News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Student designs device that stops blood loss from stab wo... by giantg2 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @12:35PM (#27750811)
I think there's a serious misunderstanding about definitions. This study is looking at fatalities. Justifiable homicide is not the only thing included in the estimates of defensive gun use. In fact, the claim is that most defensive gun use does not involve shots being fired.

I see that you are just posting more studies that support your own view. Do you have anything that refutes the CDC's findings posted earlier?

I also stated two different concerns with studies from your Harvard links. Would you care to address those, or continue ignoring valid conversation?

You ask why old data should be called into question. It is well known that violent crime rates have been falling for decades. This could drastically affect the number of people being threatened and the number of people using a gun defensively. Also, a number of prior restrictions on the carrying of firearms have been reduced in many states. If you have more people with the ability/access to use a firearm, that could also affect both sides of the equation. Yes, I do see one study in that list from 2015. I wonder why that one conflicts with the CDC's finding.

I believe there have been peer reviewed and published studies by Kleck and Lott that you can look up if you are truly interested. I'm sure these can be questioned along the same lines as the other comments concerning the author of those other studies and Bloomberg money. American Homicide is supposed to be a good read too.

The main issue with just regurgitating studies like this is that studies can be misinterpreted and misapplied. The way the study is designed can make it a valid study, but at the same time it can limit the scope. Then we end up comparing defensive gun use to justifiable homicide, which are not the same thing.

There are no comments on this comment yet.