There is no bygone era of highly educated and high minded people.
As an example I don’t think Hal would have much interest in shibemoon pump and dump telegram channels and likewise most people joining today don’t have much interest in the implementation details of rootstock.
For example, at the last minute he decided to enter a Gomoku-playing computer programming contest. He learned Gomoku and wrote a program that trashed the competition (including the MIT entry) in a weekend.
Pretty cool that a 'garage-scale' team can make a functioning technolibertarian market so rapidly. (But also helped me learn to appreciate the utility of regulation :-P) IIRC I think Trendon Shavers/pirateat40's "miner financing" ponzi's implosion was a significant factor in taking it down.
There were lots of cool little projects popping up every month. Gambling sites that allowed wagers to be made directly on the blockchain - most engineering was around proving to gamblers that outcome determination was being done fairly. Accountless websites where you'd log in by sending a small fraction of a bitcoin, and your address was used as your identity. When bitcoin was less than $20, it was exciting and easy to experiment with - who cares if the $5 you sent disappears - but then the price spiked, and so fees increased and all of the 'loose change' people had everywhere was suddenly a significant amount of money - exit scams became frequent and people stopped being willing to store small amounts with others, because that small amount could 20x in 4 years.
Lots of small businesses posting that they'd accept bitcoin for their products. Found a lovely beekeeper's business that made great honey caramels and beeswax chapstick. I paid a teenager to custom make perler bead pixel art of Liu Kang and Raiden from the original Mortal Kombat (I think I may have paid multiple bitcoins for those :-P - hope they hodled!)
The DeFi tech is real, but early. Vitalik Buterin is a really good leader for Ethereum and development.
Vitalik Interview: https://www.stitcher.com/show/rationally-speaking/episode/in...
This is a worthwhile list to read through: https://danromero.org/crypto-reading/
The main issue for outsiders is that the industry is surrounded by snake oil salesman and people that don't know what they're talking about (the 'evil central bank' types), but the underlying tech is real and the potential is real (imo). If you look at it quickly you might dismiss it all, but I think that'd be a mistake.
The ability to manage decentralized state is very cool, but there's a lot to build to make it viable (and as a result, there's a lot of opportunity). When something is hard, there's often value in making it easier.
There's also a lot of stuff in legacy finance that requires humans to do and is slow. Multi-day financial transfers for clearing and high associated fees for wires (at some banks) - crypto options are much better and modern implementations of the legacy stack. The current state is still a bit unstable, and the UX is a disaster, but the future is clearly better (imo) in a way legacy systems will have trouble competing with.
As an aside, 'wealth inequality' is a feature you want in effective capitalist systems (you can still protect the lower bound). http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html
In 1999 a lot of people recognized the value of the internet (though many still dismissed it [0]), but there was also a lot of dumb money and failure - loud people who didn't know what was going on. The web obviously became extremely economically relevant despite all of that. There's some similar potential here - I think it'll just take a while to shake out.
[0] "By 2005 or so, it will become clear that the Internet’s impact on the economy has been no greater than the fax machine’s." -Paul Krugman (1998)
Irony of the above quote is it's wrong on two levels - the internet, but also the impact of the fax machine (also huge).
Sure infinite coins can be fixed later, but the same can be said about Bitcoin. If POS works, it can be implemented on Bitcoin.
This was before the DAO hack.
I don't recall Vitalik ever claiming that arbitrary smart contracts built on top of Ethereum were provably safe. Back then nobody was applying formal proof to smart contract code, it was just regular devs slamming out Solidity scripts with minimal third-party audits. That's what the vulnerable DAO code was; there wasn't a formal proof within miles of that stuff. The hack did not target the Ethereum protocol itself.
Applying formal proofs to smart contracts does make sense, since failures are expensive and the code is short. There's been gradual movement in that direction but it's been slow.
Once Stanford gets fully restarted, I'll see if I can dredge those up.
Issuance right now is 2 ETH/block. The white paper just promised 5 ETH/block forever.
https://ethereum.org/en/whitepaper/
Net issuance will be lower after 1559 rolls out in August and starts burning a portion of transaction fees. Combining that with the PoS merge in half a year or so, and net issuance may well go negative. (Ethereum's PoS isn't really a scaling solution though.)
Yes, but can you convince the hardcore PoW maximalists to join your fork? IMO Bitcoin is doing its best to be a raw, pseudo-physical element.
That means immutability, costs rooted in the physical world, etc. The community will change its protocols sparingly and slowly.
To some who prefer rapid change and development this is unattractive. But to Bitcoiners, decentralization and immutability are the foundations of this new type of property. They are uninterested in technical gains that come with complexity and risk.
DOGE is problematic because it's an infinite coin with an inflation rate that is too high.
https://john-tromp.medium.com/a-case-for-using-soft-total-su...
> "Sure infinite coins can be fixed later, but the same can be said about Bitcoin. If POS works, it can be implemented on Bitcoin."
In theory yes, in practice no. BTC community elevated a clear con-man fake Satoshi because he took sides in a block size political battle. They can't even agree to increase the block size. This lack of leadership is a problem, moving to ETH2 is a serious project and requires a leader, priorities, direction etc. I don't think BTC can do any of this.
If you dig enough, you'll see a lot of very useful and important projects being built by some very capable engineers.
This kind of comment reminds me of when people were predicting that internet was going to be a useless thing[1].
1: https://www.newsweek.com/clifford-stoll-why-web-wont-be-nirv...
DAOs, and AMMs are interesting - there's a lot of potential in leveraging DeFi to make systems that can work in ways better than existing legacy tech, it's just hard and people don't have it already figured out to the point where looking at it makes it obvious. General public state is a new thing and how it can be used is being figured out (oracles, programmable money, etc.).
When something is new it looks more 'pointless' and toy-like. It takes a while for its value to become truly obvious to everyone (and it requires some people to see that value early).
I believe the great financial speed-run has hit Mid-1929.
Before the Securities Act, Securities Exchange Act, Regulation S and Regulation T, before the SEC, CFTC and FDIC. A world of unrestricted margin, wildcat banks, hucksters, shills, snake-oil salesmen, and some, I assume, are good people.
Crypto is what the stock market would look like if everyone at the SEC decided to take a few months vacation at once, a financial version of The Purge.
If you create a system without a central authority able to correct for incentive failures of system design, you can end up trapped by the incentives themselves. [0]
That can lead to bad outcomes we already see in existing systems (NIMBY housing, partisan politics, etc.)
2008 loans to save the system were wildly successful, in DeFi - there is no authority that can jump in with liquidity temporarily to save the system. Maybe some consensus could be reached, but it definitely seems like there's big future risk in this area.
[0]: Moloch basically: https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/
For anyone who's looking into more serious/technical discussions, I think looking through github contributions, whitepapers, technical parts of bitcointalk and in depth interviews of legitimate contributors to the ecosystem (like Vitalik) is much more informative and has better signal to noise ratios.
Unfortunately, as is becoming more and more true in our pretty weird modern inter-connected world there's no substitute for getting your own hands dirty, reading primary sources and trying to understand what's true and what's bullshit yourself. Only then can you really evaluate who is worth listening to and what is actually interesting (I found the above stuff I linked to be good, but you should judge them for yourself).
The 'investment' bit is kind of secondary (https://soliditylang.org/), I personally think BTC, ETH, and Coinbase stock are the main long term bets - other stuff has extreme risk and requires a lot of attention to know if it's worthwhile or not. I do think the ZCash privacy model is cool.
Basically, I wouldn't invest unless you're going to sort through the nonsense yourself. Though like any investing the stuff where the value is harder to see is also where the bigger returns are (and the bigger failures).
There's a lot of datapoints that you can use or you can find reliable people and rely on their judgments. Also, if you're simply looking for investment, you can't go wrong with BTC/ETH portfolio, they have been proven to work over many years now and most of the remaining altcoins are correlated with them in price anyways.
HN is probably fine, I just feel bad for anyone who learns about crypto on YouTube and asks a newbie question in the comments - they are swarmed by bot armies recommending “investment strategies” over WhatsApp
Also, how many transactions/day does the second-most-used cryptocurrency facilitate?
If so, then you don't want Bitcoin. You can use Paypal.
However if you want to own an asset that can't be debased by central banks, where your transactions can't be censored, where you can participate from anywhere geographically, then you might want Bitcoin.
Those features come at a transaction capacity tradeoff.
If you say "Choose proven cryptocurrencies with transactions" I am going to assume you don't mean ten transactions/day.
I do not think it is unreasonable to ask "How many people are actually transacting with this cryptocurrency?".
2) Type "Bitcoin transactions per day", click search
3) View results
????
Is it really a good idea to invest in such a volatile asset?
(Genuinely asking as a complete noob)
It’s impossible and maddening to keep the “movement” on track in messaging. Every era is less educated technically and cares less about ideological or political goals and more about the bottom line of making some wealth.
So of course the movement is diluted. Influencers are rarely true cypherpunks and are the loudest by profession. But it doesn’t mean it isn’t working. IMHO the traditional finance system has only gotten more troubling since Satoshi’s whitepaper while crypto has grown more and more capable. It’s true there have been new challenges that have emerged, some of which are still ongoing, but that’s part of growth.