News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by WalterBright on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:16PM (#27786011)
> This OS and its shell later inspired Digital Research's CP/M OS, the first industry-standard OS for 8-bit micros.

The irony here is that MS-DOS was routinely derided for having "stolen" from CP/M. Having used the PDP-10 and PDP-11 before CP/M, I knew that CP/M was based on DEC's ideas.

Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by retrac on Friday July 09, 2021 @03:53PM (#27787840)
CP/M could probably be fairly described as "heavily inspired" by the likes of TOPS-10, right down to borrowing some command names and some architectural ideas.

DOS 1.0 could probably be fairly described as a CP/M clone -- it was intended to be binary compatible basically, such that translated (perhaps automatically - the 8086 had similar compatibility goals) 8080 CP/M programs would run directly on DOS without much if any change.

Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by TheOtherHobbes on Friday July 09, 2021 @06:19PM (#27789157)
The PDP-10 - and TOPS-10 - were also used by Gates and Allen (and Davidoff) to write their version of BASIC.

The lineage is more like OS-8 -> TOPS-10 -> CP/M -> DOS, although TOPS-10 did a lot more than CP/M etc because it was running on a small mainframe and not a micro.

PDP-10s were also one of the foundations of ARPANET. And also used in early AI research. And also an influence on RMS.

There was also a separate TOPS-20 lineage. TOPS-20 was the successor to TOPS-10 and (more or less) the anti-UNIX. It was designed to be as friendly as possible with command completion and other niceties like versioning and a kind of trash can - although it was quite verbose and had some strange command names of its own. (Like EXPUNGE.)

Some of the philosophy of TOPS-20 made it into VMS. Cutler famously hated UNIX, but by the time he was done with NT the remains of VMS had been thoroughly Microsofted and it was hard to see any of the TOPS-20 lineage left in the UX.

DEC shot itself in the kneecaps when it killed the PDP-10 line in 1983 and went all-in on the VAX. The VAX was a perfectly fine computer, but culturally it wasn't in the same space. PDP-10s were almost proto-Macs in the mainframe market - very popular with academics and creative researchers.

The VAX felt more like a functional but unexciting proto-PC product. A lot of PDP-10 customers - and not a few PDP-10 engineers and developers - never forgave DEC for the move.

Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by skissane on Friday July 09, 2021 @09:09PM (#27790232)
> The lineage is more like OS-8 -> TOPS-10 -> CP/M -> DOS, although TOPS-10 did a lot more than CP/M etc because it was running on a small mainframe and not a micro.

Gary Kildall had experience with a bunch of different DEC systems, definitely PDP-8s running OS/8 and PDP-11s running RT-11, he may have had some experience with PDP-10s as well. I would say he more took ideas from DEC operating systems in general rather than copying any one of them in particular, but if people want to cite particular ones, OS/8 and RT-11 are mentioned more often than TOPS-10.

He also used IBM VM/CMS at the Naval Postgraduate School, which is arguably where CP/M gets drive letters from – CMS uses single letters to identify disks, DEC operating systems generally used multi-character device names like DL0: or RKA0: instead.

> Some of the philosophy of TOPS-20 made it into VMS.

Can you give a specific example of this? VMS was mainly influenced by RSX-11. What did it get from TOPS-20 that it didn't get from RSX-11?

Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by pinewurst on Friday July 09, 2021 @10:20PM (#27790617)
I don’t think DEC had much choice other than to kill the PDP-10 at that point. It was obvious that the non-legacy software world wasn’t a 36-bit one and never would be again. It was obvious it was taking increasingly incompatible hacks to extend the base 18-bit memory addressing (various combinations of magic segments). And while some may disagree, it wasn’t easy to make that architecture fast, hence the long standing performance plateau (the version codeveloped w VAX8600 never fully worked and XKL is only a proof of a faster system in much later technology but still much slower than other current CPUs). Nostalgia takes no prisoners.
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by aap_ on Saturday July 10, 2021 @04:31AM (#27792009)
> The lineage is more like OS-8 -> TOPS-10 -> CP/M -> DOS

TOPS-10 predates OS-8

Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by zh3 on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:56PM (#27786498)
As a 60+ year old programmer who's pretty familiar with writing code for PDP-11s (down to device driver level) I'm interested in the link from PDPs to CP/M, which (as with MSDOS) I've also written for at a low level. While the link from CP/M to QDOS/MSDOS is clear to me, the jump from PDP11 trap instructions to CP/M's BDOS invocation is less clear. Is is the general idea of system calls/returns, or a deeper connection I've missed?
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by cmrdporcupine on Friday July 09, 2021 @02:01PM (#27786556)
What I remember reading is that Gary Kildall was a big RT-11 and OS-8 user and so it's more that the shell/command line was patterned after some things he was familiar with there. I don't think anybody has made the claim that CP/M's internals were patterned off of PDP OS internals as much. More interface conventions.
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by zh3 on Friday July 09, 2021 @03:01PM (#27787260)
I didn't know that; having RT-11 at work and running CP/M at home, there was a 'sort of' similiarity there but not like the same kind of underlying structure between CP/M and DOS (hence the reason I was asking). Thanks!
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by zabzonk on Friday July 09, 2021 @04:41PM (#27788255)
I'm also a 60+ year old programmer (let's make that 60++), but I'm not clear what you are asking. I was quite proud of a Forth-like language I wrote using CP/M (Wordstar, assembler) back round about 1980 - but once it was loaded into memory (via CP/M) it didn't use CP/M BDOS at all, system calls or trap instructions.
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by zh3 on Friday July 09, 2021 @04:48PM (#27788315)
That's interesting, how did you do I/O? Bypassing the OS was a lot easier back then :)
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by zabzonk on Friday July 09, 2021 @04:53PM (#27788372)
Direct memory access, BIOS (such as it was). I was actually toying with a version that would be fully CP/M hosted, so that it could read and write CP/M files but then I got a proper paying programming job - previously I was a microbiologist, moonlighting, and who could resist the delights of a DecSystem10? And then an IBM 4381?
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by WalterBright on Friday July 09, 2021 @02:27PM (#27786838)
I don't see any conceptual difference between the methods used to interface with the OS. It's more one of detail.
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by bluGill on Friday July 09, 2021 @04:57PM (#27788404)
Well IBM wanted CP/M, but couldn't get DR to talk to them, so they ask Bill Gates if he could do something. Between Bill Gates already knowing CP/M (he wrote the basic that everyone used including on CP/M systems) and IBM wanting CP/M it isn't a surprised what inspired MSDOS 1.0.
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by rst on Friday July 09, 2021 @06:46PM (#27789369)
Except that Microsoft didn't write DOS 1.0; they bought it. It was a relabeled version of a CP/M clone originally called QDOS (quick and dirty OS) that was written by Tim Paterson, for a company called Seattle Computer Products, reportedly in about six weeks.
Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by EvanAnderson on Friday July 09, 2021 @06:53PM (#27789438)
Here's a nice video of Tim Paterson talking about QDOS / 86/DOS, Seattle Computer Products (and their x86 hardware):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R2Qh0O3Dt10

Re:The historical significance of DEC and the PDP-7, -8, -11... by hsnewman on Friday July 09, 2021 @09:19PM (#27790295)
I was wondering why the PDP 10 wasn't mentioned in the article, it's historical significance is unquestionable (some of the first computers on the internet...).