News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by publicola1990 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @11:19PM (#27768147)
Not related to the article, but would you be able to comment on why Sinhala is classified as an Indo-European language, rather than as a Dravidian language?
Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by umanwizard on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @11:27PM (#27768190)
Because it is descended from Sanskrit which has been known to be an Indo-European language since the very beginning of comparative linguistics.

It is genetically unrelated to Dravidian languages, but it does have a lot of Dravidian loanwords.

Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by publicola1990 on Thursday July 08, 2021 @03:57AM (#27769347)
Kannada is very influenced by Sanskrit, but still is a Dravidian lang. Is there more Sanskrit influence in Sinhala compared with Kannada?
Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by hliyan on Thursday July 08, 2021 @06:38AM (#27770273)
I speak and read Sinhala fluently. I can't speak to origins, but one thing that struck me the first time I learned a little Latin was the similarities:

queen: latin = regina. sinhala = regina.

tooth: latin = dente. sinhala = danta.

nose: latin = nasus. sinhala = naasa.

Etc.

Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by chakkepolja on Thursday July 08, 2021 @06:03AM (#27770071)
It's more about linguistic structure than origin of words.

Kannada, Telugu & Malayalam, even pre-dravidan-movement Tamil have lot of borrowed sanskrit vocabulary, but they retain structure of Dravidian languages.

Also most common words used are also Dravidan origin.

For example:

Kannada - Naanu, Tamil - Naan, Telugu - Nenu, Malayalam - Njan

Etc..

Another small thing unique about Dravidian languages is clusivity, there's exclusive 'we' and inclusive 'we'. While modern Kannada, unlike Tamil / Telugu, doesn't retain this feature, some dialects such as Havyaka retain this feature.

Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by publicola1990 on Thursday July 08, 2021 @06:27AM (#27770204)
Yes, but does Sinhala hase the linguistic structure of Dravidian languages or not?
Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by tmmx on Friday July 09, 2021 @01:56AM (#27780830)
Sinhala does not have the structure of Dravidian languages. However, the alphabet used to write Sinhala has a shared origin with the alphabets used to write Dravidian languages. Also due to long coexistence with Tamil in the island, Sinhala burrows lot of loanwords from Tamil.

I am Sinhalese who grew up in Sri Lanka. As such I am exposed to Tamil, but when I watch Tamil TV, at best I can pick few words here and there. But when I watch Hindi show, I understand a lot more due to the structure is very similar to that of Sinhala.

Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by chakkepolja on Thursday July 08, 2021 @08:13AM (#27770916)
I don't understand sinhala but if it is classified as Indo Aryan language and not Dravidian, then that is the reason.

There will be always be some influence and loanwords from neighbouring languages but comparative linguistics can tell origin / family of the language pretty accurately.

Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by umanwizard on Thursday July 08, 2021 @09:41AM (#27771811)
Yeah, historical linguistics distinguishes between a language being influenced by another vs. descending from another.

For example, English is descended from Old English (a Germanic language), but was very heavily influenced by French (a Romance language, i.e. descended from Latin). The grammatical structure and origin of basic words are still more Germanic than Romance.

Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by ummonk on Thursday July 08, 2021 @03:35AM (#27769242)
Languages are classified based on relatedness, not geography. Just as you have an Indo-Aryan language, Sinhala, that made it down to Sri Lanka, you also have a Dravidian language, Brahui, that stuck around up in Pakistan.
Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by thaumasiotes on Thursday July 08, 2021 @08:37AM (#27771147)
The famous example of an "out of place" language is Madagascar, where they speak a language you'd expect to find spoken by Pacific islanders.
Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by cmrajan on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @11:26PM (#27768183)
Not OP, but Sinhala is classified as Indo-Aryan having developed when Buddhism spread to Srilanka and separate from Dravidian family of languages which is mostly limited to Southern part of India
Re:Sri Lanka’s ancient, almost lost martial art by chakkepolja on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @11:58PM (#27768322)
Some tales tell that Sinhalese were Buddhists from somewhere near modern day Bengal who fled to avoid persecution.