called Deprivation of Rights Under Color of Law. It is a felony punishable by up to ten years in prison. Funnily enough, if you've ever heard a cop say a variant of the phrase "you can beat the rap but not the ride", that is essentially admission of such criminal action by the cop...if they think that the evidence is sparse enough that you won't be charged with a crime, then they do not have probable cause grounds to arrest you, and by continuing with the arrest, they commit a felony.

Unfortunately, we can probably count the number of cops charged with that crime on zero hands. I'm increasingly convinced that our entire police problem in the US boils down to our incentives that we give to prosecutors which make them avoid any attempt to hold cops accountable for their crimes. I'm not sure what the solution is, but having independent prosecutors for police crimes might be a good start.

With regards to your point about cooperating until the cop starts acting adversarial, I think that advice applies to someone who is intelligent and informed about the law enough to understand when a cop is actually trying to coerce an admission. It might be good advice for you, but it might actually be terrible advice for someone else.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by jfengel on Friday July 16, 2021 @12:55PM (#27858286)
Unfortunately, I am well aware that I don't know when they're trying to coerce an admission. One of the things I'm most terrified of is being asked "Do you know why I pulled you over?", and I can't think of any answer that doesn't have the potential to land me in a lot of trouble.

I feel like that question is going to be hostile no matter what. I've been told by police that they don't use it, but didn't rule out the notion that others might.

I've never had an encounter with the police worse than a basic traffic stop, so I've never really had to apply the "don't talk" advice. I hope I never do. Because I'm quite certain I'll do the wrong thing, regardless of what I do.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by mrguyorama on Friday July 16, 2021 @01:30PM (#27858766)
>"Do you know why I pulled you over?"

The only safe answer to that, period, is "No". Even if you think the cop pulled you over because you were going 100 in a 55, you still don't know, it's not ever going to be a lie, and anything else can legitimately be taken as an admission of guilt in court

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by bloak on Friday July 16, 2021 @04:07PM (#27860648)
> "Do you know why I pulled you over?"

On a scale from 1 to 10, how bad would it be to answer that with "Is it because I is black?" (© 1998-2021 Ali G)?

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by kbenson on Friday July 16, 2021 @12:11PM (#27857804)
> I'm not sure what the solution is, but having independent prosecutors for police crimes might be a good start

It would have to be an almost entirely separate career path once you stepped into it. Once you've prosecuted a few cops, I'm sure that will follow you as a prosecutor wherever you go, and good luck hiding it. Gotta either stay in that game or advance to the point you no longer need to work with cops (become a judge I guess)

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by FireBeyond on Friday July 16, 2021 @02:50PM (#27859787)
The problem is if in doing your job you piss off the wrong cops, you too become a target.

I'm a firefighter / paramedic.

Cops have arrested paramedics providing patient care on accident scenes for varying slights.

Cops have come to hospitals where their off-duty drunk buddy runs a red light and t-boned someone else, and demanded nurses do blood draws (without a warrant) of the other party looking for intoxication, and then arrested the nurse for refusing.

All groups that (rightly or wrongly, I'm making no judgment here, just observing) are considered to be "on the same side", are only on that side as long as it is not inconvenient to those cops, then they're as much a target as anyone else.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by boring_twenties on Friday July 16, 2021 @09:23PM (#27862891)
> Cops have come to hospitals where their off-duty drunk buddy runs a red light and t-boned someone else, and demanded nurses do blood draws (without a warrant) of the other party looking for intoxication, and then arrested the nurse for refusing.

If you are referring to the incident in Salt Lake City, you might be pleased to know that the nurse in question ended up getting a $500,000 settlement: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/11/01/561337106...

edit: Oh, and the cop was fired, too.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by darksaints on Saturday July 17, 2021 @10:08AM (#27865851)
It should be noted that the cop claimed he did nothing wrong and sued for wrongful termination for $1.5M, and the police union, representing all of their officers, supported him.

The Overton window that cops believe exists about acceptable cop behavior is unfathomably out of line with reality. That's the reason why police oppose citizen backed reviews of their conduct. Makes me wonder how many people with similar circumstances but less publicity get swept under the rug.

Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by darksaints on Friday July 16, 2021 @08:11PM (#27862562)
I think "I've put dozens of cops behind bars" would be an excellent sales pitch, as well as resume boost, for a criminal defense attorney.
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by kleton on Friday July 16, 2021 @10:24AM (#27856508)
His advice probably works well for himself. It is easy to tell for anyone who pulls him over from the way he talks that he is a lawyer. And a decent lawyer can make a lot of inconvenient paperwork for the police department when he's working "for free".
Re:Illinois first state to tell police they can't lie to min... by LgWoodenBadger on Friday July 16, 2021 @12:17PM (#27857861)
By the time you realize you should (have) shut up, it's already too late