Re:“I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases...
by pjmlp on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @06:18AM
(#27746332)
Nope, you are missing the whole picture in order to frame your argumentation.
Several Google contributions were taken, just not 100%.
One notable contribution was cleaning up the kernel from all VLAs, the fortifications of several modules, some cleaning outcomes from clang compilation support.
Or the ongoing efforts to allow Rust drivers.
With Sony there were 0%.
Re:“I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases...
by trasz on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @11:57AM
(#27750244)
Nope, you are missing the whole picture :-)
You're stopping your reasoning at the numbers: some contributions from Google, none from Sony. (At this step you're also ignoring contributions to FreeBSD from companies that do contribute back, but whatever.) The big picture would be understanding why GPL wouldn't affect that situation.
Re:“I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases...
by elevader on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @05:50AM
(#27746132)
I feel like this isn't really framing the issue fairly. The issue isn't that Sony couldn't use GPL code, there is no law preventing them from doing so, they just choose not to (for a variety of reasons, I'd imagine). Just as the could contribute to FreeBSD but choose not to.
And OS developers have the choice to prevent Sony (or some other company) from essentially using free labor to make money without any obligation on their side.
Re:“I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases...
by trasz on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @11:54AM
(#27750193)
Nothing in GPL prevents Sony from using free labor; most of the companies using Linux do precisely that.
Re:“I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases...
by elevader on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @01:49PM
(#27751932)
Of course, but they can't just copy&paste their favorite files from the linux kernel sources and call it FancyOs without releasing the sources to that.
I think you got my point, I don't really see the benefit in arguing semantics.
Re:“I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases...
by trasz on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @04:31AM
(#27758756)
It’s not about semantics - it’s about demonstrating that Sony using someone’s sources doesn’t hurt that someone, and trying force them to give away their changes with license doesn’t work.
With Android, Google wanted to give their changes back, so they were able to use GPL-ed code. They would give the changes back without GPL too. You can see that with non-GPL-ed projects they contribute to.