News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by slownews45 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @07:19PM (#27755577)
Is there any option for folks to do an "I accept all cookies but reserve right to manage them myself" setting - and then skip all the popups? In other words, the site can set what it wants, and I can delete what I want?

I really don't need more setting options tweaks etc. How many people do this carefully on each site? How many are annoyed by this STUPID pop up game that means almost nothing.

Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by anyfoo on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @07:51PM (#27755814)
I carefully turn them all off. I'd much rather have a setting that says "I don't want to participate in your bullshit". We tried such a thing as "Do Not Track", but companies weren't playing along. So now we have to have this regulation, and you should be upset at the companies who necessitated that regulation, not at the people who are doing their best to keep it being a choice.
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by etripe on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @03:55AM (#27758524)
The GDPR is explicit about that: non-functional stuff should be turned off by default. No, marketing isn't functional. If companies follow the law, the default is set at "I don't want to participate in your bullshit".

It's just that a lot of companies are employing dark patterns or getting it wrong on purpose, and it's working because people are now annoyed at GDPR instead of the companies doing this.

Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by anyfoo on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @12:30PM (#27762955)
Yes, and it's ultimately sad to me, although not terribly surprising, that people are getting annoyed at the legislation instead of the perpetrators.
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by peder on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @08:33PM (#27756067)
I really want a browser flag like "I DO NOT CARE ABOUT TRACKING" that auto-accepts.
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by WA on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @03:18AM (#27758304)
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by slownews45 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @12:10AM (#27757266)
Exactly. I just blow away all cookies but a few selected sites periodically.

There are people carefully going through the deep menus that supposedly turn something off. Why not just control yourself, blow them away if you care.

But key is - I want to ACCEPT all cookies in return for not being asked at all. If I care about tracking many other solutions I can use.

Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by tobr on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @01:44AM (#27757820)
Cookies, OK. But there are other forms of tracking that you can’t undo on your end.
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by XCSme on Sunday July 18, 2021 @04:00PM (#27876135)
But you can already delete specific cookies from the browser, or you are referring to deleting some other data?
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by SimeVidas on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @07:57PM (#27755856)
There is only an option to reject all cookies via GPC https://globalprivacycontrol.org/. Some sites have started to respect it.
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by slownews45 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @12:12AM (#27757274)
Is there an accept all cookies version of this?

Reject all is pointless. You can do it in browser already. You need cookies to hold a login session - folks who try to get websites to block cookies - it doesn't make sense and isn't what most folks want (I need login, shopping cart etc).

Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by jlokier on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:03AM (#27757910)
There is a crucial difference between login session cookies and personal tracking cookies for ads.

You don't even need consent for login session cookies, provided that is all they are used for. Because the user is already asking the site to remember who they are. Similarly for a shopping cart, as the user is asking the site to remember selected items.

"Reject all for privacy" is about rejecting personal tracking cookies for ads, usually while keeping essential login and shopping cart cookies.

Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by slownews45 on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @01:25PM (#27763593)
Please note that some (many) people don't care - they don't want these browser pop-ups, they understand that cookies aren't the only way profiles are built etc etc.

The problem is the zealots here are souring generations on actual user control of data by endlessly requiring more and more notices and popups. Don't annoy 95% of users so some random subgroup can feel smug about themselves.

It seems every CA company now sends me - via PAPER MAIL - a privacy notice of privacy practices. I DON'T CARE. There are no teeth in any of this. Even if there were people don't care.

Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by jlokier on Saturday July 10, 2021 @01:01PM (#27794804)
The people who want more privacy - including zealots - also don't want the notices, popups, options, etc.

It's a mistake to think privacy zealots are requiring all those things. They are not; they don't want them. And so they are not to blame for them.

They do want to be able to find out what commitments a company is binding itself to, to be able to hold the company accountable under the law, which acts to curtail some abuses, but even that would be much preferred in the form of statutury commitments that could be assumed by default everywhere, the same way consumer protection law works.

Those endless annoyances are the result of companies that are actively hostile to users who value privacy and to statutory privacy policies in general. So companies make the popups, in particular, intrusive and often difficult to reject properly. Sometimes they outright lie about the GDPR requiring some heavy duty options lists.

I say companies. Usually the worst popups on a site are not from a site's own company, they are from third party surveillance-based advertising services or similar used by the company. Naturally, those third parties are the ones most actively hostile to a privacy oriented society, and on an individual level, most interested in persuading or tricking someone into accepting the tracking.

With regards to CA privacy notices: Imagine how refreshing it would be if it was like consumer protection law protecting you when buying things mail order and against false advertising and faulty products. You wouldn't need to receive a privacy policy at all, because there would be a statutory privacy policy you could always assume and all companies adhered to it. Perhaps you would be able to opt out of privacy explicitly, but you always had the option to take the service without opting out of the statutory privacy policy if you wanted.

Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by SimeVidas on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @01:09AM (#27757610)
> Reject all is pointless. You can do it in browser already.

No, you can’t. You can block cookies. GPC enables the ”I reject” signal, so websites that honor GPC don’t have to ask you (i.e., no cookie banner)..

Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by dmitriid on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:45AM (#27758115)
"Do Not Track" header was used to track users, and removed. GPC will be used to do the same.
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by SimeVidas on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @03:51AM (#27758498)
Any HTTP header can be used to build a fingerprint. Should we remove HTTP headers because of that? No.
Re:Defeating Cookie Banners by Sephr on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @11:21PM (#27756984)
Note that our consent manager integrates with and respects GPC signals.