News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by rektide on Thursday July 08, 2021 @10:49PM (#27780035)
> In the past, it was possible for an aspiring camera repair technician to go to school for it, just as one would do to learn many other skilled trades. Unfortunately, that is no longer true. The trade schools that once trained workers for the photographic equipment repair industry have all closed down. Camera manufacturers still train their own service techs, but that training is only available to those who are hired to work for them.

In general it feels like the world is heading towards un-understanding. The human world has become so big that we have relinquished our knowledge.

Oh sure, there are the John Deeres's, Monsanto's, many many many of us programmers here, actively or passively reducing how knowable, how manipulable the real systems of the world are to end consumers. Computing for so long gave enormous powers, but lately it feels like it winnows & narrows down what is possible, what is understandable, what is visible.

But I also feel like this was part of the direction, part of what globalization does, part of what productization does. Talent & skill are no longer dispersed widely, but concentrated, in very large enterprises that make gobs & gobs & gobs of money, that own the seemingly ever complexifying means of production & supply chains behind it. We have lots of great means in the world, but as our consumer expectations rise & produce quality increases, there's less interest in what the small local shop can do, with it's couple camera gurus, who once would have been a formidable force.

Trying to articulate the values of knowability, of understandability, of systems that we can be involved with is very very hard, especially after access has already faded, especially as the visible, humanizing upsides have decayed. This was mentioned by @adamhjk in his recent thread on Copilot, & FOSS[1], and this is one of the prime things that keeps me up at night: the world is becoming manufactured, and it doesn't need us, but if we could be here, if our souls were given some self-determinism, I think the world & our souls would both be much richer places.

[1] https://twitter.com/adamhjk/status/1413173304014241793

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by danboarder on Friday July 09, 2021 @12:51AM (#27780567)
We are lucky to have a vibrant Right to Repair (1) movement progressing, and lots of DIY tinkerers like myself that fix anything and everything and build 3D printers, and people like Louis Rossmann (2) who repairs laptops and is looking to get a Right to Repair initiative on the ballot in NY. So things are looking up more from how I see it.

1) https://www.repair.org/

2) https://www.youtube.com/user/rossmanngroup/videos

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by bzzzt on Friday July 09, 2021 @03:19AM (#27781222)
People who build 3d printers don't design the microcontroller used to actually drive te thing. It's magic with a DIY layer on top. Right to repair may help in keep costs and waste down by making swapping highly integrated parts easier, but I don't think Louis Rossmann or any other human on earth has a complete grasp of the entire iOS codebase. That's still a long way from the build your own radio kits of the 1950's where it was possible to understand what each component did. (and even then, how to make components was already impossible because you did not have the tools to do so)
Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by toomanybeersies on Friday July 09, 2021 @10:01AM (#27783760)
No human has ever been able to understand and build all the tools that they use. Steel was to the neolithic man what silicon is to the modern man. Throughout history, science has been more about trying to understand the mechanisms of how we utilise nature than genuinely novel ideas like relativity.

The problem is the deliberate secrecy of knowledge; holding information to oneself in order to gain an advantage over others.

You don't need to understand gravity to benefit from the gravity. Likewise, the average person doesn't need to understand integrated circuits, atomic physics, or any other high technology. The harm comes from those who hold information to themselves in order to exploit others.

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by userbinator on Friday July 09, 2021 @09:33AM (#27783485)
and even then, how to make components was already impossible because you did not have the tools to do so

Passive components are still (relatively) easy to make --- hand-winding inductors is still common in amateur radio, for example; and even diodes are possible (crystal radio), but transistors and other semiconductors are definitely beyond the average hobbyist.

(If you have glassworking skills, vacuum tubes are just barely doable --- that's how they were invented, after all.)

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by rektide on Friday July 09, 2021 @11:35AM (#27784750)
> People who build 3d printers don't design the microcontroller used to actually drive the thing.

On the upside, hopefully soon-ish they well. Open chip design has become a very quick moving area lately. We're starting to see more fabs open up to having chips made.

But the makers probably won't be building the chip fabs to make those chips.

> It's magic with a DIY layer on top.

It'd be lovely to see some folks try to DIY a fab. How hard do you think it would be to go build a 1µm chip fab yourself (what the 486 launched on)?

The fab is hard (probably! not sure!), but we're getting pretty good at spreading the knowledge of how to design chips.

Your point is well taken that we can't know everything. I like the above quote, "magic with a DIY layer on top". In the 3d printing scenario, I think we're closer to full-knowledge than we might originally credit. With something more complex like an OS, I'd rate it down to more a question of knowability: no one may know Linux entirely or even let's say (a much vaster) Freedesktop stack, but there's a couple thousand people on the planet (maybe decreasing, ffffff) that, if they had some reason to figure something out, could go & dive in & understand all the relevant subsystems to the challenge at hand reasonably well within a day. Computing drags in so so so many things, there is so much going on, just mountains of code... but our tools to navigate & observe & experiment & view are highly highly refined, are very very good. Computing is imminently knowable, everywhere (except when institutionally designed not to be).

Personally I really think the web as a medium is probably one of the best ways to introduce people to information technology, to bestow agency & learn about systems. There is a consistent, malleable, programmatic (inter-)system, focused on media delivery (immediate results) with well defined rules. But I wrestle with this difficulty you present: even with the best DevTools (quite likely one of the greatest understanding/learning-machines on the planet), under the surface lies of it all is an incredibly complex browser, constituting a vast magical system. One can be a complete expert at web development, but few of those experts are browser experts. Usually there's no call to go below the abstraction boundary, to understand the magic. But it is a barrier. The web is by far my most preferred rich environment, the most hands-on, practical, tactile thing I could imagine putting before a new IT recruit, but it's with faith not reason that I would justify putting them to such a highly abstract machine first. And, alas, there aren't even that many browsers left to compare across- not that most were open source or viewable anyhow, not until very recently.

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by brudgers on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:00AM (#27780599)
I find this resource is evidence of balance. While it was possible to go to school for camera repair, access was extremely limited…lots of hurdles and gatekeepers.

But here it is on HN and you don’t have to know anyone or anything more than the phrase “camera repair” can go in the Google.

Today interest is enough to get started along the learning curve. Sure it would be great to have access to an experienced expert on the workbench by the door. But that was always an extremely limited resource.

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by xkeysc0re on Friday July 09, 2021 @12:58AM (#27780594)
> the world is becoming manufactured, and it doesn't need us, but if we could be here, if our souls were given some self-determinism, I think the world & our souls would both be much richer places.

The philosopher Jean Baudrillard speaks on this topic a bit in his last work, "The Agony of Power." Highly recommended reading for all those in tech

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by SilverRed on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:27AM (#27780708)
These days cameras are solid state things which tend to just not break like mechanical items did. And when they do break, the camera body part tends to not be terribly expensive so you would just buy a new body and keep your expensive glass accessories.
Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by toomanybeersies on Friday July 09, 2021 @09:15AM (#27783333)
> The human world has become so big that we have relinquished our knowledge

Sure, the average person probably knows/understands less of the sum of 'human knowledge' than the medieval man. But the average person has more knowledge, both learned and learnable, than ever before in human history.

Most people have never been particularly knowledgable or skilled. The average medieval peasant was no more able to make steel than the average person today.

Ideas and theories that were groundbreaking at their time, such as Newton's calculus, Shannons information theory, and Einstein's theory of relativity are now undergraduate (or even high school) courses. As part of my B.Sc in Computer Science, we studied public key cryptography (in particular RSA), which conceptually didn't exist until the 1970's. The average undergraduate probably knows more about cryptography than Alan Turing ever did.

In the 1800s, we didn't have biology, chemistry, and physics, we simply had "natural philosophy". The sum of our scientific knowledge was so meagre that there was no need for that distinction. Today, not only is physics distinct from biology, but quantum physics is distinct from geophysics. In medicine, don't just have doctors, we have neurologists, paediatricians, and radiologists.

> Trying to articulate the values of knowability, of understandability, of systems that we can be involved with is very very hard

The world today is more knowable than ever. When I was in primary school 20-something years ago, if I wanted to find information I had to go to the library and hope they had a book on the subject. These days, if I'm at the pub stuck in an argument about who scored the first try in the 1987 Rugby World Cup (Michael Jones), it takes about 10 seconds pull out my phone and find the answer. I think your concern is the opposite, that there's too much to know. It's so knowable that we spend at least 10 years at school just learning things.

Until recently, apart from (and due to) the lack of knowledge, it was incredibly hard to transfer and obtain information.

Before ~1455, when Johannes Gutenberg developed printing press, the reproduction of knowledge was incredibly labour intensive. It took more than a year for a monk to create a copy of the bible. Gutenberg's printing press shortened that to a week. Today, I can download a 40 megapixel copy of the Gutenberg bible (2 GB) in less than a minute. [1]

In 1820 only 14% of the worlds population was literate, it wasn't until the 1960's that more than 50% of the world could read. Even now, in Australia, 20% of Aboriginal people are illiterate, and up to 65% are functionally illiterate.

That said, we shouldn't rest on our laurels. We still need to continue to strive for our right to the freedom and access of information and knowledge.

TL;DR I think you have a romantic idea of the history of information and knowledge.

[1] For what it's worth, I'm not religious, but it's a good example of the history of information

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by rektide on Friday July 09, 2021 @11:15AM (#27784527)
You talk very eloquently to how much more knowledge the natural philosophers have dug up and how much more a person might be able to know.

But I was born into that world. The world that has happened during my lived life has been one where a greater and greater amount of the total knowledge has been withheld, retained, kept proprietary.

And worse, a large amount of this knowledge is knowledge that is impossible for anyone else to ever figure out. Almost all manufacturers keep their processes & ingredients secret. Want to know what this Tyvek thing is that you wrap your house with? We'll give you some marketing blurb, but mostly you have to trust us. With cloud computing, with DRM, there is no observable world: where-as with Tyvek we could buy some & put it under microscopes, tear it apart, run mass-spectrometers on it, try to reproduce it, we couldn't even take our chips out, give them an acid bath, & see what they do any more, because vast amount of the functionality is behind a firewall. That knowledge is physically retained, withheld, guarded inside a data center.

And that knowledge is vast, is the very core of the business of many of the biggest companies of the world. Powering products that we interact with for hours a day.

This domain of unnatural knowledge defines more and more of the world about us. It shapes society more actively in our day to day than our relationship with the natural world, our knowledge of the sciences. In spite of being the most active force shaping the world about us, humans, it has felt to me, have less and less ability to peer into, to see, to understand the world about them. While our total knowledge grows & we have a bigger pool of knowable things- truly a wonder- as you argue, I argue that the past handful of decades have seen far more knowledge created which is un-discoverable, un-findable than at any other point. And it is knowledge of the basic world about us, of how the basic elements of our world work. This to me is an anathema.

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by toomanybeersies on Friday July 09, 2021 @11:51AM (#27784959)
I generally agree with you, that proprietary knowledge isn't a good thing, but I don't don't see how things AWS Graviton are different to Tyvek or Nomex.

Given the opportunity, DuPont and Amazon would hide their proprietary knowledge just the same. Maybe one chemicals are easier to reverse engineer than cloud platforms, but the intention is the same.

Re:Camera Repair Course (2019) by chrstphrknwtn on Thursday July 08, 2021 @11:27PM (#27780212)
I'm genuinely curious why this reply is being downvoted.