Re:End of an Era: NTSC Finally Goes Dark in America
by hulitu on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:25PM
(#27847241)
It is. A so called digital signal is still an analog signal which must be processed. You only obtain the digital signal after you process it. The main issue here is that the digital signal is much more complex and due to this much sensible to noise. When it rains for example the analog signal will still be visible as long as the sync part can be decoded. For digital signal noise will be replaced by predicted frames. The issue is that a lot of providers have a very bad quality and they rely heavily on predicted frames. And when the key frames are not available (due to noise) good luck predicting the rest of the frames.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:End of an Era: NTSC Finally Goes Dark in America
by yholio on Friday July 16, 2021 @05:12AM
(#27854390)
The difference between sync level and black level in analog TV standards is about 15% of maximum transmitter power. This means that any noise added that is more than 7.5% of max power will confuse the TV to detect sync as black and black as sync. In practice, a 20dB SNR or less will be completely unwatchable.
The Shannon limit for a 5Mhz channel with 20 dB SNR is 17 Mbit/s and latest DTV standards approach this, easily 10, maybe 15 Mbit. That's enough for a HD channel in perfect quality or many more in SD.
So the problem is not with analog vs digital, that debate is long settled. It's the specific tradeoffs made when digital TV was deployed.
Re:End of an Era: NTSC Finally Goes Dark in America
by BenjiWiebe on Thursday July 15, 2021 @01:53PM
(#27847717)
Actually, thanks to error correcting codes, a digital signal can get right up against the Shannon limit. You can't improve on the Shannon limit.