News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by squarefoot on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @06:37PM (#27766555)
Clarification, about mid-page.

"... At least for an initial period, we want to prevent counterfeiters from blindly downloading a file and manufacturing it without any R&D effort or contribution to the community, because the result of that will be tens or hundreds of low-quality clones which do not have nearly the quality of ours, and no benefit for the community. ..."

"... This is why for them we chose the same approach as Raspberry Pi: we publish schematics so that anyone can learn from them, and we keep the entire software stack completely open source. But at least for now, Altium files are available only upon request so that we can check whether someone can actually manufacture them with the required quality. ..."

"Alessandro Ranellucci Head of Maker Business, Open Source & Community ARDUINO.CC"

Aside the unfortunate comparison with the Raspberry PI approach (the RPi uses binary blobs, therefore is not open), it seems the case is closed: at least initially, hackers will have all necessary information minus what is often being used only by clone builders, namely CAD files. Schematics are open and software is open; building clones is still possible for users but less convenient for companies.

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by admax88q on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @09:30PM (#27767626)
> building clones is still possible for users but less convenient for companies.

That's a pretty charitable way to phrase it. I would think companies looking to make clones have the expertise and can afford to take the effort to recreate the PCB layouts from the schematics, but normal users are denied the opportunity to learn from it.

It's a small roadblock to commercial clones, but a complex gate to the average user looking to learn.

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by squarefoot on Thursday July 08, 2021 @11:39AM (#27773400)
True, however they're not aiming at big industry but cheap asian cloners. Forcing them to hire someone to produce complete layouts would have some impact on the final costs of otherwise very cheap boards.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by pjmlp on Thursday July 08, 2021 @02:25AM (#27768949)
When I was in school doing electronics late 80's, that was the way to go.

So 80's high school students were able to do it, but average users are not?

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by soco on Thursday July 08, 2021 @05:15AM (#27769752)
Then you surely remember how important layout is for cross signaling, high frequency and and and. All this will be missing from the schematic.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by pjmlp on Thursday July 08, 2021 @06:53AM (#27770363)
No one said it was an hello world effort.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by admax88q on Thursday July 08, 2021 @11:51AM (#27773619)
When I was in high school we wrote our own code. So I guess we can stop doing open source as well right?
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by pjmlp on Thursday July 08, 2021 @01:30PM (#27775231)
So now you turned into a manager and are delegating coding tasks to others?

When GPL fades away, the new wave of shareware and public domain will rule again anyway, now we call it copyleft.

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by hulitu on Thursday July 08, 2021 @02:06AM (#27768868)
As I said, schematics is all you need. And making your own layout makes you learn. Just copying blindly does not help. And there are a lot of scammers who will take your design and compete with you so let them do some work.
Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by admax88q on Thursday July 08, 2021 @11:51AM (#27773599)
Oh come now, you can't just "learn by doing" when it comes to circuit layout, when you have no idea what will and won't work. Especially with modern high frequency circuits that have a lot more challenges due to cross signaling and propagation delays.

Sure copying blindly doesn't help, but neither does shooting int he dark. Having reference layouts that actually work however can be a useful learning resource and starting point to work from if you want to do something similar but slightly different.

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by duskwuff on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @06:46PM (#27766627)
Meanwhile, ST publishes full schematics and CAD files for all of their development boards, e.g.

https://www.st.com/en/evaluation-tools/stm32h747i-disco.html...

They aren't freely licensed, to be fair, but at least they're published! And, in practice, ST won't mind if you refer to their reference boards while designing your own hardware; that's what they're for, after all.

Re:Arduino Pro hardware is not open-source hardware by MayeulC on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @07:00PM (#27766741)
It's different as ST is a chip manufacturer. If you make clones, chances are they'll only work with their chips, so you end up ordering from them anyway. Win-win. Boards could have an open license though.