News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by goda90 on Thursday July 08, 2021 @03:30PM (#27776629)
So we should be doing calculations of "what percentage of its lifetime power production is required to sequester the carbon it took to create and use it?"
Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by kristopolous on Thursday July 08, 2021 @03:39PM (#27776707)
That's almost a peak oil approach, which was both insufficient and the most accurate possible.

We can only state things in terms of stuff which currently exists. The future will yield different results because new techniques and technologies will come along. But we can't rely on or predict them.

There's a lot of "pons and fleischmanning" when talking about future energy use - mass scale geo-engineering or sucking carbon out of the atmosphere technology, it has to be avoided. The technologies don't exist yet. We have to use real-world stuff.

Using current reality for future projections is inherently defective because of the innovation factor and routinely leads to bad predictions (such as peak oil[1]), but it's the only reality we have and is sadly as good as we're going to get. Anything else (such as say next-gen nuclear) has to be regarded as a fiction in the calculations until it actually exists.

It's messy, sloppy, and requires a large trashcan but the alternative is to get to results that rely on things that literally do not actually exist. Kinda like how the people planning Operation Downfall (the land invasion of japan during ww2) weren't told about all the other things in the works (backroom deal to get Russia to declare war on Japan and the Manhattan project), they had to assume those things would continue to not happen.

[1] - The Hubbert peak was essentially that the amount of energy to extract and refine oil would surpass the energy from the oil and thus make it unsustainable so the operations for oil extraction would cease. New techniques have been developed (such as fracking) which have changed this math, but in 1956, using 1956 knowledge, this was the best prediction possible. It's somewhat Malthusian - who was also as "correct as possible" with the best science that 1798 had to offer. He couldn't factor in, say, the Haber–Bosch process from 112 years in the future in his food growth computations.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by scarby2 on Thursday July 08, 2021 @05:24PM (#27777785)
> Using current reality for future projections is inherently defective because of the innovation factor and routinely leads to bad predictions (such as peak oil[1]), but it's the only reality we have and is sadly as good as we're going to get. Anything else (such as say next-gen nuclear) has to be regarded as a fiction in the calculations until it actually exists.

but are certain that at least one of these fictitious scenarios will come into being. We just have no certainty as to which.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by jandrese on Thursday July 08, 2021 @03:41PM (#27776727)
The first step in this is inventing a scalable way of sequestering the carbon from atmospheric CO2. We have been talking about carbon markets for over three decades now and still have not solved the supply side of the equation. It's frankly embarrassing.
Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by abraae on Thursday July 08, 2021 @04:29PM (#27777197)
> We have been talking about carbon markets for over three decades now and still have not solved the supply side of the equation.

Talking, but never actually doing.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by jandrese on Thursday July 08, 2021 @04:35PM (#27777278)
Carbon Credits are a thing, but the fundamental problem is that one 1 of carbon credit isn't used to pull 1 ton of carbon out of the atmosphere. Instead they're like brownie points that politicians arbitrarily set the price on.

If there were some large scale way to scrub carbon out of the atmosphere then the market could work, but in their current state they are a joke.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by Dylan16807 on Thursday July 08, 2021 @05:50PM (#27778047)
> If there were some large scale way to scrub carbon out of the atmosphere then the market could work

We don't need to wait for that to set up an impactful system. At the simplest, have a serious tax and dump a bunch of the resulting money into research grants and a big reverse auction for capture.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by liketochill on Thursday July 08, 2021 @07:11PM (#27778743)
Http://www.carbonengineering.com
Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by rapind on Thursday July 08, 2021 @04:07PM (#27776974)
Is it embarrassing? Maybe it’s a shortage of market incentives or maybe it’s just a really difficult problem? We shouldn’t assume we’ll have innovative solutions for everything.

I think a healthier futuristic perspective would be one that considers only some percentage of problems will be solved through innovation, at least in the near term. That way we accept we still could be screwed and need to work harder!

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by jandrese on Thursday July 08, 2021 @04:28PM (#27777189)
It's embarrassing that we are still using fossil fuels without any plan to deal with the pollution it causes. It isn't like people weren't aware of the problem either, I remember talks in the 80s about the Greenhouse Effect and how we needed to act quickly before the problem got out of hand.

We're already well past the point where if we just stopped emitting we will be ok. We now need carbon capture as part of the solution and thus far nothing has panned out. Nor is there much political will to actually push for solutions. They're just seen as pure cost that will make your country less competitive so nobody wants to be the only country who goes for "truth" in this prisoner's dilemma.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by ipaddr on Thursday July 08, 2021 @07:35PM (#27778904)
The big problems in the 80s were acid rain and recycling. We kind of nailed those.

Global warming wasn't as important as a nuclear winter.

Embarrassing to use fossil fuels? In front of who? some future self who judges you? Wait till you see next decades' problems.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by Qwertious on Thursday July 08, 2021 @09:53PM (#27779721)
Recycling plastic is a red herring popularized by the fossil fuel industry. Up until recently most of its actual success came from a combination of:

1) China's heavy exports meaning that transporting bulk goods TO China was practically free, because the ships were making the trip while empty anyway

2) China's manufacturing industry growing so fast that they simply, literally could not get enough plastic

3) Dirt-cheap labor costs in some parts of China enabling labor-intensive recycling on razor thin margins

4) Corruption and a disregard for the true costs of environmental damage making waste dumping look far more profitable than it actually was.

AIUI these have disappeared recently, due to China's economic growth, and shift from exports to selling domestically, and their environmental damage starting to seriously catch up with them, all of which resulted in them no longer accepting plastic.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by ZeroGravitas on Friday July 09, 2021 @07:42AM (#27782650)
China still accepts plastic for recycling. As you note they make a lot of stuff and so need it and have net exports so lots of ships are going there anyway.

What they banned was people pretending to send recyclable plastic but really just sending them any old junk.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_National_Sword

Text from their official notification:

> Objective and rationale, including the nature of urgent problems where applicable: The reasons for urgent measure: According to the Special Actions of Strengthening the Supervision and Strictly Striking of Illegal "Foreign Garbage" by the General Administration of Customs of China, Ministry of Environmental Protection of China, Ministry of Public Security of China and General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of China, as well as the Special Actions of Striking of the Illegal Actions of Imported Solid Waste Processing and Utilizing Sectors by Ministry of Environmental Protection of China, we found that large amounts of dirty wastes or even hazardous wastes are mixed in the solid waste that can be used as raw materials. This polluted China's environment seriously. To protect China's environmental interests and people's health, we urgently adjust the imported solid wastes list, and forbid the import of solid wastes that are highly polluted. Protection of human health or safety; Protection of animal or plant life or health; Protection of the environment.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by petre on Friday July 09, 2021 @02:39AM (#27781028)
A waste management scientist in India has a royality free patent of using plastic in asphalt. This is a good way to recycle plastic, but one could pave only so many roads.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plastic_road

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by jandrese on Thursday July 08, 2021 @09:23PM (#27779557)
We fixed acid rain by exporting it to China. Recycling is kind of a mess at the moment due to China stopping pretending that they were recycling plastic.

We did mostly fix the Ozone hole though, albeit it is still an ongoing process.

Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by beebeepka on Thursday July 08, 2021 @08:02PM (#27779067)
Recycling has been nailed? I might have missed a few major breakthroughs because the plastixa problem seems anything but fixed to me
Re:Why geothermal isn't ubiquitous and how it might get that... by adrianN on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:45AM (#27780784)
If we had an actual market for carbon emissions, people would be very incentivized to come up with solutions that scale better than burying charcoal. But since we're not even incentivizing people to bury charcoal, I'm not very surprised that we made little progress at doing more difficult things.