News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by tqi on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @01:06PM (#27763375)
Reading the article, it's unclear to me what the cost actually is?
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by DerpyBaby123 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @01:12PM (#27763433)
Let me summarize through quotes:

>This is not an update, but a new messaging system from which you can’t switch back.

> These are simply features presented to artificially devalue one of the systems, distract from the real changes, and manipulate users into changing to a different system.

> this change will eventually link to your real name.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by tqi on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @01:31PM (#27763666)
Hm well the first two aren't really costs, are they?

The third is a conjecture, and as I understand it this is only being offered to people who already have linked their Facebook and Instagram accounts?

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by DerpyBaby123 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @04:41PM (#27765529)
Yes, the first is a literal cost, you lose something you used to be able to use.

The second is the cost of a degraded system of instagram messaging

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by tqi on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @09:25PM (#27767597)
So the sticking point on the first point is that it is a one-way decision? By that framing, every product update is a cost. Upgrading from iOS 13 to iOS 14 was a cost. For the second point, then every time a company decides not to build a new feature that is also a cost? I guess I could buy that, but it feels pretty weak.
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by nine_k on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @07:59PM (#27767141)
When you use a free but not open product, you are not the customer. This is an old and tired idea, but also true.

If you want features not disappearing or changing when you don't want them to, you need to be in control. I know only two ways to be in control: you either pay (and the agreement contains a provision about the product properties you care about), or manage it yourself.

Using a free-as-in-beer service always puts someone else in control, not you. Bear it in mind every time you register with such a service, and shape your expectations.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by cartoonworld on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @09:20PM (#27767560)
Yes, proprietary software is negative in the freedom dimension.

You have to realize that what your saying here is a category error: The libre alternatives don't have billions of dollars of marketing, engineering, market cap and users.

EFF here is trying to point out exactly what you are espousing. These kind of dark patterns are used at all levels to drive engagement, including sign up and retention. ("But ... How will I be able to talk to my friends if I delete Facebook??")

I can't recommend a solution, but "Well, its free, what do you expect?" is even worse.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by nine_k on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @09:43PM (#27767695)
Would you prefer to hold private parties somehow liable to follow your convenience or best interest, and not their best interest? Anyone who would suggest that should prepare for this approach to be applied to themselves — that is, being coerced to do what some other people want. Whatever it is, it's not freedom.

(Yes, indeed, the law works by coercion in the common interests. But I don't see any law having been broken here.)

So yes, it's free to play — what did you expect? Too much? Memorize this, and remember next time. Tell your friends and relatives what to not expect. Name and shame the entities which did something unsavory: this helps make users less gullible, and through that, nudges companies to be more careful.

Consider avoiding the use of stuff you don't control for important things. Be conscious when consuming free candy from a for-profit entity, even if you think your interests are currently aligned. But don't force anybody's hand.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by cartoonworld on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @10:57PM (#27768046)
>Consider avoiding the use of stuff you don't control for important things. Be conscious when consuming free candy from a for-profit entity, even if you think your interests are currently aligned. But don't force anybody's hand.

This is excellent advice, but it doesn't help all the people who are not even in the same league as this idea, who are just making their way through the landscape using whatever they come across to not get herded further into the vortex of asshole walled gardens.

The value proposition of this to mom or some kid is gonna sound like: "What?"

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by nine_k on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @11:33PM (#27768215)
I see.

But I hope that both the mom and the kid will understand my comparison to free candy. Some moms even teach their kids to be cautious with that.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by cartoonworld on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @11:41PM (#27768253)
I'm sure they can relate, but the good alternative is probably going to involve thinking about something. Just consider how many people can't stop clicking phishing emails.

Our society has really turned the screws up wrt attention, it's pretty taxing just living life sometimes. I hate to get all "hoi polloi", but I mean people are out there that are sure Sars-CoV-2 vaccines render them magnetic.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by croes on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:32PM (#27764316)
It costs you your choice.
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by reaperducer on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @01:35PM (#27763716)
I'm not sure the third part is conjecture. The EFF has an entire article about it: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/12/changes-facebooks-real...
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by tqi on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:24PM (#27764242)
Ah sorry, I was being unclear.

Facebook definitely has a "real name" policy, but it isn't clear to me why a unified messaging experience means that your real name will now be shown to other users. That seems like a product decision, rather than an inevitability.

As an aside, I don't like this feature and have not opted into it because I actually dislike interoperability. If there was a hypothetical way to get Twitter DM / IG Direct / Messenger / iMessages all in one unified inbox, I would never use it because I actually prefer to keep things in context. My persona and networks on the various platforms are different on purpose, and I like to keep it that way.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by cartoonworld on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @09:24PM (#27767587)
>it isn't clear to me why a unified messaging experience means that your real name will now be shown to other users. That seems like a product decision, rather than an inevitability.

They've probably noticed that Instagram has more marketshare with younger audiences and better engagement, where Facebook is full of your grandma and "old people".

If they can slowly boil the frog and make them the same, they have a much stronger grip. Its better to ask for forgiveness than for permission.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by spicybright on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @03:06PM (#27764676)
Ditto with this. If my reddit account and SMS messages every intermixed, I would be a very very unhappy camper lol
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by SheinhardtWigCo on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @08:39PM (#27767348)
Same. As a Facebook skeptic and EFF donor, I think this article is unhelpful because it tries to portray user choice as something bad just because Facebook is involved. It totally misses that most software platforms do not allow users to opt-out of massive UI/UX changes and the world could be better if they did.

When there are countless legitimate criticisms to make regarding Facebook, an institution as influential as EFF coming out with something this weak actually hurts the cause.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by catcher on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @01:17PM (#27763489)
It seems like Facebook is trying to prevent anti-trust regulatory action by making it harder to split up / distinguish its core products. Although I’m unsure of how effective that would be.
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by mrkramer on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @01:27PM (#27763619)
Zuck already merged Facebook's and Instagram's database so good luck splitting them.

I hope free market economy prevails or in another words lawsuits fail. They should've learnt their lesson with Microsoft(antitrust is waste of taxpayers' money).

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by zahllos on Thursday July 08, 2021 @02:33AM (#27768983)
The Microsoft antitrust thing was about bundling Internet Explorer in Windows, and also Microsoft's Java VM. The argument from Microsoft was that these two components constituted essential parts of Windows (to that end internet explorer became a web view control in Windows) and so couldn't be removed. In practice this hurt competition from other browser vendors and from Sun.

20 years on, Internet Explorer is dead and Microsoft Edge uses Blink (the same engine as Chrome). Firefox is the only other browser with a distinct rendering engine.

Microsoft's Java VM also died. It was removed in XP SP2 and Microsoft no longer distribute, even via MSDN, versions of Windows that shipped with it. You could argue these events lead directly to the creation of .net since Microsoft's original plan was to jump on the Java train.

So it worked, or at least certainly shaped those various markets.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by croes on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:35PM (#27764346)
That thing in your pocket you use to browse the web and make phone calls is a computer too, so Windows isn't the dominating operating system. And IE isn't the number one browser anymore, so this worked out.
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by mrkramer on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @03:04PM (#27764660)
I was alluding to PC operating system industry but whatever. Yea it worked out really well Microsoft is only worth $2 trillion.

And try to work from home or remote work on your smartphone and not on your PC or laptop and tell me how productive you are. Or try to get any serious task done on smartphone except taking photos, browsing the web and writing notes.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by stale2002 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @10:17PM (#27767864)
> Yea it worked out really well

It did, actually. Microsoft was not able to engage in as many unfair anti-competitive practices in the browser space, and partially because of that, there was a increase in browser competition.

Preventing microsoft from locking the world in to its browser, with illegal and anti-competitive practices, caused lots of better browsers to be developed.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by cycomanic on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:00PM (#27763983)
Standard oil? Antitrust is only a waste of taxpayers' money if there's no real willingness to go after the offenders.
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by mrkramer on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:05PM (#27764045)
What happened to Microsoft? Microsoft still controls 70-90% market share of computer operating system industry. Amazon, Google, Facebook and Apple achieved dominant market position through legal and fair market competition.
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by jdminhbg on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @07:48PM (#27767065)
> Microsoft still controls 70-90% market share of computer operating system industry.

Definitely not, unless you are defining computer in a way that only includes computer form factors that existed in the 90s and also excludes server computers.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by _jal on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @08:43PM (#27767372)
That isn't how antitrust works. In the US, having a monopoly is not a crime; abusing a monopoly is. The consent decree had very specific goals and requirements, you can go read about it at Wikipedia. But none of them were about shrinking their market share.

The European EC decision was different, but also was not targeting market share.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by throwaway3699 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:15PM (#27764147)
People stopped caring about Windows being dominant years ago. Mac and Linux became competitive for those who wanted it, mobile ate the world, and Windows only dominates in Office and gaming, neither of which are apparently worth fighting over.
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by mrkramer on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:51PM (#27764518)
>Windows only dominates in Office and gaming, neither of which are apparently worth fighting over.

Everyone and everything is worth fighting over.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by throwaway3699 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @05:27PM (#27765904)
Agree personally, I just mean the general population doesn't care anymore.
Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by munk-a on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:21PM (#27764210)
I think that's less an indictment of anti-trust lawsuits being effective and more of an indictment of either a lack of knowledge or willful ignorance around how connected the economy was becoming via computers.

Microsoft, Amazon, Google and Facebook are all companies that are beyond a reasonable scale - there are far too many eggs in those baskets for long term economic health. Those companies are making GD, Raytheon and Lockheed look like kids playing in a sandbox.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by mrkramer on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:26PM (#27764265)
>Those companies are making GD, Raytheon and Lockheed look like kids playing in a sandbox.

Maybe because >Microsoft, Amazon, Google and Facebook are extremely useful consumer technology companies. I don't know about you but I won't be buying fighter aircraft anytime soon.

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by munk-a on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:33PM (#27764327)
Boeing gets about 28.6 Billion from the US government each year[1] given the US population of around 400 million you're giving them (if we spread the cost evenly) about seventy five dollars every year. Once upon a time this was a large sum of money - now-a-days it's probably less than most folks spend on spotify and definitely less folks spend on coffee in a non-pandemic year.

1. https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2020/01/02/ho...

Re:The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020) by advael on Thursday July 08, 2021 @03:56AM (#27769344)
A monopoly of any kind subverts both the free market and democracy, and there is literally no such thing as "wasting taxpayers' money" at the federal level in the US, because the US issues its own currency