The axiom of choice is exactly the thing that tells us that we can make "random" choices. The way set theory works is that you have axioms to talk about intuitions of sets. So you might say that such a reasonable intuition is that we can make "make unlimited random choices", but this is exactly the axiom of choice!
It's not about a choice from an infinity but an infinity of choices.
(The first journal he submitted it to rejected the paper with the comment "this is not mathematics, this is theology")
Anyway, I hope they gave him a Ph.D for that comment, lolol.
Oh and yikes, did Hilbert just bring roots of polynomials into the mix?
> The Axiom of Choice is obviously true, the well-ordering principle obviously false, and who can tell about Zorn's lemma?
Turns out, it depends which socks you buy - there are makes which are different, and ones which aren't. examples at https://www.quora.com/Is-there-a-left-and-right-sock-in-a-pa... including toe-socks but not limited to them.
Can you always pick the center of each universe in a universe of infinite universes ? Any point can be the center, you just need to pick one.
A sphere has a center which is in that sphere but not on the surface (boundary) of the sphere.
A 4-sphere has a center which is in that hypersphere but not in the volume boundary of the hypersphere.
...
It is entirely possible that the universe is a 3s1t shape which is part of the boundary of an NsNt shape, and there is a center to it which is not usefully accessible -- or even discoverable -- from anywhere in the universe.
Still centerless seems like it could carry less baggage and be just as "correct", but IDK.
I mean... they're not in exactly the same position and state at exactly the same time, no? That would seem to distinguish them.
> Or might this imply that the electrons are actually distinguishable in some way? Or maybe I should re-phrase; could each electron actually have some (possibly hidden) identity?
I still don't see what that has to do with the above. The context with and relation to their surroundings seems entirely sufficient to distinguish between electrons, so they're not indistinguishable, even if, in isolation, they are.
I suspect that's key to why the axiom of choice has to be an axiom (and how this may pop up from time-to-time in the realm of computer science problems).
if it does, then "I select one at random." That could be accomplishable without a guarantee that I can tell you how to select (in finite time) the same element I selected.
This is my preferred quote about the AOC:
> The Axiom of Choice is obviously true, the well-ordering principle obviously false, and who can tell about Zorn's lemma?
Jerry Bona. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_L._Bona
> If we have infinitely many pairs of shoes we don’t need the axiom of choice, since we can just take the left shoe from each pair; but if we have infinitely many pairs of socks, we do need the axiom of choice.
- Bertrand Russell
So randomness seems like a good fit for "choice" here, no? Or maybe call it ambivalence, or indifference. If the objects are truly unidentifiable, can it possibly matter which one you choose?
As the argument surely goes...