News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple AirPod batteries and the need for right-to-repair r... by ksec on Saturday July 10, 2021 @03:36PM (#27795859)
Basically a $149 consumable wireless earphone. Somehow Apple managed to train a lot of people thinking these as consumables. And that by third year they will need a new pair because of battery, hence renewed purchase. From a company that claims they enrich people's life and care deeply about the environment.
Re:Apple AirPod batteries and the need for right-to-repair r... by szc on Sunday July 11, 2021 @03:44AM (#27799108)
A 13 gallon "garbage" bag, commonly used to dispose of waste in the USA weighs 22grams. Each Airpod, according to Apple, weights 4grams. (yeah, I'm just talking about plastic, but plastic really is part of this). The actual material (resource) cost of an Airpod is utterly insignificant (over the 3 years you cite as the lifetime) to the daily and weekly waste caused by each person in a western culture. The average waste per human for western cultures seems to be about 500+Kg per year. Over that time, the equivalent of about 375,000 Airpods. This is for materials disposed of each week, without thought - the numbers I'm using do not include any materials that are recycled. What is the actual useful "lifetime" of this garbage or trash? Perhaps a week? Or if it was a Starbucks coffee cup lid, perhaps 30 minutes. Doubtful it was 3 years.

The outrage at not being able to repair a 4gm Airpod when compared to the complete disregard to wasting other resources, in my opinion, has a very dubious moral stance.

I get that the price paid is indicative of the engineering that went into the product and you feel it might be outrageous to pay that amount for 2x 4gm.

Any argument about repairability needs to be considered in the context of actual resources used to make the product, what the cost to humanity was when compared to what it will cost to repair the product, including the human cost.

Re:Apple AirPod batteries and the need for right-to-repair r... by eric__cartman on Saturday July 10, 2021 @03:50PM (#27795965)
It's sad that even in over the ear wireless headphones the batteries are not easily replaceable. Is it too much to ask for a few discreetly hidden screws that allow the user to open the headphones up without destroying them? If that were possible, replacing a battery would take less than 10 minutes.

The same way that many good wired headphones allow you to replace the cables and earpads. That makes them last for decades as long as spare parts are available.

Now with wireless headphones when the battery dies you're SOL. You better pony up for a new pair even though the failed part costs ~$5 and could be replaced easily with good design and part availability.