News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by StavrosK on Monday July 18, 2011 @08:51AM (#2776061)
What's wrong with just giving people who cheated a bad grade, rather than wasting hours talking to them?
Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by spne on Monday July 18, 2011 @03:43PM (#2777873)
One (not uncommon) scenario is when two identical (or high match) assignments are turned in, and the professor does not know if (1) the students collaborated or (2) one student cheated off of the other. Penalizing both students is clearly wrong if one student did the assignment properly without cheating, and the other student copied the first student's work.

How can the professor determine which student cheated (or if both students cheated), without spending substantially time looking into it and talking to both students?

Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by effigies on Monday July 18, 2011 @08:39PM (#2779079)
> Penalizing both students is clearly wrong if one student did the assignment properly without cheating, and the other student copied the first student's work.

I had a professor who would actually give the person who did the work the worse grade, under the justification that you can never get rid of demand, but you could discourage supply. I thought it was a pretty clever solution. If I'd worked my ass off and somebody copying me got a 50% where I got a 0%, I'd be much more careful about what I shared.

Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by tyree732 on Monday July 18, 2011 @05:17PM (#2778301)
> (2) one student cheated off of the other

You might believe that it's morally wrong to penalize the person who did the work, but I would have to disagree with you. Both Cheating and giving others the ability to cheat undermine the credibility of an institution and harm the legitimate efforts of others.

Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by rimmjob on Monday July 18, 2011 @07:43PM (#2778905)
not really. people who do the work are usually pressured to share it, and are ostracized if they don't. I don't really think its fair to punish a victim unless there's some kind of evidence that they played a more insidious role.
Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by skeltoac on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @12:01AM (#2779561)
Neither student is a victim in the scenario you give. Peer pressure does not make one conspirator innocent.
Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by eropple on Monday July 18, 2011 @11:32AM (#2776670)
They will whine. Endlessly.

Then again, they'll do that anyway.

Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by ori_b on Monday July 18, 2011 @12:14PM (#2776860)
So give them a chance to appeal.
Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by eropple on Monday July 18, 2011 @01:26PM (#2777180)
Sure. What I mean is, they'll whine to you anyway, trying to get around the system. And, practically, refusing to talk to them is difficult-to-impossible.
Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by ori_b on Monday July 18, 2011 @06:23PM (#2778589)
I'm not sure that it should be the professor's job to handle appeals. It should be the same sort of process that schools use to handle appeals for missed tests and work.

You miss a test, you get a zero. You go to the office of the dean with a note or explanation, get them to sign off that you should be allowed to retake, reweight, or whatever else it is that is needed, and then you go to the professor to deal with it.

The same sort of process should probably be put in place for plagarism. The professor flags you, and if you want to appeal, you go to the dean's office, they review the possibly-plagarized paper, and if they feel that the professor was in error, or that the student deserves the benefit of the doubt, they allow some sort of corrective action.

Re:Why I will never pursue cheating again by eropple on Tuesday July 19, 2011 @11:59AM (#2781453)
It shouldn't be their job at all, I agree, but the practical consideration is that they'll have a line of complaining students in their office that they can't exactly get rid of.