My female roommate once had to walk from the marina to edge of outer mission to get home late at night because on weekends you could not get cabs and/or they wouldn't take you places that they didn't like. It was that or stay at some ultra sketch guys house or hang in a park till buses started again.
Just ridiculous - they wouldn't even do weekend only medallions to lighten load - so some commission was def. bought by the taxi cartel type folks.
Was so glad when uber came along. you could get rid of your car, no if (or if not) you'd be picked up etc.
And yes - the "broken" CC machine - the Taxi commission was busy making sure there were too few medallions and no gypsy cabs, but did diddly squat to enforce any other rules (ie, discrimination in pickups, CC machines working, lost property handling). The statistical chance that every other business seems to be able to operate CC machine, and these guys, in a regulated and licensed business could not, was just ridiculous.
Corrupt through and through.
Leaving the implementation aside (a number of different ideas come to mind), all that would be needed is for it to verify before you get in the car that it's the same type you ordered (e.g. UberX) and then detect and handle the fact that you've started a ride with that particular driver.
Ideally this would be something that could be opted in or out of on the rider's end, as well as on the driver's end.
Yellow cabs? They form a line. The passengers form a line. Passengers get into cabs, in order. Very simple and efficient.
Ride hailing? Everyone's playing some idiot game of matching-riders-to-cars, and it's totally unnecessary. At any busy airport, it's a complete shitshow.
Uber/Lyft drivers should have the option to accept rides from pickup stations, riders should be able to do the same (or it should be automatic based on GPS), there should be a convention for how it's organized, and, at a really busy place like an airport, there should even be a person who is paid to organize the process. It'd be worth it to everyone.
They're even asking for a PIN in some circumstances https://www.uber.com/blog/pin-verification-drivers/
What I'm suggesting is that they could potentially add a feature that enables hopping into any of a set of cars (probably whichever arrives first or is closest) and matches the rider with the driver after the fact.
Think it was UberCab.
https://thenextweb.com/news/ubers-first-ever-blog-posts-are-...
The drivers they had (initially) were used to talking rich execs around - so everything was leather and usually pretty dressed up.
Then SF started in on "rider / consumer protection" and weirdly the drivers became just random / unlicensed folks! Literally, uberCab was amazing, then San Francisco started fighting Uber and before you know it the cars were random / drivers random etc.
In the US that would mean allowing the same bureaucratic organization that manages Medicare/Medicaid to manage a transportation app. And then you'd deal with the Intuits of transportation that would legally hobble any meaningful development in favor of their bespoke (and expensive) ride-hailing service...
And so on. Maybe I'm just a cynic about these things.
We could instead regulate a distributed ride-sharing communications system that companies could build apps for and drivers could hook in to. Well regulated industries tend to thrive (look at internet/cellphone providers in Japan).
Why are you keeping your public companies in such a bad shape?
I'm hesistant to say this because I don't live in the USA and so it's not really my business but ....
You know you really don't have to live in this society where large organisations are allowed to maintain de-facto monopolies. Every other part of the developed world has laws which limit monopoly suppliers. The laws aren't perfect but they have an effect.
Oddly enough the only real exception to this is the digital advertising duopoly owned by two large US companies and which operates on a, pretty much, global scale. So far, the rest of the developed world hasn't worked out how to address that.
Every large organization is bureaucratic. The US federal government does pretty well, IME: Parks, highways, air travel, food safety, drug safety, medical and scientific research, public universities, NASA, military, etc etc. It's not perfect, but nothing is.
I won't use anything but rideshare apps because they seem to have higher standards for the cars and the drivers.
Taxi drivers in NYC have an informal network of places where they can use a proper bathroom. They're actually easy to spot if you know where to look. So there would be no reason to do what you claim. Also any taxi driver knows the TLC could revoke their hack license for a meter violation like what you mentioned so none of them are going to jeopardize their livelihood with such foolishness. Again this is very hard to believe and would indeed be very freak occurrences if they happened.
Yes you will have the occasional dirty car or bad driver but getting scammed is not something you ever really need to worry about with yellow cabs in NYC. Even if you're a tourist. Yellow cab drivers are some of the hardest working salt of the earth folks and you're making them out to be something they're not.
I'm Queens born, grew up in NJ and spent a lot of time in the city growing up and now I've lived here for the last decade or so and those experiences were enough to put me off of yellow cabs entirely.
You're right in that they're probably freak occurrences but I don't owe them benefit of the doubt as a consumer when I have what is in my opinion the superior solution of rideshares.
It's possible things have gotten worse, I haven't lived there in 6 years, and that was basically pre-uber there. But yeah, can't reconcile my (likely thousands of) rides with that.
edit: BTW, with the broken meter (the one time I recall this happening), I just told the guy I knew how much it cost every day - 7 bucks including tip - and that that's what I'd pay. He agreed, he took me where I was going, and I paid. Easy. I know some people will get out of the cab, I kinda remember that once when I was really young and my mother was like 'nah' and we got in another cab.
A couple months after Uber started, DC taxis started accepting credit cards.
If taxis can now offer lower prices than Uber, great! That's how competition is supposed to work.
If the price accurately represented the drivers' costs, they wouldn't refuse the rides.
We tried uber a few times then just said the black cabs were worth the extra. None of the cabs needed GPS and always knew where we needed to go and told us about areas.
I know, kinda touristy and not needed for people living their day to day, but after uber they made the rest of our trip better (is this a black cab ad?)
An experienced transiter would know that when the cabbie asks, “where are you going?” the correct answer is to get in the cab and say “I’m doing great. How are you my friend?”.
Only then would you inform them of your destination.
To be fair NYC system is maybe the best in the U.S. but they are all flawed enough I wouldn't praise any. My personal favorite that I have ridden is Tokyo's.
I'd bet that a given uber ride is 3-4x as expensive, easily, these days.
Not my experience. I used taxis in many cities for many years.
Now you get the joy of having an Uber show up then refuse to take you from SF to San Jose, and then they try to make YOU cancel so it actually costs you money, unlike a taxi.
I used to work at Curb years and years ago (and its predecessor TaxiMagic). It's always fun to still hear someone uses it and makes me wonder if any code I wrote could still be running somewhere for it.
My first programming job was at an insurance broker where 15-20 years ago I wrote a maybe 20 line VB exe to transfer a file to our systems that was invoked by a comparative rater.
It was still out there being distributed to client PCs for over a decade.
It's at least 15 years old and just keeps plugging alone. The author retired last year.
I never understood this line, but maybe it is local taxi regulations differences. Where I live the taxis cannot refuse credit payment, so if their machine is really out, they do an old school carbon copy. If they refuse that then they've basically given a free ride, so they didn't tend to put up a fight.
I’ve even had a taxi prefer to take the 20€ I had on me rather than take the 25€ bill by card. They don’t declare any of that income.
That’s why I always avoid taxis in France, as much as possible.
Yeah everybody remembers the worst situations and not the average, but Uber totally changed the game. Little electric scooters are also pretty amazing there, since it's so compact.
I have the exact same experience. It's to the point where I think SF literally hates anyone from outside the city. You have to live there to understand any of the public transit as it doesn't seem to work like that of anywhere else.
Despite being only an hour away I hate going there as driving and parking is a pain at best and downright dangerous at worst. Taking CalTrain or BART into the city isn't much better thanks to the inscrutable public transit.
After that mistake it seemed pretty easy, and this was before iPhones
Also when uber first implemented the uber-taxi option before uber-x, I tried it and would regularly have multiple cabs cancel en-route to me because they just picked up a closer fare.
But pre-Uber, calling a cab was a waste of time.
So it's a problem on both ends.
this is because of the legal bribes paid to the government... aka lobbying. The free market would have solved that. What Uber did was illegal in many places, yet the Gov. let them do it (maybe they were scared of repercussions).
I don't see how that applies to government. A corrupt person in DHS spoils all the other people there? And spoils people in the the Dept of the Interior, and in Congress?
That’s because New York is corrupt and artificially limits both ride shares and taxis. But they’re heavily biased towards taxis and their outrageous medallion system.
Taxi’s have definitely been forced to improve thanks to competition from Uber/Lyft. But don’t be fooled into thinking scarcity and high price of ride share in NYC is a naturally occurring phenomena.
It is both desirable and definitely within the purview of government to control the number of vehicles on the road. Congestion/traffic is a perfect example of an externality. Go to a megacity in a developing country like Delhi and experience traffic that causes what would be a 20 minute trip with 0 traffic to become a 4 hour trip in traffic.
Given the traffic/congestion externality, taxing/charging vehicles to enter downtowns, creating a cap on the number of taxis via medallions, etc are all the economically optimal solutions according to economics.
We want to substitute individual vehicle transport to mass transit wherein there is a dramatically reduced externality (e.g. adding a person to a subway train or a bus only has an effect if that train hits capacity -- in contrast to adding an additional vehicle to the road).
Ideally, the pricing model for ridesharing and taxis should be dynamic but account for the congestion impacts (i.e. internalize the traffic externality). The fixed pricing of taxis doesn't do this (though medallions partly do from a more traditional cap and trade scheme) and the surge pricing of Uber and Lyft is only to clear their internal market and not to resolve the traffic impacts of all those additional vehicles on the road. As such, there have been numerous peer reviewed papers that have demonstrated that traffic is actually increased by ridesharing due to a substitution away from mass transit.
Now I'm in NY and I use taxis almost as often as rideshares. The Curb app makes it easy to find a taxi and the prices are almost always lower. But half the time I can't get a taxi through the app at all and have to wander the streets or use Lyft/Uber.