Re:Soldiers speak out about being blocked from repairing equ...
by azernik on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:45PM
(#27850994)
And that's the point - for such a contractor, the only punishment available is through courts, with more or less a presumption of innocence, and where the officer is in a lot of career jeopardy if the tribunal digs up that they were being unreasonable.
By contrast, a soldier in the chain of command can be punished administratively, and disobeying orders is a crime that in most militaries is only excusable if the order is criminal, not if it's stupid. Rarely brought, but the spectre of it is there
Re:Soldiers speak out about being blocked from repairing equ...
by loonster on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:17PM
(#27851729)
You can always refuse the NJP and demand a court martial. In most cases, it's an extremely bad idea. As you go up the chain, more severe punishment can be applied.
I have seen it work with one pissed off LCpl. The officer decided to back off.
Re:Soldiers speak out about being blocked from repairing equ...
by michaelmrose on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:42PM
(#27852847)
The requirements and financial penalties for failing to perform the duties specified in the contract are spelled out... in the contract. The biggest one is the government could neither give you a pile of money nor give you the opportunity to earn more piles of money in the future.
There is no way you could do your job badly enough for it to be treason nor as far as I know subject one to a military tribunal.
And "everything possible" would include tools, electronic or software, and software codes - and yes, possibly engineers who created them on the line, something like what was done when Apollo project had landings on the Moon. Only in this case I'd assume different kind of responsibility than just contractual.
I don't fall in the military hierarchy at the moment, but that doesn't mean I can give aid and comfort to enemy. Again, I'm not a lawyer - that's why it's a tribunal - but for a court to give go-ahead to this (absent more prompt collaboration beforehand) would be something to expect. What would you expect if you'd be in the field in this case?